Chao-Hsi Chang

Feynman Integrals of Grassmannians

We embed Feynman integrals in the subvarieties of Grassmannians through homogenization of the integrands in projective space, then obtain GKZ-systems satisfied by those scalar integrals. The Feynman integral can be written as linear combinations of the hypergeometric functions of a fundamental solution system in neighborhoods of regular singularities of the GKZ-system, whose linear combination coefficients are determined by the integral on an ordinary point or some regular singularities. Taking some Feynman diagrams as examples, we elucidate in detail how to obtain the fundamental solution systems of Feynman integrals in neighborhoods of regular singularities. Furthermore we also present the parametric representations of Feynman integrals of the 2-loop self-energy diagrams which are convenient to embed in the subvarieties of Grassmannians.

Fragmentation functions for gluon into $B_c$ or $B_c^*$ meson

In the paper, we calculate the fragmentation functions for $g \to B_c$ and $g \to B_c^*$ . The ultraviolet divergences in the calculation are removed through the renormalization of the operator definition of the fragmentation functions under the modified minimal subtraction scheme. We then obtain the fragmentation functions $D_{g \to B_c}(z,μ_F)$ and $D_{g \to B_c^*}(z,μ_F)$ , which are presented as figures and fitting functions. The obtained fragmentation functions are complementary to the previous work on the next-to-leading order fragmentation functions for $\bar{b}\to B_c(B_c^*)$ and $c\to B_c(B_c^*)$ .

Nuclear $0\nu2β$ decays in $B-L$ symmetric SUSY model and in TeV scale left-right symmetric model

In this paper we take B-L supersymmetric standard model (B-LSSM) and TeV scale left-right symmetric model (LRSM) as two representations of the two kinds of new physics models to study the nuclear neutrinoless double beta decays ( $0\nu2β$ ) so as to see the senses onto these two kinds of models when the decays are taken into account additionally. Within the parameter spaces allowed by all the exist experimental data, the decay half-life of the nucleus $^{76}$ Ge and $^{136}$ Xe, $T^{0ν}_{1/2}$ ( $^{76}$ Ge, $^{136}$ Xe), is precisely calculated and the results are presented properly. Based on the numerical results, we conclude that the room of LRSM type models for the foreseeable future experimental observations on the decays is greater than that of B-LSSM type models.

The mass spectrum and wave functions of the $B_c$ system

The spectrum and relativistic wave functions of $B_c$ system are investigated via solving the complete Salpeter equation. Emphases are put on the study of the partial waves of each $J^P$ state. Our study shows that there are three categories of $J^P$ states. The first category contains $0^-$ and $0^+$ states, which are ${}^1S_0$ dominant state with a small amount of $P$ wave and ${}^3P_0$ dominant state with a small amount of $S$ wave, respectively. The second category includes the natural parity states, such as $1^-$ , $2^+$ , $3^-$ , etc. Taking the $1^-$ state as an example, we study it in two cases. One is the ${}^3S_1$ dominant state with a small amount of $P$ and $D$ waves, and the other is the ${}^3D_1$ dominant state but contains a large amount of $S$ and $P$ wave components. The third category includes the unnatural parity states, such as $1^+$ , $2^-$ , $3^+$ , etc. For the $1^+$ spectrum, the states are grouped into pairs with different radial quantum numbers. Each pair contains two ${}^1P_1-{}^3P_1$ mixing states, and the corresponding mixing angles are calculated by using the relativistic wave functions.

preprint2021arXiv

Mass spectra, wave functions and mixing effects of the $(bcq)$ baryon

Mass spectra and wave functions of the $J^P=\frac{1}{2}^+$ $(bcq)$ baryons are calculated by the relativistic Bethe-Salpeter equation\,(BSE) with considering the mixing effects between the $1^+$ and $0^+$ $(bc)$ -diquarks inside. Based on the diquark picture, the three-body problem of baryons is transformed into two two-body problems. The BSE and wave functions of the $0^+$ diquark are given, and then solved numerically to obtain the effective mass spectra and form factors. Also we present the wave functions at zero point for the $(bc)$ -diquark. Considering the obtained diquark form factors, the $(bcq)$ baryons are then described by the BSE as the bound state of a diquark and a light quark, where the interaction kernel includes the inner transitions between the $0^+$ and $1^+$ diquarks. The general wave function of the $\frac{1}{2}^+$ $(bcq)$ baryons is constructed and solved to obtain the corresponding mass spectra. Especially, by using the obtained wave functions, the mixing effects between $Ξ_{bc}(Ω_{bc})$ and $Ξ_{bc}'(Ω'_{bc})$ in ground states are computed and determined to be small ( $\sim \!1\%$ ). The numerical results indicate that it is a good choice to take $Ξ_{bc}$ and $Ξ'_{bc}$ as the baryon states with the inside $(bc)$ -diquarks occupying the definite spin.

GKZ-hypergeometric systems for Feynman integrals

Basing on the systems of linear partial differential equations derived from Mellin-Barnes representations and Miller's transformation, we obtain GKZ-hypergeometric systems of one-loop self energy, one-loop triangle, two-loop vacuum, and two-loop sunset diagrams, respectively. The codimension of derived GKZ-hypergeometric system equals the number of independent dimensionless ratios among the external momentum squared and virtual mass squared. Taking GKZ-hypergeometric systems of one-loop self energy, massless one-loop triangle, and two-loop vacuum diagrams as examples, we present in detail how to perform triangulation and how to construct canonical series solutions in the corresponding convergent regions. The series solutions constructed for these hypergeometric systems recover the well known results in literature.

Next-to-leading order QCD corrections to the production of $B_c$ and $B_c^*$ through $W^+$ -boson decays

In this paper, we calculate the total decay widths for the $W^+$ -boson decays, $W^+ \to B_c+b+\bar{s}+X$ and $W^+ \to B^*_c+b+\bar{s}+X$ , up to next-to-leading order (NLO) accuracy within the framework of the nonrelativistic QCD theory. Both the fixed-order and the fragmentation approaches are adopted to do the calculation. Differential decay widths $dΓ/dz$ and $dΓ/ds_1$ are also given. We find that the NLO corrections are significant in those two $W^+$ decay channels. Our numerical results show that at the LHC, there are about $7.03\times 10^4$ $B_c$ -meson events and $5.10\times 10^4$ $B^*_c$ -meson events to be produced via the $W^+$ -boson decays per operation year.

Recently observed $P_c$ as molecular states and possible mixture of $P_c(4457)$

Recently observed spectrum of $P_c$ states exhibits a strong link to $Σ_c \bar{D}^{(*)}$ thresholds. In spite of successful molecular interpretations, we still push forward to wonder whether there exist finer structures. Utilizing the effecitve lagrangians respecting heavy quark symmetry and chiral symmetry, as well as instantaneous Bethe-Salpeter equations, we investigate the $Σ_c \bar{D}^{(*)}$ interactions and three $P_c$ states. We confirm that $P_c(4312)$ and $P_c(4440)$ are good candidates of $Σ_c \bar{D}$ and $Σ_c \bar{D}^{*}$ molecules with spin- $\frac12$ , respectively. Unlike other molecular calculations, our results indicate $P_c(4457)$ signal might be a mixture of spin- $\frac32$ and spin- $\frac12$ $Σ_c \bar{D}^{*}$ molecules, where the latter one appears to be an excitation of $P_c(4440)$ . Therefore we conclude that, confronting three LHCb $P_c$ signals, there may exist not three, but four molecular states.

The complete study on polarization of $Υ(nS)$ hadroproduction at QCD next-to-leading order

Applying the nonrelativistic quantum chromodynamics factorization formalism to the $Υ(1S,2S,3S)$ hadroproduction, a complete analysis on the polarization parameters $λ_θ$ , $λ_{θϕ}$ , $λ_ϕ$ for the production are presented at QCD next-to-leading order. With the long-distance matrix elements extracted from experimental data for the production rate and polarization parameter $λ_θ$ of $Υ$ hadroproduction, our results provide a good description for the measured parameters $λ_{θϕ}$ and $λ_ϕ$ in both the helicity and the Collins-Soper frames. In our calculations the frame invariant parameter $\tildeλ$ is consistent in the two frames. Finally, it is pointed out that there are discrepancies for $\tildeλ$ between available experimental data and corresponding theoretical predictions.

preprint2019arXiv

A proposal on complementary determination of the electro-weak mixing angles ${\rm sin^2θ_W}$ at a super Z-factory

A proposal on determination of the effective electro-weak mixing angle ${\rm sin^2θ_{eff}^f\;(f=c,b)}$ at a super Z-factory (an $e^+e^-$ collider designed with the possible highest luminosity and running around the center mass energy $\sqrt s=m_Z$ ) is proposed. It is to determine how the effective mixing angles depend on the flavors, especially the flavors $c$ , $b$ (with the determined effective ones, the electro-weak mixing angles ${\rm sin^2θ_W^f\;(f=c,b)}$ of Standard Model can be derived out precisely). The key point of the proposal is that at such a super Z-factory, via measuring the forward-backward ( $A_{FB}$ ), left-right ( $A_{LR}$ ) and combined left-right forward-backward ( $A^{FB}_{LR}$ ) asymmetries of the produced doubly heavy-flavored hadrons (such as $B_c$ , $B_c^*$ and the baryons $H_{QQ'q}$ : $Ξ_{cc}$ , $Ξ_{bc}$ and $Ξ_{bb}$ etc) in the relevant production processes $e^+e^-\to B_c+\cdots$ and $e^+e^-\to H_{QQ'q}+\cdots$ one may complement the final determination of the mixing angle ${\rm sin^2θ_W^f\;(f=c,b)}$ of Standard Model. The advantage of the proposed way to determine the effective electro-weak mixing angles is that the doubly heavy flavor(s) and the out-going direction of the produced doubly-heavy hadron can be experimental determined precisely, i.e. there are no such errors caused by missing identification of the heavy flavor(s) and by determining the so-called thrust axis of the produced jets, which can not be avoided in the early determination at LEP-I and SLC.

preprint2019arXiv

The QCD NLO fragmentation functions for $c$ or $\bar{b}$ quark to $B_c$ or $B_c^*$ meson and their application

The fragmentation functions for $c$ or $\bar{b}$ quark to $B_c$ or $B_c^*$ meson are derived up to QCD next-to-leading order (NLO). They are further computed numerically and presented in figures precisely. In order to reach a higher accuracy, we have also tried properly to apply them to estimating the $B_c$ and $B_c^*$ production at a $Z$ -factory (an $e^+e^-$ collider running at the energy of the $Z$ -boson pole).

BCVEGPY2.2: A Newly Upgraded Version for Hadronic Production of the Meson $B_c$ and Its Excited States

A newly upgraded version of the BCVEGPY, a generator for hadronic production of the meson $B_c$ and its excited states, is available. In comparison with the previous one [C.H. Chang, J.X. Wang and X.G. Wu, Comput. Phys. Commun. {\bf 175}, 624 (2006)], the new version is to apply an improved hit-and-miss technology to generating the un-weighted events much more efficiently under various simulation environments. The codes for production of $2S$ -wave $B_c$ states are also given here.

Production of doubly heavy-flavored hadrons at $e^+e^-$ colliders

Production of the doubly heavy-flavored hadrons ( $B_c$ meson, doubly heavy baryons $Ξ_{cc}$ , $Ξ_{bc}$ , $Ξ_{bb}$ , their excited states and antiparticles of them as well) at $e^+e^-$ colliders is investigated under two different approaches: $LO$ (leading order QCD complete calculation) and $LL$ (leading logarithm fragmentation calculation). The results for the production obtained by the approaches $LO$ and $LL$ , including the angle distributions of the produced hadrons with unpolarized and polarized incoming beams, the behaviors on the energy fraction of the produced doubly heavy hadron and comparisons between the two approaches' results, are presented in terms of tables and figures. Thus characteristics of the production and uncertainties of the approaches are shown precisely, and it is concluded that only if the colliders run at the eneries around $Z$ -pole (which may be called as $Z$ -factories) and additionally the luminosity of the colliders is as high as possible then to study the doubly heavy hadrons thoroughly is accessible.

Some of semileptonic and nonleptonic decays of $B_c$ meson in a Bethe-Salpeter relativistic quark model

The semileptonic decays $B_c^+\rightarrow P(V) +\ell^++\barν_\ell$ and the nonleptonic decays $B_c^+\rightarrow P(V)+L$ , where $P(V)$ denotes a pseudoscalar (vector) charmonium or ( $\bar{b}s$ )-meson, and $L$ denotes a light meson, are studied in the framework of improved instantaneous Bethe-Salpeter (BS) equation and the Mandelstam formula. The numerical results (width and branching ratio of the decays) are presented in tables, and in order to compare conveniently, those obtained by other approaches are also put in the relevant tables. Based on the fact that the ratio $\frac{\mathcal{BR}(B_c^+\rightarrowψ(2S)π^+)}{\mathcal{BR}(B_c^+\rightarrow J/ψπ^+)}=0.24^{+0.023}_{-0.040}$ estimated here is in good agreement with the observation by the LHCb $\frac{\mathcal{BR}(B_c^+\rightarrow ψ(2S)π^+)}{\mathcal{BR}(B_c^+\rightarrow J/ψπ^+)}=0.250\pm0.068(\mathrm{stat})\pm0.014(\mathrm{syst})\pm0.006(\mathcal{B})$ , one may conclude that with respect to the decays the present framework works quite well.

Suggestion for measuring the weak dipole moment of $τ$ lepton at Z-factory

Three new observables for Z-factory to measure the weak dipole moment of $τ$ lepton ( $d_w^τ$ ) are proposed. As those observables employed at LEP-I, the new observables depend on the real and imaginary parts of $d_w^τ$ linearly, thus we calculate the slopes, i.e. the linear coefficients of the dependence, precisely and find that the obtained slopes are much lager than those employed at LEP-I. It means that the signal for the weak dipole moment $d_w^τ$ may be enhanced quite a lot, if one employs the new observables. Being superior to those at LEP-I, we recommend measuring the weak dipole moment $d_w^τ$ in terms of the new observables if re-analyzing the data of LEP-I or doing the measurement at a possible Z-factory in the near future.

preprint2014arXiv

Neutrino Production via $e^-e^+$ Collision at $Z$ -boson Peak

The production of the three normal neutrinos via $e^-e+$ collision at $Z$ -boson peak (neutrino production in a Z-factory) is investigated thoroughly. The differences of $ν_e$ -pair production from $ν_μ$ -pair and $ν_τ$ -pair production are presented in various aspects. Namely the total cross sections, relevant differential cross sections and the forward-backward asymmetry etc for these neutrinos are presented in terms of figures as well as numerical tables. The restriction on the room for the mixing of the three species of light neutrinos with possible externals (heavy neutral leptons and/or stereos) from refined measurements of the invisible width of $Z$ -boson is discussed.

preprint2014arXiv

Spontaneous R-parity violation in the minimal gauged $(B-L)$ supersymmetry with a $125\;{\rm GeV}$ Higgs

We precisely derive the mass squared matrices for charged and neutral (CP-odd and CP-even) Higgs, as well as the mass matrices for neutrino-neutralino and charged lepton-chargino in the minimal R-parity violating supersymmetry with local $U(1)_{B-L}$ symmetry. In the framework the nonzero TeV scale vacuum expectations of right-handed sneutrinos induce the heavy mass of neutral $U(1)_{B-L}$ gauge boson, and result in relatively large mixing between the lightest CP-even Higgs and three generation right-handed sneutrinos when we include the one-loop corrections to the scalar potential. We numerically show that there is parameter space of the considered model to accommodate experimental data on the newly ones of Higgs signal from LHC and experimental observations on the neutrino oscillation simultaneously.

preprint2012arXiv

The $B_c$ Decays to $P$ -wave Charmonium by Improved Bethe-Salpeter Approach

We re-calculate the exclusive semileptonic and nonleptonic decays of $B_c$ meson to a $P$ -wave charmonium in terms of the improved Bethe-Salpeter (B-S) approach, which is developed recently. Here the widths for the exclusive semileptonic and nonleptonic decays, the form factors, and the charged lepton spectrums for the semileptonic decays are precisely calculated. To test the concerned approach by comparing with experimental measurements when the experimental data are available, and to have comparisons with the other approaches the results obtained by the approach and those by some approaches else as well as the original B-S approach, which appeared in literature, are comparatively presented and discussed.

preprint2010arXiv

Production of a Heavy Quarkonium with a Photon or via ISR at $Z$ Peak in $e^+e^-$ Collider

Considering the possibility to build an $e^+e^-$ collider at the energies around $Z$ -boson resonance with a luminosity so high as ${\cal L} \propto 10^{34}cm^{-2}s^{-1}$ (even higher) and the abilities of a modern synthesis detector, we systematically calculate the exclusive two body processes: $e^+e^-$ annihilates into a heavy quarkonium and a photon (initiate state radiation i.e. ISR is involved), at the energies around the $Z$ -boson resonance. Since the couplings of $Z$ -boson to quarks contain axial vector as well as vector, so here the produced heavy quarkonium may stand for a charmonium such as ${J/ψ,η_c,h_c,χ_{cJ}}\cdots$ and a bottomonium such as ${Υ,η_b,h_b,χ_{bJ}}\cdots$ respectively. If we call such a collider with so high luminosity and running around the $Z$ -boson resonance as a $Z$ -factory, then our results obtained here indicate that experimental studies at a $Z$ -factory about the various heavy quarkona (their ground and excited states) via the two-body processes, especially, the production of the bound states with quantum number $J^{PC}=1^{--}$ via ISR, have outstanding advantages.

preprint2010arXiv

Spectrum for Heavy Quankonia and Mixture of the Relevant Wave Functions within the Framework of Bethe-Salpeter Equation

Considering the fact that some excited states of the heavy quarkonia (charmonium and bottomonium) still missing in experimental observations and potential applications of the relevant wave functions of the bound states, we re-analyze the spectrum and the relevant wave functions of the heavy quarkonia within the framework of Bethe-Salpeter (B.S.) equation with a proper QCD-inspired kernel. Such a kernel for the heavy quarkonia, relating to potential of non-relativistic quark model, is instantaneous, so we call the corresponding B.S. equation as BS-In equation throughout the paper. Particularly, a new way to solve the B.S. equation, which is different from the traditional ones, is proposed here, and with it not only the known spectrum for the heavy quarkonia is re-generated, but also an important issue is brought in, i.e., the obtained solutions of the equation `automatically' include the 'fine', 'hyperfine' splittings and the wave function mixture, such as $S-D$ wave mixing in $J^{PC}=1^{--}$ states, $P-F$ wave mixing in $J^{PC}=2^{++}$ states for charmonium and bottomonium etc. It is pointed out that the best place to test the wave mixture probably is at $Z$ -factory ( $e^+e^-$ collider running at $Z$ -boson pole with extremely high luminosity).

preprint2010arXiv

The magnetic dipole transitions in the $(c\bar{b})$ binding system

The magnetic dipole transitions between the vector mesons $B_c^*$ and their relevant pseudoscalar mesons $B_c$ ( $B_c$ , $B_c^*$ , $B_c(2S)$ , $B_c^*(2S)$ , $B_c(3S)$ and $B_c^*(3S)$ etc, the binding states of $(c\bar{b})$ system) of the $B_c$ family are interesting. To see the `hyperfine' splitting due to spin-spin interaction is an important topic for understanding the spin-spin interaction and the spectrum of the the $(c\bar{b})$ binding system. The knowledge about the magnetic dipole transitions is also very useful for identifying the vector boson $B_c^*$ mesons experimentally, whose masses are just slightly above the masses of their relevant pseudoscalar mesons $B_c$ accordingly. Considering the possibility to observe the vector mesons via the transitions at $Z^0$ factory and the potentially usages of the theoretical estimate on the transitions, we fucus our efforts on calculating the magnetic dipole transitions, i.e. precisely to calculate the rates for the transitions such as decays $B_c^*\to B_cγ$ and $B_c^*\to B_c e^+e^-$ , and particularly work in the Behte-Salpeter framework. In the estimate, as a typical example, we carefully investigate the dependance of the rate $Γ(B_c^*\to B_cγ)$ on the mass difference $ΔM=M_{B_c^*}-M_{B_c}$ as well.

preprint2009arXiv

GENXICC2.0: An Upgraded Version of the Generator for Hadronic Production of Double Heavy Baryons $Ξ_{cc}$ , $Ξ_{bc}$ and $Ξ_{bb}$

An upgraded (second) version of the package GENXICC ({\bf A Generator for Hadronic Production of the Double Heavy Baryons $Ξ_{cc}$ , $Ξ_{bc}$ and $Ξ_{bb}$ by C.H. Chang, J.X. Wang and X.G. Wu,} [its first version: in Comput. Phys. Commun. {\bf 177} (2007) 467-478]) is presented. Users, with this version being implemented in PYTHIA and a GNU C compiler, may simulate full events of the production in various experimental environments conveniently. In comparison with the previous version, in order to implement it in PYTHIA properly, a subprogram for the fragmentation of the produced double heavy diquark to the relevant baryon is complemented and the interphase of the generator to PYTHIA is changed accordingly. In the subprogram, with explanation, certain necessary assumptions (approximations) are made so as to conserve the momenta and the QCD `color' flow for the fragmentation.

preprint2007arXiv

Hadronic Production of the Doubly Charmed Baryon $Ξ_{cc}$ with Intrinsic Charm

The effects of the intrinsic charm on the hadronic production of $Ξ_{cc}$ are studied. By taking reasonable intrinsic charm component into account, the change of the theoretical prediction on the production of $Ξ_{cc}$ for LHC and Tevatron is small, but in contrast it may enhance significantly for SELEX. The reason is that the collision energy at LHC and Tevatron is so large that the gluon-gluon fusion sub-process, which is irrelevant to intrinsic charm, becomes dominant. But the situation for SELEX is quite different. Our numerical results for SELEX show that by considering all the contributions from various sub-processes, the predicted cross-section may be enhanced by a factor so big as $10^2$ due to a modulating intrinsic charm being taken into account. Therefore, the hadronic production of $Ξ_{cc}$ at SELEX may be sensitive enough in observing the intrinsic charm inside the incident hadrons.

preprint2006arXiv

Hadronic production of the heavy gauge bosons ( $Z_{H}$ , $B_{H}$ , $W_{H}^{\pm}$ ) associated with one QCD jet

This paper has been withdrawn by the author, due some mistakes in this paper.

preprint2005arXiv

Production and decay of the meson $B_c$

Studies on the decay and production of $B_c (B^*_c)$ meson are briefly reviewed. Considering RUN-II of Tevatron and the schedule of LHC, the theoretical studies of $B_c$ meson will jump to a new stage not only for itself but also to implement the studies of the heavy quarkonia etc.

Hadronic production of the $P$ -wave excited $B_c$ -states ( $B_{cJ,L=1}^*$ )

Adopting the complete $α_s^4$ approach of the perturbative QCD (pQCD) and updated parton distribution functions, we have estimated the hadronic production of $P$ -wave excited $B_c$ -states ( $B_{cJ,L=1}^*$ ). In the estimate, special care on the relation of the production amplitude to the derivative of wave function at origin of the potential model is payed. For experimental references, main uncertainties are discussed, and the total cross sections and the distributions of the production with reasonable cuts at the energies of Tevatron and LHC are computed and presented. The results show that $P$ -wave production may contribute to the $B_c$ -meson production indirectly by a factor about 0.5 of the direct production, and with such a big cross section, it is worth further to study the possibility to observe the $P$ -wave production itself experimentally.

Instantaneous Bethe-Salpeter Equation and Its Exact Solution

We present an approach to solve a Bethe-Salpeter (BS) equation exactly without any approximation if the kernel of the BS equation exactly is instantaneous, and take positronium as an example to illustrate the general features of the solutions. As a middle stage, a set of coupled and self-consistent integration equations for a few scalar functions can be equivalently derived from the BS equation always, which are solvable accurately. For positronium, precise corrections to those of the Schrödinger equation in order $v$ (relative velocity) in eigenfunctions, in order $v^2$ in eigenvalues, and the possible mixing, such as that between $S$ ( $P$ ) and $D$ ( $F$ ) components in $J^{PC}=1^{--}$ ( $J^{PC}=2^{++}$ ) states as well, are determined quantitatively. Moreover, we also point out that there is a problematic step in the classical derivation which was proposed first by E.E. Salpeter. Finally, we emphasize that for the effective theories (such as NRQED and NRQCD etc) we should pay great attention on the corrections indicated by the exact solutions.

On possible $S$ -wave bound states for a $N \bar N$ system within a constituent quark model

We try to apply a constituent quark model (a variety chiral constituent quark model) and the resonating group approach for the multi-quark problems to compute the effective potential between the $N\bar{N}$ in $S$ -wave (the quarks in the nucleons $N$ and $\bar{N}$ , and the two nucleons relatively as well, are in $S$ wave) so as to see the possibility if there may be a tight bound state of six quarks as indicated by a strong enhancement at threshold of $p\bar{p}$ in $J/ψ$ and B decays. The effective potential which we obtain in terms of the model and approach shows if the experimental enhancement is really caused by a tight $S$ -wave bound state of six quarks, then the quantum number of the bound state is very likely to be $I=1, J^{PC}=0^{-+}$ .

The Instantaneous Bethe-Salpeter Equation and Its Analog: the Breit-like Equation

We take ( $μ^\pm e^\mp$ ) systems and consider the states with quantum number $J^P=0^-$ as examples, to explore the different contents of the instantaneous Bethe-Salpeter (BS) equation and its analog, Breit equation, by solving them exactly. The results show that the two equations are not equivalent, although they are analogous. Furthermore, we point out that the Breit equation contains extra un-physical solutions, so it should be abandoned if one wishes to have an accurate description of the bound states for the instantaneous interacting binding systems.