Researcher profile

J. W. Sulentic

J. W. Sulentic contributes to research discovery and scholarly infrastructure.

ResearcherAffiliation not importedOpen to collaborate

Trust snapshot

Quick read

Trust 21 - Emerging
18works
0followers
3topics
4close collaborators

Actions

Decide how to stay connected

Follow researcher0

Research graph

See the researcher in context

Open full explorer

Inspect adjacent work, topics, institutions and collaborators without jumping out to a separate graph page.

Building this graph slice

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Published work

18 published item(s)

preprint2015arXiv

3C 57 as an Atypical Radio-Loud Quasar: Implications for the Radio-Loud/Radio-Quiet Dichotomy

Lobe-dominated radio-loud (LD RL) quasars occupy a restricted domain in the 4D Eigenvector 1 (4DE1) parameter space which implies restricted geometry/physics/kinematics for this subclass compared to the radio-quiet (RQ) majority of quasars. We discuss how this restricted domain for the LD RL parent population supports the notion for a RQ-RL dichotomy among Type 1 sources. 3C 57 is an atypical RL quasar that shows both uncertain radio morphology and falls in a region of 4DE1 space where RL quasars are rare. We present new radio flux and optical spectroscopic measures designed to verify its atypical optical/UV spectroscopic behaviour and clarify its radio structure. The former data confirms that 3C 57 falls off the 4DE1 quasar "main sequence" with both extreme optical FeII emission (R_{FeII} ~ 1) and a large CIV 1549 profile blueshift (~ -1500 km/s). These parameter values are typical of extreme Population A sources which are almost always RQ. New radio measures show no evidence for flux change over a 50+ year timescale consistent with compact steep-spectrum (CSS or young LD) over core-dominated morphology. In the 4DE1 context where LD RL are usually low L/L_{Edd} quasars we suggest that 3C 57 is an evolved RL quasar (i.e. large Black Hole mass) undergoing a major accretion event leading to a rejuvenation reflected by strong FeII emission, perhaps indicating significant heavy metal enrichment, high bolometric luminosity for a low redshift source and resultant unusually high Eddington ratio giving rise to the atypical CIV 1549.

preprint2015arXiv

Balmer line shifts in quasars

We offer a broad review of Balmer line phenomenology in type 1 active galactic nuclei, briefly sum- marising luminosity and radio loudness effects, and discussing interpretation in terms of nebular physics along the 4D eigenvector 1 sequence of quasars. We stress that relatively rare, peculiar Balmer line profiles (i.e., with large shifts with respect to the rest frame or double and multiple peaked) that start attracted attentions since the 1970s are still passable of multiple dynamical interpretation. More mainstream objects are still not fully understood as well, since competing dynamical models and geometries are possible. Further progress may come from inter-line comparison across the 4D Eigenvector 1 sequence.

preprint2015arXiv

Blue outliers among intermediate redshift quasars

[Oiii]λλ4959,5007 "blue outliers" -- that are suggestive of outflows in the narrow line region of quasars -- appear to be much more common at intermediate z (high luminosity) than at low z. About 40% of quasars in a Hamburg ESO intermediate-z sample of 52 sources qualify as blue outliers (i.e., quasars with [OIII] λλ4959,5007 lines showing large systematic blueshifts with respect to rest frame). We discuss major findings on what has become an intriguing field in active galactic nuclei research and stress the relevance of blue outliers to feedback and host galaxy evolution.

preprint2015arXiv

The most powerful quasar outflows as revealed by the Civ λ1549 resonance line

While quasar outflows may be quasi-ubiquitous, there are significant differences on a source-by- source basis. These differences can be organized along the 4D Eigenvector 1 sequence: at least at low z, with only Population A sources radiating at relatively high Eddington ratio and showing prominent high-velocity outflows in Civ λ1549 line profiles. We discuss in this paper VLT-FORS observations of Civ λ1549 emission line profiles for a high-luminosity sample of Hamburg- ESO quasars and how they are affected by outflow motion as a function of quasar luminosity. Our high- luminosity sample has the notable advantage that the rest frame has been accurately determined from previous VLT-ISAAC observations of Hβ in the J, H, and K bands. This makes measures of inter-line velocity shifts accurate and free of systemic biases. As the redshift increases and the luminosity of the brightest quasars increases, powerful, high-velocity outflows become more frequent. We discuss the outflow contextualisation, fol- lowing the 4DE1 formalism, as a tool for understanding the nature of the so-called weak lined quasars (WLQ) discovered in recent years as a new, poorly understood class of quasars. We estimate the kinetic power associ- ated with Civ λ1549 outflows and suggest that the host galaxies in the most luminous sources likely experience significant feedback.

preprint2014arXiv

A new method to obtain the Broad Line Region size of high redshift quasars

We present high S/N UV spectra for eight quasars at z $\sim$ 3 obtained with VLT/FORS. The spectra enable us to analyze in detail the strong and weak emission features in the rest-frame range 1300-2000 A of each source (Ciii]$λ$1909, Siiii]$λ$1892, Aliii$λ$1860, Siii$λ$1814, Civ$λ$1549 and blended Siiv$λ$1397+Oiv]$λ$1402). Flux ratios Aliii$λ$1860/Siiii]$λ$1892, Civ$λ$1549/Aliii$λ$1860, Siiv$λ$1397+Oiv]$λ$1402/Siiii]$λ$1892 and Siiv$λ$1397+Oiv]$λ$1402/Civ$λ$1549 strongly constrain ionizing photon flux and metallicity through the use of diagnostic maps built from CLOUDY simulations. The radius of the broad line region is then derived from the ionizing photon flux applying the definition of the ionization parameter. The rBLR estimate and the width of a virial component isolated in prominent UV lines yields an estimate of black hole mass. We compare our results with previous estimates obtained from the rBLR - luminosity correlation customarily employed to estimate black hole masses of high redshift quasars.

preprint2014arXiv

Fifty Years of Quasars: Physical Insights and Potential for Cosmology

Last year (2013) was more or less the 50th anniversary of the discovery of quasars. It is an interesting time to review what we know (and don't know) about them both empirically and theoretically. These compact sources involving line emitting plasma show extraordinary luminosities extending to one thousand times that of our Milky Way in emitting volumes of a few solar system diameters (bolometric luminosity log L$_{bol} \sim $ 44-48 [erg s$^{-1}$]: D=1-3 light months $\sim$ $10^3$ - $10^4$ gravitational radii). The advent of 8-10 meter class telescopes enables us to study them spectroscopically in ever greater detail. In 2000 we introduced a 4D Eigenvector 1 parameters space involving optical, UV and X-Ray measures designed to serve as a 4D equivalent of the 2D Hertzsprung-Russell diagram so important for depicting the diversity of stellar types and evolutionary states. This diagram has revealed a principal sequence of quasars distinguished by Eddington ratio (proportional to the accretion rate per unit mass). Thus while stellar differences are primarily driven by the mass of a star, quasar differences are apparently driven by the ratio of luminosity-to-mass. Out of this work has emerged the concept of two quasars populations A and B separated at Eddington ratio around 0.2 which maximizes quasar multispectral differences. The mysterious 8% of quasars that are radio-loud belong to population B which are the lowest accretors with the largest black hole masses. Finally we consider the most extreme population A quasars which are the highest accretors and in some cases are among the youngest quasars. We describe how these sources might be exploited as standard candles for cosmology.

preprint2014arXiv

UV spectral diagnostics for low redshift quasars: estimating physical conditions and radius of the Broad Line Region

The UV spectral range (1100 - 3000 A) contains the strongest resonance lines observed in active galactic nuclei (AGN). Analysis of UV line intensity ratios and profile shapes in quasar spectra provide diagnostics of physical and dynamical conditions in the broad line emitting region. This paper discusses properties of UV lines in type-1 AGN spectra, and how they lead an estimate of ionizing photon flux, chemical abundances, radius of the broad line emitting region and central black hole mass. These estimates are meaningfully contextualised through the 4D "eigenvector-1" (4DE1) formalism.

preprint2013arXiv

Exploring Low Luminosity Quasar Diversity at z ~ 2.5 with the Gran Telescopio Canarias

We present preliminary results from a pencil-beam spectroscopic survey of low-luminosity quasars at z ~ 2.2-2.5. Our goal is to compare these sources with low redshift analogues of similar luminosity. High s/n and moderate resolution spectra were obtained for 15 sources using the faint object spectrograph Osiris on the 10m Gran Telescopio Canarias. The new data make possible an almost unprecedented comparison between sources with the same (moderate) luminosity at widely different cosmic epochs. Preliminary analysis of our spectra confirms the presence of a relatively evolved population of quasars radiating at modest Eddington ratios. A notable difference between the low and high z quasars may involve the presence of lower metallicity quasars at high redshift.

preprint2013arXiv

Low-Ionization Outflows in High Eddington Ratio Quasars

The broad MgII doublet has been much studied in connection with its potentially important role as a virial estimator of black hole mass in high redshift quasars. An important task is therefore identification of any line components likely related to broadening by non-virial motions. High s/n median composite spectra (binned in the &#34;4D eigenvector 1&#34; context of Sulentic et al. 2007) were constructed for the brightest 680 SDSS DR7 quasars in the 0.4 < z < 0.75 range where both MgII 2800 and Hbeta are recorded in the same spectra. Composite spectra representing 90% of the quasars confirm previous findings that FWHM(MgII 2800) is about 20% narrower than FWHM(Hbeta). The situation is clearly different for the most extreme (Population A) sources which are the highest Eddington radiators in the sample. In the median spectra of these sources FWHM MgII 2800 is equal to or greater than FWHM(Hbeta) and shows a significant blueshift relative to Hbeta. We interpret the MgII 2800 blueshift as the signature of a radiation-driven wind or outflow in the highest accreting quasars. In this interpretation the MgII 2800 line width -- affected by blueshifted emission -- is unsuitable for virial mass estimation in ~ 10% of quasars.

preprint2012arXiv

New insights on Stephan&#39;s Quintet: exploring the shock in three dimensions

We carried out IFU optical spectroscopy on three pointings in and near the SQ shock. We used PMAS on the 3.5m Calar Alto telescope to obtain measures of emission lines that provide insight into physical properties of the gas. Severe blending of Hα and [NII]6548,6583A emission lines in many spaxels required the assumption of at least two kinematical components in order to extract fluxes for the individual lines. Main results from our study include: (a) detection of discrete emission features in the new intruder velocity range 5400-6000km/s showing properties consistent with HII regions, (b) detection of a low velocity component spanning the range 5800-6300km/s with properties resembling a solar metallicity shocked gas and (c) detection of a high velocity component at ~6600km/s with properties consistent with those of a low metallicity shocked gas. The two shocked components are interpreted as products of a collision between NGC7318b new intruder and a debris field in its path. This has given rise to a complex structure of ionized gas where several components with different kinematical and physical properties coexist although part of the original ISM associated with NGC7318b is still present and remains unaltered. Our observations suggest that the low velocity ionized component might have existed before the new intruder collision and could be associated with the NW-LV HI component of Williams et al. (2002). The high velocity ionized component might fill the gap between the HI complexes observed in SQ-A and NGC7319&#39;s tidal filament (NW-HV, Arc-N and Arc-S in Williams et al. 2002).

preprint2012arXiv

No Evidence for a Aystematic FEII Emission Line Redshift in Type 1 AGN

We test the recent claim by Hu et al. (2008) that FeII emission in Type 1 AGN shows a systematic redshift relative to the local source rest frame and broad-line Hbeta. We compile high s/n median composites using SDSS spectra from both the Hu et al. sample and our own sample of the 469 brightest DR5 spectra. Our composites are generated in bins of FWHM Hbeta and FeII strength as defined in our 4D Eigenvector 1 (4DE1) formalism. We find no evidence for a systematic FeII redshift and consistency with previous assumptions that FeII shift and width (FWHM) follow Hbeta shift and FWHM in virtually all sources. This result is consistent with the hypothesis that FeII emission (quasi-ubiquitous in type 1 sources) arises from a broad-line region with geometry and kinematics the same as that producing the Balmer lines.

preprint2009arXiv

Comparing Hbeta Line Profiles in the 4D Eigenvector 1 Context

We describe a 4D Eigenvector 1 (4DE1) space that serves as a surrogate H-R diagram for quasars. It provides a context for describing and unifying differences between all broad line AGN. Quasar spectra can be averaged in a non-random way using 4DE1 just as stellar spectra can be averaged non-randomly within the OBAFGKM classification sequence. We find that quasars with FWHM H_beta less than (Population A) and greater than (Population B) 4000 km/s show many significant differences that may point to an actual dichotomy. Broad line profile measures and fits reenforce the idea of a dichotomy because they are fundamentally different: Pop.A - Lorentzian-like and Pop.B - double Gaussian. The differences have implications both for BH mass estimation and for inferences about source structure and kinematics.

preprint2009arXiv

Detailed Characterization of H_beta emission line profile in low z SDSS quasars

We explore the properties of the H_beta emission line profile in a large, homogeneous and bright sample of N~470 low redshift quasars extracted from Sloan Digital Sky Survey (DR5). We approach the investigation from two complementary directions: composite/median spectra and a set of line diagnostic measures (asymmetry index, centroid shift and kurtosis) in individual quasars. The project is developed and presented in the framework of the so-called 4D Eigenvector 1 (4DE1) Parameter Space, with a focus on its optical dimensions, FWHM(H_beta) and the relative strength of optical FeII (R_FeII=W(FeII4434-4684)/W(H_beta)). We reenforce the conclusion that not all quasars are alike and spectroscopically they do not distribute randomly about an average typical optical spectrum. Our results give further support to the concept of two populations A and B (narrower and broader than 4000 km/s FWHM(H_beta), respectively) that emerged in the context of 4DE1 space. The broad H_beta profiles in composite spectra of Population A sources are best described by a Lorentzian and in Population B by a double Gaussian model. Moreover, high and low accretion sources (an alternative view of the Population A/B concept) not only show significant differences in terms of Black Hole (BH) mass and Eddington ratio L_bol/L_Edd, but they also show distinct properties in terms of line asymmetry, shift and shapes. We finally suggest that a potential refinement of the 4DE1 space can be provided by separating two populations of quasars at R_FeII~0.50 rather than at FWHM(H_beta)=4000 km/s. Concomitantly, the asymmetry and centroid shift profile measures at 1/4 fractional intensity can be reasonable surrogates for the FWHM(H_beta) dimension of the current 4DE1.

preprint2009arXiv

Fourier Photometric Analysis of Isolated Galaxies in the Context of the AMIGA Project

We present the results of a Fourier photometric decomposition of a representative sample of ~100 isolated Sb-Sc CIG/AMIGA galaxies. It complements the analysis presented in Durbala et al. 2008 for the same sample by allowing a description of the spiral structure morphology. We estimate dynamical measures like torque strength for bar and spiral, and also the total nonaxisymmetric torque. We explore the interplay between the spiral and bar components of galaxies. Both the length and the contrast of the Fourier bars decrease along the morphological sequence Sb-Sbc-Sc, with bars in earlier types being longer and showing higher contrast. Bars of Sb galaxies are ~3x longer than bars in Sc types. We find that longer bars are not necessarily stronger (as quantified by the torque Q_{b} measure), but longer bars show a higher contrast, in very good agreement with theoretical predictions. Our data suggests that bar and spiral components are rather independent in the sense that the torque strengths of the two components are not correlated. The total strength Q_{g} is a very reliable tracer of the bar strength Q_{b}, the two quantities showing a very tight linear correlation. Comparison with a similar sample of disk galaxies extracted from the OSUBGS indicates that the isolated CIG/AMIGA galaxies host significantly longer Fourier bars and possibly show a different distribution of spiral torque Q_{s}. The Fourier analysis also revealed a potential case of counterwinding spiral structure (NGC 5768), which deserves further kinematic study. We find that m = 2 (i.e., dominating two-armed pattern) is the most common spiral arm multiplicity among the sample of Sb-Sc CIG/AMIGA galaxies (~40%), m = 2&3 and m = 1&2 are found in ~28% and ~13% of isolated galaxies, respectively.

preprint2009arXiv

Small-scale systems of galaxies. IV. Searching for the faint galaxy population associated with X-ray detected isolated E+S pairs

In hierarchical evolutionary scenarios, isolated, physical pairs may represent an intermediate phase, or &#34;way station&#34;, between collapsing groups and isolated elliptical (E) galaxies (or fossil groups). We started a comprehensive study of a sample of galaxy pairs composed of a giant E and a spiral (S) with the aim of investigating their formation/evolutionary history from observed optical and X-ray properties. Here we present VLT-VIMOS observations designed to identify faint galaxies associated with the E+S systems from candidate lists generated using photometric criteria on WFI images covering an area of ~ 0.2 h^{-1} Mpc radius around the pairs. The results are discussed in the context of the evolution of poor galaxy group associations. A comparison between the Optical Luminosity Functions (OLFs) of our E+S systems and a sample of X-ray bright poor groups suggest that the OLF of X-ray detected poor galaxy systems is not universal. The OLF of our X-ray bright systems suggests that they are more dynamically evolved than our X-ray faint sample and some X-ray bright groups in the literature. However, we suggest that the X-ray faint E+S pairs represent a phase in the dynamical evolution of some X-ray bright poor galaxy groups. The recent or ongoing interaction in which the E member of the X-ray faint pairs is involved could have decreased the luminosity of any surrounding X-ray emitting gas.

preprint2000arXiv

Eigenvector 1: An Optimal Correlation Space for Active Galactic Nuclei

We identify a correlation space involving optical and UV emission line parameters as well as the soft X-ray spectral index that provides optimal discrimination between all principal classes of active galactic nuclei. Most of the sources in our three high quality data samples show a strong intercorrelation with narrow line Seyfert 1 (NLSy1) galaxies and steep spectrum radio galaxies occupying opposite extrema in the space. NLSy1 sources show a clear continuity with broader line sources indicating that they are not a disjoint class of AGN as is sometimes suggested. We interpret the principal intercorrelation in the parameter space as being driven by AGN luminosity to black hole mass ratio (L/M prop. to the Eddington ratio). Source orientation no doubt also plays an important role but it is not yet clear whether FWHM H beta or CIV 1549 line shift is the better indicator. We tentatively identify two RQ populations: an almost pure RQ population A with FWHM<=4000 and population B which occupies the same parameter domain as the flat spectrum RL sources. A possible interpretation sees Pop. A/NLSy1 as lower mass/high accretion rate sources and Pop. B/RL sources the opposite.

preprint1999arXiv

UGC 3995: A Close Pair of Spiral Galaxies

UGC 3995 is a close pair of spiral galaxies whose eastern component hosts a Seyfert 2 nucleus. We present a detailed analysis of this system using long slit spectroscopy and narrow (\ha + \nii) as well as broad band (B, R) imaging and an archive WFPC2 image. The component galaxies reveal surprisingly small signs of interaction considering their spatial proximity and almost identical recession velocities, as the bright filament is probably an optical illusion due to the superposition of the bar of the Seyfert galaxy and of the spiral arms of the companion. The broad band morphology, a B--R color map, and a continuum-subtracted \ha + \nii image demonstrate that the western component UGC 3995B is in front of the Seyfert-hosting component UGC 3995A, partly obscuring its western side. The small radial velocity difference leaves the relative motion of the two galaxies largely unconstrained. The observed lack of major tidal deformations, along with some morphological peculiarities, suggests that the galaxies are proximate in space but may have recently approached each other on the plane of the sky. The geometry of the system and the radial velocity curve at P. A. = 106 suggest that the encounter may be retrograde or, alternatively, prograde before perigalacticon. The partial overlap of the two galaxies allows us to estimate the optical thickness of the disk of component B. We derive an extinction = 0.18 visual magnitudes in the infra-arms parts of the foreground galaxy disk, and >= 1-1.5 visual magnitudes in correspondence of the spiral arms.

preprint1998arXiv

Disk Models for MCG-06-30-15: The Variability Challenge

Recent observations have shown that the Fe Kalpha line profile of the Seyfert~1 galaxy MCG-06-30-15 is strongly variable. We attempt accretion disk model fits to the Fa Kalpha line profiles in a high, low and medium continuum luminosity phase of this source. During the monitoring by Iwasawa et al. (1996) a broad red-shifted component remained reasonably constant while a narrower component at $\approx$ 6.4 keV strongly responded to continuum changes. Physically consistent fits are possible if the index xi of the power-law emissivity changes from 0.7 (high phase) to 3.0 (low phase). The shape of the red-shifted component at low phase is crucial to the disk model interpretation. We suggest that the actual shape may be a broad redshifted Gaussian. Three lines of evidence support the interpretation of the Fe Kalpha line as multicomponent, beyond the lack of correlation in the response to continuum changes of the red and blue components in MCG -06-30-15. (1) We show that the strong concentration of narrow peak centroids at 6.4 keV is inconsistent with expectations of a random distribution of disk orientations. (2) The average Fe Kalpha profile for a sample of 16 mostly Seyfert~1&#39;s suggests a natural decomposition into two Gaussians one unshifted/narrow and the other redshifted/broad. (3) Evidence for emission in excess to the expectation of disk models on the high energy side of the Fe Kalpha profile is both a challenge for low inclination disk models and support for the two component decomposition.