Source author record

Damir D. Dzhafarov

Explore this author’s publications, collaborators and research topics. This catalog record has not been claimed by its author.

ResearcherUnclaimed source record

math.LO Artificial Intelligence

Catalog footprint

Research overview

17works

2topics

4close collaborators

Actions

Is this your work?

Open graph Browse papers

preprint2020arXiv

Some results concerning the $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ vs. $\mathsf{COH}$ problem

The $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ vs.\ $\mathsf{COH}$ problem is a central problem in computable combinatorics and reverse mathematics, asking whether every Turing ideal that satisfies the principle $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ also satisfies the principle $\mathsf{COH}$ . This paper is a contribution towards further developing some of the main techniques involved in attacking this problem. We study several principles related to each of $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ and $\mathsf{COH}$ , and prove results that highlight the limits of our current understanding, but also point to new directions ripe for further exploration.

preprint2016arXiv

Effectiveness of Hindman's theorem for bounded sums

We consider the strength and effective content of restricted versions of Hindman's Theorem in which the number of colors is specified and the length of the sums has a specified finite bound. Let $\mathsf{HT}^{\leq n}_k$ denote the assertion that for each $k$ -coloring $c$ of $\mathbb{N}$ there is an infinite set $X \subseteq \mathbb{N}$ such that all sums $\sum_{x \in F} x$ for $F \subseteq X$ and $0 < |F| \leq n$ have the same color. We prove that there is a computable $2$ -coloring $c$ of $\mathbb{N}$ such that there is no infinite computable set $X$ such that all nonempty sums of at most $2$ elements of $X$ have the same color. It follows that $\mathsf{HT}^{\leq 2}_2$ is not provable in $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ and in fact we show that it implies $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ in $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ . We also show that there is a computable instance of $\mathsf{HT}^{\leq 3}_3$ with all solutions computing $0'$ . The proof of this result shows that $\mathsf{HT}^{\leq 3}_3$ implies $\mathsf{ACA}_0$ in $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ .

preprint2016arXiv

Generics for Mathias forcing over general Turing ideals

In Mathias forcing, conditions are pairs $(D,S)$ of sets of natural numbers, in which $D$ is finite, $S$ is infinite, and $\max D < \min S$ . The Turing degrees and computational characteristics of generics for this forcing in the special (but important) case where the infinite sets $S$ are computable were thoroughly explored by Cholak, Dzhafarov, Hirst, and Slaman~\cite{CDHS-2014}. In this paper, we undertake a similar investigation for the case where the sets $S$ are members of general countable Turing ideals, and give conditions under which generics for Mathias forcing over one ideal compute generics for Mathias forcing over another. It turns out that if $\mathcal{I}$ does not contain only the computable sets, then non-trivial information can be encoded into the generics for Mathias forcing over $\mathcal{I}$ . We give a classification of this information in terms of computability-theoretic properties of the ideal, using coding techniques that also yield new results about introreducibility. In particular, we extend a result of Slaman and Groszek and show that there is an infinite $Δ^0_3$ set with no introreducible subset of the same degree.

preprint2016arXiv

Ramsey's theorem for singletons and strong computable reducibility

We answer a question posed by Hirschfeldt and Jockusch by showing that whenever $k > \ell$ , Ramsey's theorem for singletons and $k$ -colorings, $\mathsf{RT}^1_k$ , is not strongly computably reducible to the stable Ramsey's theorem for $\ell$ -colorings, $\mathsf{SRT}^2_\ell$ . Our proof actually establishes the following considerably stronger fact: given $k > \ell$ , there is a coloring $c : ω\to k$ such that for every stable coloring $d : [ω]^2 \to \ell$ (computable from $c$ or not), there is an infinite homogeneous set $H$ for $d$ that computes no infinite homogeneous set for $c$ . This also answers a separate question of Dzhafarov, as it follows that the cohesive principle, $\mathsf{COH}$ , is not strongly computably reducible to the stable Ramsey's theorem for all colorings, $\mathsf{SRT}^2_{<\infty}$ . The latter is the strongest partial result to date in the direction of giving a negative answer to the longstanding open question of whether $\mathsf{COH}$ is implied by the stable Ramsey's theorem in $ω$ -models of $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ .

preprint2016arXiv

The uniform content of partial and linear orders

The principle $ADS$ asserts that every linear order on $ω$ has an infinite ascending or descending sequence. This has been studied extensively in the reverse mathematics literature, beginning with the work of Hirschfeldt and Shore. We introduce the principle $ADC$ , which asserts that linear order has an infinite ascending or descending chain. The two are easily seen to be equivalent over the base system $RCA_0$ of second order arithmetic; they are even computably equivalent. However, we prove that $ADC$ is strictly weaker than $ADS$ under Weihrauch (uniform) reducibility. In fact, we show that even the principle $SADS$ , which is the restriction of $ADS$ to linear orders of type $ω+ ω^*$ , is not Weihrauch reducible to $ADC$ . In this connection, we define a more natural stable form of $ADS$ that we call $General\text-SADS$ , which is the restriction of $ADS$ to linear orders of type $k + ω$ , $ω+ ω^*$ , or $ω+ k$ , where $k$ is a finite number. We define $GeneralSADC$ analogously. We prove that $GeneralSADC$ is not Weihrauch reducible to $SADS$ , and so in particular, each of $SADS$ and $SADC$ is strictly weaker under Weihrauch reducibility than its general version. Finally, we turn to the principle $CAC$ , which asserts that every partial order on $ω$ has an infinite chain or antichain. This has two previously studied stable variants, $SCAC$ and $WSCAC$ , which were introduced by Hirschfeldt and Jockusch, and by Jockusch, Kastermans, Lempp, Lerman, and Solomon, respectively, and which are known to be equivalent over $RCA_0$ . Here, we show that $SCAC$ is strictly weaker than $WSCAC$ under even computable reducibility.

preprint2015arXiv

Classificatory Sorites, Probabilistic Supervenience, and Rule-Making

We view sorites in terms of stimuli acting upon a system and evoking this system's responses. Supervenience of responses on stimuli implies that they either lack tolerance (i.e., they change in every vicinity of some of the stimuli), or stimuli are not always connectable by finite chains of stimuli in which successive members are `very similar'. If supervenience does not hold, the properties of tolerance and connectedness cannot be formulated and therefore soritical sequences cannot be constructed. We hypothesize that supervenience in empirical systems (such as people answering questions) is fundamentally probabilistic. The supervenience of probabilities of responses on stimuli is stable, in the sense that `higher-order' probability distributions can always be reduced to `ordinary' ones. In making rules about which stimuli ought to correspond to which responses, the main characterization of choices in soritical situations is their arbitrariness. We argue that arbitrariness poses no problems for classical logic.

preprint2015arXiv

On uniform relationships between combinatorial problems

The enterprise of comparing mathematical theorems according to their logical strength is an active area in mathematical logic. In this setting, called reverse mathematics, one investigates which theorems provably imply which others in a weak formal theory roughly corresponding to computable mathematics. Since the proofs of such implications take place in classical logic, they may in principle involve appeals to multiple applications of a particular theorem, or to non-uniform decisions about how to proceed in a given construction. In practice, however, if a theorem $\mathsf{Q}$ implies a theorem $\mathsf{P}$ , it is usually because there is a direct uniform translation of the problems represented by $\mathsf{P}$ into the problems represented by $\mathsf{Q}$ , in a precise sense. We study this notion of uniform reducibility in the context of several natural combinatorial problems, and compare and contrast it with the traditional notion of implication in reverse mathematics. We show, for instance, that for all $n,j,k \geq 1$ , if $j < k$ then Ramsey's theorem for $n$ -tuples and $k$ many colors does not uniformly reduce to Ramsey's theorem for $j$ many colors. The two theorems are classically equivalent, so our analysis gives a genuinely finer metric by which to gauge the relative strength of mathematical propositions. We also study Weak König's Lemma, the Thin Set Theorem, and the Rainbow Ramsey's Theorem, along with a number of their variants investigated in the literature. Uniform reducibility turns out to be connected with sequential forms of mathematical principles, where one wishes to solve infinitely many instances of a particular problem simultaneously. We exploit this connection to uncover new points of difference between combinatorial problems previously thought to be more closely related.

preprint2015arXiv

Strong reductions and combinatorial principles

This paper is a contribution to the growing investigation of strong reducibilities between $Π^1_2$ statements of second-order arithmetic, viewed as an extension of the traditional analysis of reverse mathematics. We answer several questions of Hirschfeldt and Jockusch (to appear) about uniform and strong computable reductions between various combinatorial principles related to Ramsey's theorem for pairs. Among other results, we establish that the principle $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ is not uniformly or strongly computably reducible to $\mathsf{D}^2_{<\infty}$ , that $\mathsf{COH}$ is not uniformly reducible to $\mathsf{D}^2_{<\infty}$ , and that $\mathsf{COH}$ is not strongly reducible to $\mathsf{D}^2_2$ . The latter also extends a prior result of Dzhafarov (2015). We introduce a number of new techniques for controlling the combinatorial and computability-theoretic properties of the problems and solutions we construct in our arguments.

preprint2012arXiv

Cohesive avoidance and arithmetical sets

An open question in reverse mathematics is whether the cohesive principle, $\COH$, is implied by the stable form of Ramsey's theorem for pairs, $\SRT^2_2$, in $ω$ -models of $\RCA$. One typical way of establishing this implication would be to show that for every sequence $\vec{R}$ of subsets of $ω$ , there is a set $A$ that is $Δ^0_2$ in $\vec{R}$ such that every infinite subset of $A$ or $\bar{A}$ computes an $\vec{R}$ -cohesive set. In this article, this is shown to be false, even under far less stringent assumptions: for all natural numbers $n \geq 2$ and $m < 2^n$ , there is a sequence $\vec{R} = \sequence{R_0,...,R_{n-1}}$ of subsets of $ω$ such that for any partition $A_0,...,A_{m-1}$ of $ω$ arithmetical in $\vec{R}$ , there is an infinite subset of some $A_j$ that computes no set cohesive for $\vec{R}$ . This complements a number of previous results in computability theory on the computational feebleness of infinite sets of numbers with prescribed combinatorial properties. The proof is a forcing argument using an adaptation of the method of Seetapun showing that every finite coloring of pairs of integers has an infinite homogeneous set not computing a given non-computable set.

preprint2012arXiv

Limits to joining with generics and randoms

Posner and Robinson (1981) proved that if $S \subseteq ω$ is non-computable, then there exists a $G \subseteq ω$ such that $S \oplus G \geq_T G'$ . Shore and Slaman (1999) extended this result to all $n \in ω$ , by showing that if $S \nleq_T \emptyset^{(n-1)}$ then there exists a $G$ such that $S \oplus G \geq_T G^{(n)}$ . Their argument employs Kumabe-Slaman forcing, and so the set they obtain, unlike that of the Posner-Robinson theorem, is not generic for Cohen forcing in any way. We answer the question of whether this is a necessary complication by showing that for all $n \geq 1$ , the set $G$ of the Shore-Slaman theorem cannot be chosen to be even weakly 2-generic. Our result applies to several other effective forcing notions commonly used in computability theory, and we also prove that the set $G$ cannot be chosen to be 2-random.

preprint2012arXiv

On Mathias generic sets

We present some results about generics for computable Mathias forcing. The $n$ -generics and weak $n$ -generics in this setting form a strict hierarchy as in the case of Cohen forcing. We analyze the complexity of the Mathias forcing relation, and show that if $G$ is any $n$ -generic with $n \geq 3$ then it satisfies the jump property $G^{(n-1)} = G' \oplus \emptyset^{(n)}$ . We prove that every such $G$ has generalized high degree, and so cannot have even Cohen 1-generic degree. On the other hand, we show that $G$ , together with any bi-immune set $A \leq_T \emptyset^{(n-1)}$ , computes a Cohen $n$ -generic set.

preprint2012arXiv

Reverse mathematics and properties of finite character

We study the reverse mathematics of the principle stating that, for every property of finite character, every set has a maximal subset satisfying the property. In the context of set theory, this variant of Tukey's lemma is equivalent to the axiom of choice. We study its behavior in the context of second-order arithmetic, where it applies to sets of natural numbers only, and give a full characterization of its strength in terms of the quantifier structure of the formula defining the property. We then study the interaction between properties of finite character and finitary closure operators, and the interaction between these properties and a class of nondeterministic closure operators.

preprint2011arXiv

Computably enumerable partial orders

We study the degree spectra and reverse-mathematical applications of computably enumerable and co-computably enumerable partial orders. We formulate versions of the chain/antichain principle and ascending/descending sequence principle for such orders, and show that the former is strictly stronger than the latter. We then show that every $\emptyset'$ -computable structure (or even just of c.e.\ degree) has the same degree spectrum as some computably enumerable (co-c.e.)\ partial order, and hence that there is a c.e.\ (co-c.e.)\ partial order with spectrum equal to the set of nonzero degrees.

preprint2011arXiv

On the strength of the finite intersection principle

We study the logical content of several maximality principles related to the finite intersection principle ($F\IP$) in set theory. Classically, these are all equivalent to the axiom of choice, but in the context of reverse mathematics their strengths vary: some are equivalent to $\ACA$ over $\RCA$, while others are strictly weaker, and incomparable with $\WKL$. We show that there is a computable instance of $F\IP$ all of whose solutions have hyperimmune degree, and that every computable instance has a solution in every nonzero c.e.\ degree. In terms of other weak principles previously studied in the literature, the former result translates to $F\IP$ implying the omitting partial types principle ( $\mathsf{OPT}$ ). We also show that, modulo $Σ^0_2$ induction, $F\IP$ lies strictly below the atomic model theorem ( $\mathsf{AMT}$ ).

preprint2010arXiv

Infinite saturated orders

We generalize the notion of saturated order to infinite partial orders and give both a set-theoretic and an algebraic characterization of such orders. We then study the proof theoretic strength of the equivalence of these characterizations in the context of reverse mathematics, showing that depending on one's choice of definitions it is either provable in $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ or equivalent to $\mathsf{ACA}_0$ .

preprint2010arXiv

Reverse mathematics and equivalents of the axiom of choice

We study the reverse mathematics of countable analogues of several maximality principles that are equivalent to the axiom of choice in set theory. Among these are the principle asserting that every family of sets has a $\subseteq$ -maximal subfamily with the finite intersection property and the principle asserting that if $P$ is a property of finite character then every set has a $\subseteq$ -maximal subset of which $P$ holds. We show that these principles and their variations have a wide range of strengths in the context of second-order arithmetic, from being equivalent to $\mathsf{Z}_2$ to being weaker than $\mathsf{ACA}_0$ and incomparable with $\mathsf{WKL}_0$ . In particular, we identify a choice principle that, modulo $Σ^0_2$ induction, lies strictly below the atomic model theorem principle $\mathsf{AMT}$ and implies the omitting partial types principle $\mathsf{OPT}$ .

preprint2010arXiv

Stable Ramsey's theorem and measure

The stable Ramsey's theorem for pairs has been the subject of numerous investigations in mathematical logic. We introduce a weaker form of it by restricting from the class of all stable colorings to subclasses of it that are non-null in a certain effective measure-theoretic sense. We show that the sets that can compute infinite homogeneous sets for non-null many computable stable colorings and the sets that can compute infinite homogeneous sets for all computable stable colorings agree below $\emp'$ but not in general. We also answer the analogs of two well known questions about the stable Ramsey's theorem by showing that our weaker principle does not imply $\mathsf{COH}$ or $\mathsf{WKL}_0$ in the context of reverse mathematics.

Inspect adjacent papers, topics, institutions and collaborators without losing the researcher page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Damir D. Dzhafarov

Research overview

Is this your work?

17 publications

Some results concerning the $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ vs. $\mathsf{COH}$ problem

Effectiveness of Hindman's theorem for bounded sums

Generics for Mathias forcing over general Turing ideals

Ramsey's theorem for singletons and strong computable reducibility

The uniform content of partial and linear orders

Classificatory Sorites, Probabilistic Supervenience, and Rule-Making

On uniform relationships between combinatorial problems

Strong reductions and combinatorial principles

Cohesive avoidance and arithmetical sets

Limits to joining with generics and randoms

On Mathias generic sets

Reverse mathematics and properties of finite character

Computably enumerable partial orders

On the strength of the finite intersection principle

Infinite saturated orders

Reverse mathematics and equivalents of the axiom of choice

Stable Ramsey's theorem and measure

See the researcher in context

Building this map preview

Damir D. Dzhafarov

Research overview

Is this your work?

17 publications

Some results concerning the SRT22\mathsf{SRT}^2_2SRT22​ vs. COH\mathsf{COH}COH problem

Effectiveness of Hindman's theorem for bounded sums

Generics for Mathias forcing over general Turing ideals

Ramsey's theorem for singletons and strong computable reducibility

The uniform content of partial and linear orders

Classificatory Sorites, Probabilistic Supervenience, and Rule-Making

On uniform relationships between combinatorial problems

Strong reductions and combinatorial principles

Cohesive avoidance and arithmetical sets

Limits to joining with generics and randoms

On Mathias generic sets

Reverse mathematics and properties of finite character

Computably enumerable partial orders

On the strength of the finite intersection principle

Infinite saturated orders

Reverse mathematics and equivalents of the axiom of choice

Stable Ramsey's theorem and measure

See the researcher in context

Building this map preview

Some results concerning the $\mathsf{SRT}^2_2$ vs. $\mathsf{COH}$ problem