Paper detail

Reply to Comment on Nonlocal quartic interactions and universality classes in perovskite manganites

Comment [arXiv:cond-mat.stat.mech., 1602.02087v1 (2016)] has raised questions claiming that the nonlocal model Hamiltonian presented in [Phys. Rev. E 92, 012123 (2015)] is equivalent to the standard (short-ranged) Φ^4 theory. These claims are based on a low momentum expansion of the interaction vertex that cannot be applied to the vertex factors containing both low and high momenta inside the loop-integrals. Elaborating upon the important steps of the momentum shell decimation scheme, employed in the renormalization-group calculation, we explicitly show the interplay of internal (high) and external (low) momenta determining the loop integrals for self-energy and vertex functions giving rise to corrections (to the bare parameters) different from those of the standard (short-ranged) Φ^4 theory. Employing explicit mathematical arguments, we show that this difference persists when the range of interaction is assumed to be long (short) ranged with respect to the lattice constant (correlation-length), yielding the critical exponents as given in the original paper.

preprint2016arXivOpen access

Signal facts

What is known right now

Open access3 authors1 topic

Next steps

Decide what to do with this paper

Use like or dislike for the fast social read. The more specific scholarly feedback stays available below when needed.

Log in to curate

Reading frame

Keep the important context close to the paper

Keep the important signals around this paper in one place: votes, save state, collection context, reviews and the metadata you need before deciding what to do next.

Institutions

Add specific reaction

Move through the context

Research map

Open full explorer

Move through nearby people, institutions, topics and adjacent work without leaving the paper page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Structured reviews

0 review(s)

ContributeLeave structured feedbackUse the review template when you have a concrete strength, concern or method question.Open review form

No structured reviews yet. High-signal critique starts here.

Work discussion

0 comment(s)

DiscussAdd a high-signal commentKeep quick notes, caveats and replication pointers separate from formal reviews.Open comment form

No discussion yet. The first strong comment sets the tone.