Paper detail

Non-probabilistic odds and forecasting with imperfect models

Probability forecasts are intended to account for the uncertainties inherent in forecasting. It is suggested that from an end-user's point of view probability is not necessarily sufficient to reflect uncertainties that are not simply the result of complexity or randomness, for example, probability forecasts may not adequately account for uncertainties due to model error. It is suggested that an alternative forecast product is to issue non-probabilistic odds forecasts, which may be as useful to end-users, and give a less distorted account of the uncertainties of a forecast. Our analysis of odds forecasts derives from game theory using the principle that if forecasters truly believe their forecasts, then they should take bets at the odds they offer and not expect to be bankrupted. Despite this game theoretic approach, it is not a market or economic evaluation; it is intended to be a scientific evaluation. Illustrative examples are given of the calculation of odds forecasts and their application to investment, loss mitigation and ensemble weather forecasting.