Conditioning on the pre-test versus gain score modeling: revisiting the controversy in a multilevel setting
We consider estimating the effect of a treatment on the progress of subjects tested both before and after treatment assignment. A vast literature compares the competing approaches of modeling the post-test score conditionally on the pre-test score versus modeling the difference, namely the gain score. Our contribution resides in analyzing the merits and drawbacks of the two approaches in a multilevel setting. This is relevant in many fields, for example education with students nested into schools. The multilevel structure raises peculiar issues related to the contextual effects and the distinction between individual-level and cluster-level treatment. We derive approximate analytical results and compare the two approaches by a simulation study. For an individual-level treatment our findings are in line with the literature, whereas for a cluster-level treatment we point out the key role of the cluster mean of the pre-test score, which favors the conditioning approach in settings with large clusters.