Researcher profile

Jason Crampton

Jason Crampton contributes to research discovery and scholarly infrastructure.

ResearcherAffiliation not importedOpen to collaborate

Trust snapshot

Quick read

Trust 21 - EmergingVerification L1Unclaimed author
17works
0followers
4topics
4close collaborators

Actions

Decide how to stay connected

Follow researcher0

Identity and collaboration

How to connect with this researcher

Claiming links this public author record to a researcher profile and unlocks direct collaboration workflows.

Log in to claim

Direct collaboration

Open a focused conversation when the fit is right

Claim this author entity first to unlock direct invitations.

Research graph

See the researcher in context

Open full explorer

Inspect adjacent work, topics, institutions and collaborators without jumping out to a separate graph page.

Building this graph slice

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Published work

17 published item(s)

preprint2016arXiv

A Multivariate Approach for Checking Resiliency in Access Control

In recent years, several combinatorial problems were introduced in the area of access control. Typically, such problems deal with an authorization policy, seen as a relation $UR \subseteq U \times R$, where $(u, r) \in UR$ means that user $u$ is authorized to access resource $r$. Li, Tripunitara and Wang (2009) introduced the Resiliency Checking Problem (RCP), in which we are given an authorization policy, a subset of resources $P \subseteq R$, as well as integers $s \ge 0$, $d \ge 1$ and $t \geq 1$. It asks whether upon removal of any set of at most $s$ users, there still exist $d$ pairwise disjoint sets of at most $t$ users such that each set has collectively access to all resources in $P$. This problem possesses several parameters which appear to take small values in practice. We thus analyze the parameterized complexity of RCP with respect to these parameters, by considering all possible combinations of $|P|, s, d, t$. In all but one case, we are able to settle whether the problem is in FPT, XP, W[2]-hard, para-NP-hard or para-coNP-hard. We also consider the restricted case where $s=0$ for which we determine the complexity for all possible combinations of the parameters.

preprint2015arXiv

Cryptographic Enforcement of Information Flow Policies without Public Information

Cryptographic access control has been studied for over 30 years and is now a mature research topic. When symmetric cryptographic primitives are used, each protected resource is encrypted and only authorized users should have access to the encryption key. By treating the keys themselves as protected resources, it is possible to develop schemes in which authorized keys are derived from the keys explicitly assigned to the user's possession and publicly available information. It has been generally assumed that each user would be assigned a single key from which all other authorized keys would be derived. Recent work has challenged this assumption by developing schemes that do not require public information, the trade-off being that a user may require more than one key. However, these new schemes, which require a chain partition of the partially ordered set on which the access control policy is based, have some disadvantages. In this paper we define the notion of a tree-based cryptographic enforcement scheme, which, like chain-based schemes, requires no public information. We establish that the strong security properties of chain-based schemes are preserved by tree-based schemes, and provide an efficient construction for deriving a tree-based enforcement scheme from a given policy that minimizes the number of keys required.

preprint2015arXiv

On the Workflow Satisfiability Problem with Class-Independent Constraints

A workflow specification defines sets of steps and users. An authorization policy determines for each user a subset of steps the user is allowed to perform. Other security requirements, such as separation-of-duty, impose constraints on which subsets of users may perform certain subsets of steps. The \emph{workflow satisfiability problem} (WSP) is the problem of determining whether there exists an assignment of users to workflow steps that satisfies all such authorizations and constraints. An algorithm for solving WSP is important, both as a static analysis tool for workflow specifications, and for the construction of run-time reference monitors for workflow management systems. Given the computational difficulty of WSP, it is important, particularly for the second application, that such algorithms are as efficient as possible. We introduce class-independent constraints, enabling us to model scenarios where the set of users is partitioned into groups, and the identities of the user groups are irrelevant to the satisfaction of the constraint. We prove that solving WSP is fixed-parameter tractable (FPT) for this class of constraints and develop an FPT algorithm that is useful in practice. We compare the performance of the FPT algorithm with that of SAT4J (a pseudo-Boolean SAT solver) in computational experiments, which show that our algorithm significantly outperforms SAT4J for many instances of WSP. User-independent constraints, a large class of constraints including many practical ones, are a special case of class-independent constraints for which WSP was proved to be FPT (Cohen {\em et al.}, J. Artif. Intel. Res. 2014). Thus our results considerably extend our knowledge of the fixed-parameter tractability of WSP.

preprint2015arXiv

Optimal Constructions for Chain-based Cryptographic Enforcement of Information Flow Policies

The simple security property in an information flow policy can be enforced by encrypting data objects and distributing an appropriate secret to each user. A user derives a suitable decryption key from the secret and publicly available information. A chain-based enforcement scheme provides an alternative method of cryptographic enforcement that does not require any public information, the trade-off being that a user may require more than one secret. For a given information flow policy, there will be many different possible chain-based enforcement schemes. In this paper, we provide a polynomial-time algorithm for selecting a chain-based scheme which uses the minimum possible number of keys. We also compute the number of secrets that will be required and establish an upper bound on the number of secrets required by any user.

preprint2015arXiv

Relationship-Based Access Control for OpenMRS

Inspired by the access control models of social network systems, Relationship-Based Access Control (ReBAC) was recently proposed as a general-purpose access control paradigm for application domains in which authorization must take into account the relationship between the access requestor and the resource owner. The healthcare domain is envisioned to be an archetypical application domain in which ReBAC is sorely needed: e.g., my patient record should be accessible only by my family doctor, but not by all doctors. In this work, we demonstrate for the first time that ReBAC can be incorporated into a production-scale medical records system, OpenMRS, with backward compatibility to the legacy RBAC mechanism. Specifically, we extend the access control mechanism of OpenMRS to enforce ReBAC policies. Our extensions incorporate and extend advanced ReBAC features recently proposed by Crampton and Sellwood. In addition, we designed and implemented the first administrative model for ReBAC. In this paper, we describe our ReBAC implementation, discuss the system engineering lessons learnt as a result, and evaluate the experimental work we have undertaken. In particular, we compare the performance of the various authorization schemes we implemented, thereby demonstrating the feasibility of ReBAC.

preprint2015arXiv

Relationships, Paths and Principal Matching: A New Approach to Access Control

Recent work on relationship-based access control has begun to show how it can be applied to general computing systems, as opposed to simply being employed for social networking applications. The use of relationships to determine authorization policies enables more powerful policies to be defined than those based solely on the commonly used concept of role membership. The relationships, paths and principal matching (RPPM) model described here is a formal access control model using relationships and a two-stage request evaluation process. We make use of path conditions, which are similar to regular expressions, to define policies. We then employ non-deterministic finite automata to determine which policies are applicable to a request. The power and robustness of the RPPM model allows us to include contextual information in the authorization process (through the inclusion of logical entities) and allows us to support desirable policy foundations such as separation of duty and Chinese Wall. Additionally, the RPPM model naturally supports a caching mechanism which has significant impact on request evaluation performance.

preprint2015arXiv

Valued Workflow Satisfiability Problem

A workflow is a collection of steps that must be executed in some specific order to achieve an objective. A computerised workflow management system may enforce authorisation policies and constraints, thereby restricting which users can perform particular steps in a workflow. The existence of policies and constraints may mean that a workflow is unsatisfiable, in the sense that it is impossible to find an authorised user for each step in the workflow and satisfy all constraints. In this paper, we consider the problem of finding the "least bad" assignment of users to workflow steps by assigning a weight to each policy and constraint violation. To this end, we introduce a framework for associating costs with the violation of workflow policies and constraints and define the \emph{valued workflow satisfiability problem} (Valued WSP), whose solution is an assignment of steps to users of minimum cost. We establish the computational complexity of Valued WSP with user-independent constraints and show that it is fixed-parameter tractable. We then describe an algorithm for solving Valued WSP with user-independent constraints and evaluate its performance, comparing it to that of an off-the-shelf mixed integer programming package.

preprint2014arXiv

Caching and Auditing in the RPPM Model

Crampton and Sellwood recently introduced a variant of relationship-based access control based on the concepts of relationships, paths and principal matching, to which we will refer as the RPPM model. In this paper, we show that the RPPM model can be extended to provide support for caching of authorization decisions and enforcement of separation of duty policies. We show that these extensions are natural and powerful. Indeed, caching provides far greater advantages in RPPM than it does in most other access control models and we are able to support a wide range of separation of duty policies.

preprint2014arXiv

Iterative Plan Construction for the Workflow Satisfiability Problem

The \emph{Workflow Satisfiability Problem (WSP)} is a problem of practical interest that arises whenever tasks need to be performed by authorized users, subject to constraints defined by business rules. We are required to decide whether there exists a \emph{plan} -- an assignment of tasks to authorized users -- such that all constraints are satisfied. Several bespoke algorithms have been constructed for solving the WSP, optimised to deal with constraints (business rules) of particular types. It is natural to see the WSP as a subclass of the {\em Constraint Satisfaction Problem (CSP)} in which the variables are tasks and the domain is the set of users. What makes the WSP distinctive as a CSP is that we can assume that the number of tasks is very small compared to the number of users. This is in sharp contrast with traditional CSP models where the domain is small and the number of variables is very large. As such, it is appropriate to ask for which constraint languages the WSP is fixed-parameter tractable (FPT), parameterized by the number of tasks. We have identified a new FPT constraint language, user-independent constraint, that includes many of the constraints of interest in business processing systems. We are also able to prove that the union of FPT languages remains FPT if they satisfy a simple compatibility condition. In this paper we present our generic algorithm, in which plans are grouped into equivalence classes, each class being associated with a \emph{pattern}. We demonstrate that our generic algorithm has running time $O^*(2^{k\log k})$, where $k$ is the number of tasks, for the language of user-independent constraints. We also show that there is no algorithm of running time $O^*(2^{o(k\log k)})$ for user-independent constraints unless the Exponential Time Hypothesis fails.

preprint2014arXiv

Path Conditions and Principal Matching: A New Approach to Access Control

Traditional authorization policies are user-centric, in the sense that authorization is defined, ultimately, in terms of user identities. We believe that this user-centric approach is inappropriate for many applications, and that what should determine authorization is the relationships that exist between entities in the system. While recent research has considered the possibility of specifying authorization policies based on the relationships that exist between peers in social networks, we are not aware of the application of these ideas to general computing systems. We develop a formal access control model that makes use of ideas from relationship-based access control and a two-stage method for evaluating policies. Our policies are defined using path conditions, which are similar to regular expressions. We define semantics for path conditions, which we use to develop a rigorous method for evaluating policies. We describe the algorithm required to evaluate policies and establish its complexity. Finally, we illustrate the advantages of our model using an example and describe a preliminary implementation of our algorithm.

preprint2014arXiv

Publicly Verifiable Outsourced Computation with a Key Distribution Centre

The combination of software-as-a-service and the increasing use of mobile devices gives rise to a considerable difference in computational power between servers and clients. Thus, there is a desire for clients to outsource the evaluation of complex functions to a server and to be able to verify that the resulting value is correct. Previous work in this area of Publicly Verifiable Outsourced Computation (PVC) requires a costly pre-processing stage. However, in many practical situations multiple clients will be interested in the same set of core functions and will make use of the same servers. Thus, the pre-processing phase may be performed many more times than is necessary. In this paper we introduce a Key Distribution Center (KDC) that handles the generation and distribution of the keys that are required to support PVC, thereby eliminating this redundancy. We define a number of new security models and functionalities that arise with the introduction of the KDC, and present a construction of such a scheme built upon Key-Policy Attribute-based Encryption.

preprint2014arXiv

Towards A Generic Formal Framework for Access Control Systems

There have been many proposals for access control models and authorization policy languages, which are used to inform the design of access control systems. Most, if not all, of these proposals impose restrictions on the implementation of access control systems, thereby limiting the type of authorization requests that can be processed or the structure of the authorization policies that can be specified. In this paper, we develop a formal characterization of the features of an access control model that imposes few restrictions of this nature. Our characterization is intended to be a generic framework for access control, from which we may derive access control models and reason about the properties of those models. In this paper, we consider the properties of monotonicity and completeness, the first being particularly important for attribute-based access control systems. XACML, an XML-based language and architecture for attribute-based access control, is neither monotonic nor complete. Using our framework, we define attribute-based access control models, in the style of XACML, that are, respectively, monotonic and complete.

preprint2013arXiv

Constraint Expressions and Workflow Satisfiability

A workflow specification defines a set of steps and the order in which those steps must be executed. Security requirements and business rules may impose constraints on which users are permitted to perform those steps. A workflow specification is said to be satisfiable if there exists an assignment of authorized users to workflow steps that satisfies all the constraints. An algorithm for determining whether such an assignment exists is important, both as a static analysis tool for workflow specifications, and for the construction of run-time reference monitors for workflow management systems. We develop new methods for determining workflow satisfiability based on the concept of constraint expressions, which were introduced recently by Khan and Fong. These methods are surprising versatile, enabling us to develop algorithms for, and determine the complexity of, a number of different problems related to workflow satisfiability.

preprint2013arXiv

On the Parameterized Complexity and Kernelization of the Workflow Satisfiability Problem

A workflow specification defines a set of steps and the order in which those steps must be executed. Security requirements may impose constraints on which groups of users are permitted to perform subsets of those steps. A workflow specification is said to be satisfiable if there exists an assignment of users to workflow steps that satisfies all the constraints. An algorithm for determining whether such an assignment exists is important, both as a static analysis tool for workflow specifications, and for the construction of run-time reference monitors for workflow management systems. Finding such an assignment is a hard problem in general, but work by Wang and Li in 2010 using the theory of parameterized complexity suggests that efficient algorithms exist under reasonable assumptions about workflow specifications. In this paper, we improve the complexity bounds for the workflow satisfiability problem. We also generalize and extend the types of constraints that may be defined in a workflow specification and prove that the satisfiability problem remains fixed-parameter tractable for such constraints. Finally, we consider preprocessing for the problem and prove that in an important special case, in polynomial time, we can reduce the given input into an equivalent one, where the number of users is at most the number of steps. We also show that no such reduction exists for two natural extensions of this case, which bounds the number of users by a polynomial in the number of steps, provided a widely-accepted complexity-theoretical assumption holds.

preprint2013arXiv

On the Use of Key Assignment Schemes in Authentication Protocols

Key Assignment Schemes (KASs) have been extensively studied in the context of cryptographically-enforced access control, where derived keys are used to decrypt protected resources. In this paper, we explore the use of KASs in entity authentication protocols, where we use derived keys to encrypt challenges. This novel use of KASs permits the efficient authentication of an entity in accordance with an authentication policy by associating entities with security labels representing specific services. Cryptographic keys are associated with each security label and demonstrating knowledge of an appropriate key is used as the basis for authentication. Thus, by controlling the distribution of such keys, restrictions may be efficiently placed upon the circumstances under which an entity may be authenticated and the services to which they may gain access. In this work, we explore how both standardized protocols and novel constructions may be developed to authenticate entities as members of a group associated to a particular security label, whilst protecting the long-term secrets in the system. We also see that such constructions may allow for authentication whilst preserving anonymity, and that by including a trusted third party we can achieve the authentication of individual identities and authentication based on timestamps without the need for synchronized clocks.

preprint2011arXiv

Practical Constructions for the Efficient Cryptographic Enforcement of Interval-Based Access Control Policies

The enforcement of access control policies using cryptography has received considerable attention in recent years and the security of such enforcement schemes is increasingly well understood. Recent work in the area has considered the efficient enforcement of temporal and geo-spatial access control policies, and asymptotic results for the time and space complexity of efficient enforcement schemes have been obtained. However, for practical purposes, it is useful to have explicit bounds for the complexity of enforcement schemes. In this paper, we consider interval-based access control policies, of which temporal and geo-spatial access control policies are special cases. We define enforcement schemes for interval-based access control policies for which it is possible, in almost all cases, to obtain exact values for the schemes' complexity, thereby subsuming a substantial body of work in the literature. Moreover, our enforcement schemes are more practical than existing schemes, in the sense that they operate in the same way as standard cryptographic enforcement schemes, unlike other efficient schemes in the literature. The main difference between our approach and earlier work is that we develop techniques that are specific to the cryptographic enforcement of interval-based access control policies, rather than applying generic techniques that give rise to complex constructions and asymptotic bounds.

preprint2011arXiv

PTaCL: A Language for Attribute-Based Access Control in Open Systems

Many languages and algebras have been proposed in recent years for the specification of authorization policies. For some proposals, such as XACML, the main motivation is to address real-world requirements, typically by providing a complex policy language with somewhat informal evaluation methods; others try to provide a greater degree of formality (particularly with respect to policy evaluation) but support far fewer features. In short, there are very few proposals that combine a rich set of language features with a well-defined semantics, and even fewer that do this for authorization policies for attribute-based access control in open environments. In this paper, we decompose the problem of policy specification into two distinct sub-languages: the policy target language (PTL) for target specification, which determines when a policy should be evaluated; and the policy composition language (PCL) for building more complex policies from existing ones. We define syntax and semantics for two such languages and demonstrate that they can be both simple and expressive. PTaCL, the language obtained by combining the features of these two sub-languages, supports the specification of a wide range of policies. However, the power of PTaCL means that it is possible to define policies that could produce unexpected results. We provide an analysis of how PTL should be restricted and how policies written in PCL should be evaluated to minimize the likelihood of undesirable results.