Spin and quadrupole correlations by three-spin interaction in the frustrated pyrochlore magnet Tb2+xTi2−xO7+y
We have investigated the origin of the magnetic dipole correlations ⟨σQzσ−Qz⟩ characterized by the modulation wave vector k∼(21,21,21) observed in the frustrated pyrochlore magnet Tb2+xTi2−xO7+y. This magnetic short-range order cannot be accounted for by adding further-neighbor exchange interactions to the nearest-neighbor pseudospin-21 Hamiltonian for quantum pyrochlore magnets. Using classical Monte Carlo simulation and quantum simulation based on thermally pure quantum (TPQ) states we have shown that the spin correlations with k∼(21,21,21) are induced at low temperatures by a three-spin interaction of a form σr±σr′zσr′′z, which is a correction to the Hamiltonian due to the low crystal-field excitation. Simulations using TPQ states have shown that the spin correlations coexist with electric quadrupole correlations ⟨σQασ−Qβ⟩ (α,β=x,y) with k∼0. These results suggest that the putative quantum spin liquid state of Tb2+xTi2−xO7+y is located close to phase boundaries of the spin-ice, quadrupole-ordered, and magnetic-ordered states in the classical approximation, and that the three-spin interaction brings about a quantum disordered ground state with both spin and quadrupole correlations.