Source author record

David Hobson

David Hobson appears in the imported research catalog. Authorship, coauthor and topic links are available while profile ownership is still unclaimed.

ResearcherUnclaimed source record

Catalog footprint

What is connected

20works
6topics
4close collaborators

Actions

Connect this record

Log in to claim

Research graph

See the researcher in context

Open full explorer

Inspect adjacent papers, topics, institutions and collaborators without losing the researcher page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Published work

20 published item(s)

preprint2020arXiv

The potential of the shadow measure

It is well known that given two probability measures $μ$ and $ν$ on $\mathbb{R}$ in convex order there exists a discrete-time martingale with these marginals. Several solutions are known (for example from the literature on the Skorokhod embedding problem in Brownian motion). But, if we add a requirement that the martingale should minimise the expected value of some functional of its starting and finishing positions then the problem becomes more difficult. Beiglböck and Juillet (Ann. Probab. 44 (2016) 42-106) introduced the shadow measure which induces a family of martingale couplings, and solves the optimal martingale transport problem for a class of bivariate objective functions. In this article we extend their (existence and uniqueness) results by providing an explicit construction of the shadow measure and, as an application, give a simple proof of its associativity.

preprint2020arXiv

The shape of the value function under Poisson optimal stopping

In a classical problem for the stopping of a diffusion process $(X_t)_{t \geq 0}$, where the goal is to maximise the expected discounted value of a function of the stopped process ${\mathbb E}^x[e^{-βτ}g(X_τ)]$, maximisation takes place over all stopping times $τ$. In a Poisson optimal stopping problem, stopping is restricted to event times of an independent Poisson process. In this article we consider whether the resulting value function $V_θ(x) = \sup_{τ\in {\mathcal T}({\mathbb T}^θ)}{\mathbb E}^x[e^{-βτ}g(X_τ)]$ (where the supremum is taken over stopping times taking values in the event times of an inhomogeneous Poisson process with rate $θ= (θ(X_t))_{t \geq 0}$) inherits monotonicity and convexity properties from $g$. It turns out that monotonicity (respectively convexity) of $V_θ$ in $x$ depends on the monotonicity (respectively convexity) of the quantity $\frac{θ(x) g(x)}{θ(x) + β}$ rather than $g$. Our main technique is stochastic coupling.

preprint2016arXiv

A multi-asset investment and consumption problem with transaction costs

In this article we study a multi-asset version of the Merton investment and consumption problem with proportional transaction costs. In general it is difficult to make analytical progress towards a solution in such problems, but we specialise to a case where transaction costs are zero except for sales and purchases of a single asset which we call the illiquid asset. Assuming agents have CRRA utilities and asset prices follow exponential Brownian motions we show that the underlying HJB equation can be transformed into a boundary value problem for a first order differential equation. The optimal strategy is to trade the illiquid asset only when the fraction of the total portfolio value invested in this asset falls outside a fixed interval. Important properties of the multi-asset problem (including when the problem is well-posed, ill-posed, or well-posed only for large transaction costs) can be inferred from the behaviours of a quadratic function of a single variable and another algebraic function.

preprint2016arXiv

Gambling in contests with random initial law

This paper studies a variant of the contest model introduced in Seel and Strack [J. Econom. Theory 148 (2013) 2033-2048]. In the Seel-Strack contest, each agent or contestant privately observes a Brownian motion, absorbed at zero, and chooses when to stop it. The winner of the contest is the agent who stops at the highest value. The model assumes that all the processes start from a common value $x_0>0$ and the symmetric Nash equilibrium is for each agent to utilise a stopping rule which yields a randomised value for the stopped process. In the two-player contest, this randomised value has a uniform distribution on $[0,2x_0]$. In this paper, we consider a variant of the problem whereby the starting values of the Brownian motions are independent, nonnegative random variables that have a common law $μ$. We consider a two-player contest and prove the existence and uniqueness of a symmetric Nash equilibrium for the problem. The solution is that each agent should aim for the target law $ν$, where $ν$ is greater than or equal to $μ$ in convex order; $ν$ has an atom at zero of the same size as any atom of $μ$ at zero, and otherwise is atom free; on $(0,\infty)$ $ν$ has a decreasing density; and the density of $ν$ only decreases at points where the convex order constraint is binding.

preprint2016arXiv

More on hedging American options under model uncertainty

The purpose of this note is to reconcile two different results concerning the model-free upper bound on the price of an American option, given a set of European option prices. Neuberger (2007, `Bounds on the American option') and Hobson and Neuberger (2016, `On the value of being American') argue that the cost of the cheapest super-replicating strategy is equal to the highest model-based price, where we search over all models which price correctly the given European options. Bayraktar, Huang and Zhou (2015, `On hedging American options under model uncertainty', SIAM J. Financial Math ematics) argue that the cost of the cheapest super-replicating strategy can strictly exceed the highest model-based price. We show that the reason for the difference in conclusion is that Bayraktar et al do not search over a rich enough class of models.

preprint2016arXiv

On the value of being American

The virtue of an American option is that it can be exercised at any time. This right is particularly valuable when there is model uncertainty. Yet almost all the extensive literature on American options assumes away model uncertainty. This paper quantifies the potential value of this flexibility by identifying the supremum on the price of an American option when no model is imposed on the data, but rather any model is required to be consistent with a family of European call prices. The bound is enforced by a hedging strategy involving these call options which is robust to model error.

preprint2016arXiv

Optimal consumption and investment under transaction costs

In this article we consider the Merton problem in a market with a single risky asset and transaction costs. We give a complete solution of the problem up to the solution of a free-boundary problem for a first-order differential equation, and find that the form of the solution (whether the problem is well-posed, whether the problem is well-posed only for large transaction costs, whether the no-transaction wedge lies in the first, second or fourth quadrants) depends only on a quadratic whose co-efficients are functions of the parameters of the problem, and then only through the value and slope of this quadratic at zero, one and the turning point. We find that for some parameter values and for large transaction costs the location of the boundary at which sales of the risky asset occur is independent of the transaction cost on purchases. We give both a mathematical and financial reason for this phenomena.

preprint2015arXiv

Finite, integrable and bounded time embeddings for diffusions

We solve the Skorokhod embedding problem (SEP) for a general time-homogeneous diffusion $X$: given a distribution $ρ$, we construct a stopping time $τ$ such that the stopped process $X_τ$ has the distribution $ρ$. Our solution method makes use of martingale representations (in a similar way to Bass (In Seminar on Probability XVII. Lecture Notes in Math. 784 (1983) 221-224 Springer) who solves the SEP for Brownian motion) and draws on law uniqueness of weak solutions of SDEs. Then we ask if there exist solutions of the SEP which are respectively finite almost surely, integrable or bounded, and when does our proposed construction have these properties. We provide conditions that guarantee existence of finite time solutions. Then, we fully characterize the distributions that can be embedded with integrable stopping times. Finally, we derive necessary, respectively sufficient, conditions under which there exists a bounded embedding.

preprint2015arXiv

Mimicking martingales

Given the univariate marginals of a real-valued, continuous-time martingale, (respectively, a family of measures parameterised by $t \in [0,T]$ which is increasing in convex order, or a double continuum of call prices) we construct a family of pure-jump martingales which mimic that martingale (respectively, are consistent with the family of measures, or call prices). As an example, we construct a fake Brownian motion. Then, under a further `dispersion' assumption, we construct the martingale which (within the family of martingales which are consistent with a given set of measures) has the smallest expected total variation. We also give a path-wise inequality, which in the mathematical finance context yields a model-independent sub-hedge for an exotic security with payoff equal to the total variation along a realisation of the price process.

preprint2014arXiv

Integrability of solutions of the Skorokhod Embedding Problem for Diffusions

Suppose $X$ is a time-homogeneous diffusion on an interval $I^X \subseteq \mathbb R$ and let $μ$ be a probability measure on $I^X$. Then $τ$ is a solution of the Skorokhod embedding problem (SEP) for $μ$ in $X$ if $τ$ is a stopping time and $X_τ\sim μ$. There are well-known conditions which determine whether there exists a solution of the SEP for $μ$ in $X$. We give necessary and sufficient conditions for there to exist an integrable solution. Further, if there exists a solution of the SEP then there exists a minimal solution. We show that every minimal solution of the SEP has the same first moment. When $X$ is Brownian motion, every integrable embedding of $μ$ is minimal. However, for a general diffusion there may be integrable embeddings which are not minimal.

preprint2014arXiv

Multi-asset consumption-investment problems with infinite transaction costs

The subject of this paper is an optimal consumption/optimal portfolio problem with transaction costs and with multiple risky assets. In our model the transaction costs take a special form in that transaction costs on purchases of one of the risky assets (the endowed asset) are infinite, and transaction costs involving the other risky assets are zero. Effectively, the endowed asset can only be sold. In general, multi-asset optional consumption/optimal portfolio problems are very challenging, but the extra structure we introduce allows us to make significant progress towards an analytical solution. For an agent with CRRA utility we completely characterise the different types of optimal behaviours. These include always selling the entire holdings of the endowed asset immediately, selling the endowed asset whenever the ratio of the value of the holdings of the endowed asset to other wealth gets above a critical ratio, and selling the endowed asset only when other wealth is zero. This characterisation is in terms of solutions of a boundary crossing problem for a first order ODE. The technical contribution is to show that the problem of solving the HJB equation, which is a second order, non-linear PDE subject to smooth fit at an unknown free boundary, can be reduced to this much simpler problem involving an explicit first order ODE. This technical contribution is at the heart of our analytical and numerical results, and allows us to prove monotonicity of the critical exercise threshold and the certainty equivalent value in the model parameters.

preprint2014arXiv

Optimal consumption and sale strategies for a risk averse agent

In this article we consider a special case of an optimal consumption/optimal portfolio problem first studied by Constantinides and Magill and by Davis and Norman, in which an agent with constant relative risk aversion seeks to maximise expected discounted utility of consumption over the infinite horizon, in a model comprising a risk-free asset and a risky asset with proportional transaction costs. The special case that we consider is that the cost of purchases of the risky asset is infinite, or equivalently the risky asset can only be sold and not bought. In this special setting new solution techniques are available, and we can make considerable progress towards an analytical solution. This means we are able to consider the comparative statics of the problem. There are some surprising conclusions, such as consumption rates are not monotone increasing in the return of the asset, nor are the certainty equivalent values of the risky positions monotone in the risk aversion.

preprint2013arXiv

Gambling in contests with regret

This paper discusses the gambling contest introduced in Seel & Strack (Gambling in contests, Discussion Paper Series of SFB/TR 15 Governance and the Efficiency of Economic Systems 375, Mar 2012.) and considers the impact of adding a penalty associated with failure to follow a winning strategy. The Seel & Strack model consists of $n$-agents each of whom privately observes a transient diffusion process and chooses when to stop it. The player with the highest stopped value wins the contest, and each player's objective is to maximise their probability of winning the contest. We give a new derivation of the results of Seel & Strack based on a Lagrangian approach. Moreover, we consider an extension of the problem in which in the case when an agent is penalised when their strategy is suboptimal, in the sense that they do not win the contest, but there existed an alternative strategy which would have resulted in victory.

preprint2013arXiv

Maximizing functionals of the maximum in the Skorokhod embedding problem and an application to variance swaps

The Azéma-Yor solution (resp., the Perkins solution) of the Skorokhod embedding problem has the property that it maximizes (resp., minimizes) the law of the maximum of the stopped process. We show that these constructions have a wider property in that they also maximize (and minimize) expected values for a more general class of bivariate functions $F(W_τ,S_τ)$ depending on the joint law of the stopped process and the maximum. Moreover, for monotonic functions $g$, they also maximize and minimize $\mathbb {E}[\int_0^τg(S_t)\,dt]$ amongst embeddings of $μ$, although, perhaps surprisingly, we show that for increasing $g$ the Azéma-Yor embedding minimizes this quantity, and the Perkins embedding maximizes it. For $g(s)=s^{-2}$ we show how these results are useful in calculating model independent bounds on the prices of variance swaps. Along the way we also consider whether $μ_n$ converges weakly to $μ$ is a sufficient condition for the associated Azéma-Yor and Perkins stopping times to converge. In the case of the Azéma-Yor embedding, if the potentials at zero also converge, then the stopping times converge almost surely, but for the Perkins embedding this need not be the case. However, under a further condition on the convergence of atoms at zero, the Perkins stopping times converge in probability (and hence converge almost surely down a subsequence).

preprint2013arXiv

Robust price bounds for the forward starting straddle

In this article we consider the problem of giving a robust, model-independent, lower bound on the price of a forward starting straddle with payoff $|F_{T_1} - F_{T_0}|$ where $0<T_0<T_1$. Rather than assuming a model for the underlying forward price $(F_t)_{t \geq 0}$, we assume that call prices for maturities $T_0<T_1$ are given and hence that the marginal laws of the underlying are known. The primal problem is to find the model which is consistent with the observed call prices, and for which the price of the forward starting straddle is minimised. The dual problem is to find the cheapest semi-static subhedge. Under an assumption on the supports of the marginal laws, but no assumption that the laws are atom-free or in any other way regular, we derive explicit expressions for the coupling which minimises the price of the option, and the form of the semi-static subhedge.

preprint2012arXiv

Recovering a time-homogeneous stock price process from perpetual option prices

It is well known how to determine the price of perpetual American options if the underlying stock price is a time-homogeneous diffusion. In the present paper we consider the inverse problem, that is, given prices of perpetual American options for different strikes, we show how to construct a time-homogeneous stock price model which reproduces the given option prices.

preprint2012arXiv

Utility theory front to back - inferring utility from agents' choices

We pursue an inverse approach to utility theory and consumption & investment problems. Instead of specifying an agent's utility function and deriving her actions, we assume we observe her actions (i.e. her consumption and investment strategies) and ask if it is possible to derive a utility function for which the observed behaviour is optimal. We work in continuous time both in a deterministic and stochastic setting. In the deterministic setup, we find that there are infinitely many utility functions generating a given consumption pattern. In the stochastic setting of the Black-Scholes complete market it turns out that the consumption and investment strategies have to satisfy a consistency condition (PDE) if they are to come from a classical utility maximisation problem. We show further that important characteristics of the agent such as her attitude towards risk (e.g. DARA) can be deduced directly from her consumption/investment choices.

preprint2011arXiv

Model independent hedging strategies for variance swaps

A variance swap is a derivative with a path-dependent payoff which allows investors to take positions on the future variability of an asset. In the idealised setting of a continuously monitored variance swap written on an asset with continuous paths it is well known that the variance swap payoff can be replicated exactly using a portfolio of puts and calls and a dynamic position in the asset. This fact forms the basis of the VIX contract. But what if we are in the more realistic setting where the contract is based on discrete monitoring, and the underlying asset may have jumps? We show that it is possible to derive model-independent, no-arbitrage bounds on the price of the variance swap, and corresponding sub- and super-replicating strategies. Further, we characterise the optimal bounds. The form of the hedges depends crucially on the kernel used to define the variance swap.

preprint2010arXiv

Constructing Time-Homogeneous Generalised Diffusions Consistent with Optimal Stopping Values

Consider a set of discounted optimal stopping problems for a one-parameter family of objective functions and a fixed diffusion process, started at a fixed point. A standard problem in stochastic control/optimal stopping is to solve for the problem value in this setting. In this article we consider an inverse problem; given the set of problem values for a family of objective functions, we aim to recover the diffusion. Under a natural assumption on the family of objective functions we can characterise existence and uniqueness of a diffusion for which the optimal stopping problems have the specified values. The solution of the problem relies on techniques from generalised convexity theory