Explaining the poor performance of the KASS algorithm implementation

By investigating the code for the KASS algorithm implementation used in the paper "Exploring the quantum speed limit with computer games" [1, arXiv:1506.09091] by Sørensen et al. (provided by the authors), we describe how the poor performance of the KASS algorithm reported in [1] is entirely caused by a simple sign error in a derivative calculation. Changing only this one sign in the KASS implementation, we show that the algorithm provides results comparable to all other algorithms considered for the problem [2,7], and performs better than all player solutions of [1]. Furthermore, we show that the player solutions were optimized with a different algorithm before being compared to the results from the KASS algorithm. The authors of [1] have acknowledged both findings. Finally, we show that in contrast to the claims in [1], the players did not explore two different strategies. In fact, all the players followed the same strategy.

No reviews yet.

No comments yet.