Paper detail

Comment on "Tuning the Magnetic Dimensionality by Charge Ordering in the Molecular TMTTF Salts"

Yoshimi et al. [arXiv:1110.3573] have attempted to explain the pressure(P)-dependent behavior of Fabre salts which exhibit charge order (CO), antiferromagnetic (AFM), and spin-Peierls (SP) phases. Experiments find two AFM phases, AFM1 at large P and AFM2 at small P. Yoshimi et al. suggest that there also exist two distinct zero-temperature SP phases, SP1 and SP2. Here we point out that the occurrence of two distinct SP phases contradicts experiments, and is found because of unrealistic model parameters.