Comparing H.265/HEVC and VP9: Impact of High Frame Rates on the Perceptual Quality of Compressed Videos
High frame rates have been known to enhance the perceived visual quality of specific video content. However, the lack of investigation of high frame rates has restricted the expansion of this research field particularly in the context of full-high-definition (FHD) and 4K ultra-high-definition video formats. This study involves a subjective and objective quality assessment of compressed FHD videos. First, we compress the FHD videos by employing high-efficiency video coding, and VP9 at five quantization parameter levels for multiple frame rates, i.e., 15fps, 30fps, and 60fps. The FHD videos are obtained from a high frame-rate video database BVI-HFR, spanning various scenes, colors, and motions, and are shown to be representative of the BBC broadcast content. Second, a detailed subjective quality assessment of compressed videos for both encoders and individual frame rates is conducted, resulting in subjective measurements in the form of the differential mean opinion score reflecting the quality of experience. In particular, the aim is to investigate the impact of compression on the perceptual quality of compressed FHD videos and compare the performance of both encoders for each frame rate. Finally, 11 state-of-the-art objective quality assessment metrics are benchmarked using the subjective measurements, to investigate the correlation as a statistical evaluation between the two models in terms of correlation coefficients. A recommendation for enhancing the quality estimation of full-reference (FR) video quality measurements (VQMs) is presented after the extensive investigation.