Source author record

J. B. Kogut

J. B. Kogut appears in the imported research catalog. Authorship, coauthor and topic links are available while profile ownership is still unclaimed.

ResearcherUnclaimed source record

Catalog footprint

What is connected

32works
5topics
4close collaborators

Actions

Connect this record

Log in to claim

Research graph

See the researcher in context

Open full explorer

Inspect adjacent papers, topics, institutions and collaborators without losing the researcher page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Published work

32 published item(s)

preprint2016arXiv

Complex Langevin for Lattice QCD at $T=0$ and $μ\ge 0$

QCD at finite quark-/baryon-number density, which describes nuclear matter, has a sign problem which prevents direct application of standard simulation methods based on importance sampling. When such finite density is implemented by the introduction of a quark-number chemical potential $μ$, this manifests itself as a complex fermion determinant. We apply simulations using the Complex Langevin Equation (CLE) which can be applied in such cases. However, this is not guaranteed to give correct results, so that extensive tests are required. In addition, gauge cooling is required to prevent runaway behaviour. We test these methods on 2-flavour lattice QCD at zero temperature on a small ($12^4$) lattice at an intermediate coupling $β=6/g^2=5.6$ and relatively small quark mass $m=0.025$, over a range of $μ$ values from $0$ to saturation. While this appears to show the correct phase structure with a phase transition at $μ\approx m_N/3$ and a saturation density of $3$ at large $μ$, the observables show departures from known values at small $μ$. We are now running on a larger lattice ($16^4$) at weaker coupling $β=5.7$. At $μ=0$ this significantly improves agreement between measured observables and known values, and there is some indication that this continues to small $μ$s. This leads one to hope that the CLE might produce correct results in the weak-coupling -- continuum -- limit.

preprint2015arXiv

Exploring Complex-Langevin Methods for Finite-Density QCD

QCD at non-zero chemical potential ($μ$) for quark number has a complex fermion determinant and thus standard simulation methods for lattice QCD cannot be applied. We therefore simulate this theory using the Complex-Langevin algorithm with Gauge Cooling in addition to adaptive methods, to prevent runaway behaviour. Simulations are performed at zero temperature on a $12^4$ lattice with 2 quarks which are light enough that $m_N/3$ is significantly larger than $m_π/2$. Preliminary results are qualitatively as expected. The quark-number density is close to zero for $μ< m_N/3$, beyond which it increases, eventually reaching its saturation value of $3$ for $μ$ sufficiently large. The chiral condensate decreases as $μ$ is increased approaching zero at saturation, while the plaquette increases towards its quenched value. We have yet to observe the transition to nuclear matter at $μ\approx m_N/3$, presumably because the runs for $μ$ between $m_N/3$ and saturation have yet to equilibrate.

preprint2015arXiv

The chiral phase transition for lattice QCD with 2 colour-sextet quarks

QCD with 2 flavours of massless colour-sextet quarks is studied as a possible walking-Technicolor candidate. We simulate the lattice version of this model at finite temperatures near to the chiral-symmetry restoration transition, to determine whether it is indeed a walking theory (QCD-like with a running coupling which evolves slowly over an appreciable range of length scales) or if it has an infrared fixed point, making it a conformal field theory. The lattice spacing at this transition is decreased towards zero by increasing the number $N_t$ of lattice sites in the temporal direction. Our simulations are performed at $N_t=4,6,8,12$, on lattices with spatial extent much larger than the temporal extent. A range of small fermion masses is chosen to make predictions for the chiral (zero mass) limit. We find that the bare lattice coupling does decrease as the lattice spacing is decreased. However, it decreases more slowly than would be predicted by asymptotic freedom. We discuss whether this means that the coupling is approaching a finite value as lattice $N_t$ is increased -- the conformal option, or if the apparent disagreement with the scaling predicted by asymptotic freedom is because the lattice coupling is a poor expansion parameter, and the theory walks. Currently, evidence favours QCD with 2 colour-sextet quarks being a conformal field theory. Other potential sources of disagreement with the walking hypothesis are also discussed. We also report an estimate of the position of the deconfinement transition for $N_t=12$, needed for choosing parameters for zero-temperature simulations.

preprint2014arXiv

Models of Walking Technicolor on the Lattice

We study QCD with 2 colour-sextet quarks as a walking-Technicolor candidate. As such it provides a description of the Higgs sector of the standard model, in which the Higgs field is replaced by the Goldstone `pions' of this QCD-like theory, and the Higgs itself is the $σ$. Such a theory will need to be extended if it is to also give masses to the quarks and leptons. What we are attempting to determine is whether it is indeed QCD-like and hence walking, or if it has an infrared fixed point making it a conformal field theory. We do this by simulating its lattice version at finite temperature and observing the running of the bare (lattice) coupling at the chiral transition, as the lattice spacing is varied, and comparing this running with that predicted by 2-loop perturbation theory. Our results on lattices with temporal extents ($N_t$) up to 12 indicate that the coupling runs, but not as fast as asymptotic freedom predicts. We discuss our program for studying the zero-temperature phenomenology of this theory.

preprint2014arXiv

Thermodynamics of lattice QCD with 3 flavours of colour-sextet quarks II: N_t=6 and N_t=8

We have been studying QCD with 2 flavours of colour-sextet quarks as a candidate walking-Technicolor theory using lattice-QCD simulations. The evolution of the coupling constant with lattice spacing is measured at the finite-temperature chiral transition to determine if this theory is asymptotically free and hence QCD-like. The lattice spacing is varied by changing the number of lattice sites, $N_t$, in the Euclidean time direction. QCD with 3 flavours is studied for comparison. Since this theory is expected to be conformal, with an infrared fixed point, the coupling constant at the chiral transition should approach a non-zero value as $N_t$ becomes large. Our earlier simulations on lattices with $N_t=4$ and $N_t=6$ exhibited a significant decrease in coupling at the chiral transition as $N_t$ was increased. We have now extended these simulations to $N_t=8$, and performed additional simulations at $N_t=6$ to measure the coupling constant at the chiral transition more precisely. These indicate that while there is an appreciable decrease in coupling between $N_t=6$ and $N_t=8$, this is much smaller than that between $N_t=4$ and $N_t=6$. Thus we are hopeful that we are approaching the large-$N_t$ limit. However, further simulations at larger $N_t$(s) are needed.

preprint2013arXiv

Further studies of QCD with sextet quarks

We continue our simulations of QCD with 2 flavours of colour-sextet quarks as a model for walking technicolor. QCD with 3 flavours of colour-sextet quarks is also studied for comparison with the 2-flavour theory. We simulate these theories at finite temperatures T, using lattices with a finite extent $N_t a=1/T$ in the (Euclidean) time direction. The lattice coupling at the chiral-symmetry-restoration transition is measured as a function of $N_t$. If this is indeed a finite-temperature transition, the evolution of this coupling with $N_t$ as $N_t \rightarrow \infty$ and hence the lattice spacing $a \rightarrow 0$ should be described by asymptotic freedom. If so, the theory is QCD-like and walking. If, however, this coupling approaches a constant non-zero value in the large $N_t$ limit, the transition is a bulk transition and the continuum theory is conformal. For the 2-flavour theory, the coupling does show a significant decrease between $N_t=8$ and $N_t=12$, favouring the walking scenario. However, preliminary results are that the change is less than that predicted by asymptotic freedom. For the 3-flavour case, which is expected to be conformal, there is still a significant decrease in the coupling between $N_t=6$ and $N_t=8$, indicating that we are not yet at large enough $N_t$.

preprint2012arXiv

QCD with colour-sextet quarks

We study QCD with 2 colour-sextet quarks as a model for walking Technicolor, using lattice gauge theory simulations (RHMC) at finite temperature. Our goal is to determine if the massless theory is QCD-like (confining, with spontaneously-broken chiral symmetry) with a slowly varying coupling (walks) or if it is a conformal field theory. We do this by simulating the theory at finite temperature and observing how the coupling at the chiral-symmetry restoration temperature depends on the temporal extent $N_t$ of the lattice (in lattice units). If the theory is QCD-like, this coupling should approach zero in the large $N_t$ limit in the manner predicted by asymptotic freedom. If it is conformal, this coupling should approach a finite value in this limit, i.e. the transition would be a bulk transition. We discuss new results at $N_t=6,8$ and 12. These preliminary results indicate that the coupling does decrease with increasing $N_t$, but it is unclear if this is consistent with asymptotic freedom.

preprint2011arXiv

The chiral phase transition for QCD with sextet quarks

QCD with 2 massless colour-sextet quarks is studied as a model of Walking Technicolor. We simulate lattice QCD with 2 light color-sextet staggered quarks at finite temperature, and use the dependence of the coupling at the chiral transition on the temporal extent, $N_t$, of the lattice in lattice units to study the running of the bare lattice coupling with lattice spacing. Our goal is to determine whether this theory is QCD-like and `walks', or if it is conformal. If it is QCD-like, the coupling at the chiral transition should tend to zero as $N_t \rightarrow \infty$ in a manner controlled by asymptotic freedom, i.e. by the perturbative $β$-function. On the other hand, if this theory is conformal, this coupling will approach a non-zero limit in the $N_t \rightarrow \infty$ limit. We are extending our simulations on an $N_t=8$ lattice to determine the position of the chiral transition with greater accuracy, and are performing simulations on an $N_t=12$ lattice.

preprint2011arXiv

Thermodynamics of lattice QCD with 2 sextet quarks on N_t=8 lattices

We continue our lattice simulations of QCD with 2 flavours of colour-sextet quarks as a model for conformal or walking technicolor. A 2-loop perturbative calculation of the $β$-function which describes the evolution of this theory's running coupling constant predicts that it has a second zero at a finite coupling. This non-trivial zero would be an infrared stable fixed point, in which case the theory with massless quarks would be a conformal field theory. However, if the interaction between quarks and antiquarks becomes strong enough that a chiral condensate forms before this IR fixed point is reached, the theory is QCD-like with spontaneously broken chiral symmetry and confinement. However, the presence of the nearby IR fixed point means that there is a range of couplings for which the running coupling evolves very slowly, i.e. it 'walks'. We are simulating the lattice version of this theory with staggered quarks at finite temperature studying the changes in couplings at the deconfinement and chiral-symmetry restoring transitions as the temporal extent ($N_t$) of the lattice, measured in lattice units, is increased. Our earlier results on lattices with $N_t=4,6$ show both transitions move to weaker couplings as $N_t$ increases consistent with walking behaviour. In this paper we extend these calculations to $N_t=8$. Although both transition again move to weaker couplings the change in the coupling at the chiral transition from $N_t=6$ to $N_t=8$ is appreciably smaller than that from $N_t=4$ to $N_t=6$. This indicates that at $N_t=4,6$ we are seeing strong coupling effects and that we will need results from $N_t > 8$ to determine if the chiral-transition coupling approaches zero as $N_t \rightarrow \infty$, as needed for the theory to walk.

preprint2011arXiv

Thermodynamics of lattice QCD with 3 flavours of colour-sextet quarks

We have been studying QCD with 2 flavours of colour-sextet quarks to distinguish whether it is QCD-like or conformal. For comparison we are now studying QCD with 3 flavours of colour-sextet quarks, which is believed to be conformal in the chiral limit. Here we present the results of simulations of lattice QCD with 3 colour-sextet quarks at finite temperatures on lattices of temporal extent $N_t=4$ and 6, with masses small enough to yield access to the chiral limit. As for the 2-flavour case, we find well-separated deconfinement and chiral-symmetry restoration transitions, both of which move to appreciably weaker couplings as $N_t$ is increased from 4 to 6. If this theory is conformal, we would expect there to be a bulk chiral transition at a fixed coupling. For this reason we conclude that for $N_t=4$ and 6, the chiral and hence the deconfinement transitions are in the strong-coupling domain where the theory is essentially quenched. The similarity between the behaviours of the 2 and 3 flavour theories suggested that the $N_t=4$ and 6 transitions for the 2-flavour theory also lie in the strong-coupling domain. The phase structure of both theories is very similar.

preprint2010arXiv

New results with colour-sextet quarks

We study QCD with 2 and 3 flavours of colour-sextet quarks. The 2-flavour theory is a candidate Walking Technicolor theory. Since we are attempting to distinguish whether this theory is walking or conformal, we also study the 3-flavour theory, which is believed to be conformal, for comparison. We simulate lattice QCD with 2 and 3 flavours of colour-sextet staggered quarks at finite temperatures to determine the scales of confinement and chiral-symmetry breaking from the positions of the deconfinement and chiral-symmetry restoration transitions. Unlike the case with fundamental quarks, these transitions are far apart. For 2 flavours the values of beta=6/g^2 for both transitions increase as Ta is decreased from 1/4 to 1/6 to 1/8, as expected for a theory whose coupling runs to smaller values as the lattice spacing is decreased. However, for the chiral transition, the increase in beta between Ta=1/4 and Ta=1/6 is much larger than the increase between Ta=1/6 and Ta=1/8. This suggests that between Ta=1/4 and Ta=1/6 we are at strong coupling where the theory is effectively quenched, while between Ta=1/6 and Ta=1/8 we are emerging into the weak coupling regime. It will require even smaller Ta values to determine whether the running of the chiral-transition coupling is controlled by asymptotic freedom and the theory walks, or if it reaches a non-zero limit when the transition becomes a bulk transition and the theory is conformal. The 3 flavour case at Ta=1/4 and Ta=1/6 behaves similarly to the 2 flavour case. Since this theory is expected to be conformal, the interpretation that we are seeing strong-coupling behaviour, inaccessible from the weak-coupling limit (continuum) is the most likely interpretation.

preprint2010arXiv

Thermodynamics of lattice QCD with 2 flavours of colour-sextet quarks: A model of walking/conformal Technicolor

QCD with two flavours of massless colour-sextet quarks is considered as a model for conformal/walking Technicolor. If this theory possess an infrared fixed point, as indicated by 2-loop perturbation theory, it is a conformal(unparticle) field theory. If, on the other hand, a chiral condensate forms on the weak-coupling side of this would-be fixed point, the theory remains confining. The only difference between such a theory and regular QCD is that there is a range of momentum scales over which the coupling constant runs very slowly (walks). In this first analysis, we simulate the lattice version of QCD with two flavours of staggered quarks at finite temperatures on lattices of temporal extent $N_t=4$ and 6. The deconfinement and chiral-symmetry restoration couplings give us a measure of the scales associated with confinement and chiral-symmetry breaking. We find that, in contrast to what is seen with fundamental quarks, these transition couplings are very different. $β=6/g^2$ for each of these transitions increases significantly from $N_t=4$ and $N_t=6$ as expected for the finite temperature transitions of an asymptotically-free theory. This suggests a walking rather than a conformal behaviour, in contrast to what is observed with Wilson quarks. In contrast to what is found for fundamental quarks, the deconfined phase exhibits states in which the Polyakov loop is oriented in the directions of all three cube roots of unity. At very weak coupling the states with complex Polyakov loops undergo a transition to a state with a real, negative Polyakov loop.

preprint2009arXiv

QCD thermodynamics with colour-sextet quarks

We study QCD with two flavours of colour-sextet quarks as a candidate walking-Technicolor theory. We simulate lattice QCD with two flavours of colour-sextet staggered quarks at finite temperatures to observe the scales of confinement and chiral-symmetry breaking. These should give us some indication as to whether the massless theory has an infrared fixed point making it a conformal field theory, or whether it exhibits confinement and chiral symmetry breaking with a slowly varying coupling constant, i.e. `walks'. We find that unlike the case with fundamental quarks, the deconfinement and chiral-symmetry restoration transitions are far apart. The values of $β=6/g^2$ for both transitions increase when $Ta$ is decreased from 1/4 to 1/6 as would be expected for finite temperature transitions of an asymptotically-free field theory. So far we see no suggestion of conformal behaviour.

preprint2006arXiv

Searching for the elusive critical endpoint at finite temperature and isospin density

We consider 3-flavour lattice QCD with a finite chemical potential mu_I for isospin, close to the finite temperature transition from hadronic matter to a quark-gluon plasma. In this region one can argue that the position and probably the nature of this transition mimic those at finite quark-number chemical potential mu. The quark mass is chosen to be close to the critical mass at zero chemical potentials. Since the Binder cumulants used to determine the nature of this transition in HMD(R) simulations are very sensitive to the updating increment dt, we have switched to the newer exact RHMC algorithm for our simulations. Preliminary results indicate that there is no critical endpoint in the small mu_I regime, at least none connected with the critical point at zero chemical potentials.

preprint2005arXiv

3-flavour lattice QCD at finite density and temperature: QCD at finite isospin density revisited

We simulate 3-flavour lattice QCD at finite temperature and isospin chemical potential $μ_I$. In particular we study the nature of the finite temperature transition for quark masses close to the critical mass at which this transition for zero chemical potentials changes from a first order transition to a crossover. We find that the Binder cumulants, used to determine the position of this transition, have very strong dt dependence. This leads us to an estimate of the critical mass which is about 20% below previous estimates. In addition, when this dt dependence is taken into account, we find that the Binder cumulants show very little dependence on mu_I. From this we conclude that we do not as yet see any evidence for the expected critical endpoint. We have argued previously that the position and nature of the finite temperature transition for small mu_I should be the same as that for small quark-number chemical potential mu.

preprint2005arXiv

Lattice simulations of Born-Infeld non-linear QED

Born-Infeld non-linear electrodynamics was introduced to render the self energy of a point particle finite. It has recently been revived as a field theory for branes and strings. We quantize this theory on a Euclidean space-time lattice, using Metropolis Monte-Carlo simulations to measure the properties of the quantum field theory. Luscher-Weisz methods are used to measure the electromagnetic fields from a static point charge. The D field from a point charge appears to be identical to that for the normal Maxwell Lagrangian. The E field is enhanced by quantum fluctuations, and shows short distance screening as it does in the classical theory.

preprint2004arXiv

The finite temperature transition for 3-flavour lattice QCD at finite isospin density

We simulate 3-flavour lattice QCD with a small chemical potential $μ_I$ for isospin, at temperatures close to the finite temperature transition. Using quark masses just above the critical mass for zero chemical potential, we determine the position of the transition from hadronic matter to a quark-gluon plasma as a function of $μ_I$. We see evidence for a critical endpoint where the transition changes from a crossover to a first-order transition as $μ_I$ is increased. We argue that QCD at finite $μ_I$ and QCD at finite quark-numberchemical potential $μ$ should behave similarly in this region.

preprint2003arXiv

Lattice QCD at finite isospin density and/or temperature

We simulate two-flavour lattice QCD with at a finite chemical potential $μ_I$ for isospin, and finite temperature. At small $μ_I$, we determine the position of the crossover from hadronic matter to a quark-gluon plasma as a function of $μ_I$. At larger $μ_I$ we observe the phase transition from the superfluid pion-condensed phase to a quark-gluon plasma, noting its change from second order to first order as $μ_I$ is increased. We also simulate two-flavour lattice QCD at zero quark mass, using an action which includes an additional 4-fermion interaction, at temperatures close to the chiral transition on $N_t=8$ lattices.

preprint2002arXiv

Lattice QCD at finite isospin chemical potential and temperature

We simulate lattice QCD at a finite chemical potential $μ_I$ for isospin ($I_3$) at zero and finite temperatures. At some $μ_I=μ_c$ QCD has a second order transition with mean-field critical exponents to a state where ($I_3$) is broken spontaneously by a charged pion condensate. Heating the system with $μ_I > μ_c$ we find there is some temperature at which this condensate evaporates. This transition appears to be second order and mean-field at lower $μ_I$ values, and first order for $μ_I$ sufficiently large. We are determining the dependence of the finite temperature crossover $T_c$ on $μ_I$ for $μ_I < μ_c$. This is expected to be identical to $T_c$'s dependence on quark-number chemical potential $μ_q$ for small $μ_q$.

preprint2001arXiv

Two-colour QCD at non-zero quark-number density

We have simulated two-colour four-flavour QCD at non-zero chemical potential $μ$ for quark number. Simulations were performed on $8^4$ and $12^3 \times 24$ lattices. Clear evidence was seen for the formation of a colourless diquark condensate which breaks quark number spontaneously, for $μ> μ_c \sim m_π/2$. The transition appears to be second order. We have measured the spectrum of scalar and pseudoscalar bosons which shows clear evidence for the expected Goldstone boson. Our results are in qualitative agreement with those from effective Lagrangians for the potential Goldstone excitations of this theory.

preprint2000arXiv

Two-colour QCD at finite fundamental quark-number density and related theories

We are simulating SU(2) Yang-Mills theory with four flavours of dynamical quarks in the fundamental representation of SU(2) `colour' at finite chemical potential, mu for quark number, as a model for QCD at finite baryon number density. In particular we observe that for mu large enough this theory undergoes a phase transition to a state with a diquark condensate which breaks quark-number symmetry. In this phase we examine the spectrum of light scalar and pseudoscalar bosons and see evidence for the Goldstone boson associated with this spontaneous symmetry breaking. This theory is closely related to QCD at finite chemical potential for isospin, a theory which we are now studying for SU(3) colour.

preprint1998arXiv

Critical region of the finite temperature chiral transition

We study a Yukawa theory with spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking and with a large number N of fermions near the finite temperature phase transition. Critical properties in such a system can be described by the mean field theory very close to the transition point. We show that the width of the region where non-trivial critical behavior sets in is suppressed by a certain power of 1/N. Our Monte Carlo simulations confirm these analytical results. We discuss implications for the chiral phase transition in QCD.

preprint1998arXiv

Thermodynamics of Lattice QCD with Chiral 4-Fermion Interactions

We have studied lattice QCD with an additional, irrelevant 4-fermion interaction having a U(1)xU(1) chiral symmetry, at finite temperatures. Adding this 4-fermion term allowed us to work at zero quark mass, which would have otherwise been impossible. The theory with 2 massless staggered quark flavours appears to have a first order finite temperature phase transition at N_t=4 for the value of 4-fermion coupling we have chosen, in contrast to what is expected for 2-flavour QCD. The pion screening mass is seen to vanish below this transition, only to become massive and degenerate with the sigma (f_0) above this transition where the chiral symmetry is restored, as is seen by the vanishing of the chiral condensate.

preprint1998arXiv

Topology, fermionic zero modes and flavor singlet correlators in finite temperature QCD

We compute the screening correlators in the sigma and eta' flavor singlet channels in finite temperature QCD with 2 light quark flavors. Together with the correlators in the pi and delta channels, these are used to discuss several issues related to symmetry restoration and the nature of the QCD phase transition. Our calculations span a range of temperature extending from approximately 125 MeV to 170 MeV and are carried out in the context of a staggered fermion formulation on a 16^3x8 lattice. In addition to the computation at a fixed quark mass (am_q=0.00625), we discuss the issue of the chiral limit. After careful consideration of the zero-mode shift lattice artefact, we present rather strong (topological) arguments in favor of the non-restoration of U_A(1) at T_c.

preprint1996arXiv

Thermodynamics of lattice QCD with two light quark flavours on a 16^3 x 8 lattice II

We have extended our earlier simulations of the high temperature behaviour of lattice QCD with two light flavours of staggered quarks on a $16^3 \times 8$ lattice to lower quark mass (m_q=0.00625). The transition from hadronic matter to a quark-gluon plasma is observed at $6/g^2=5.49(2)$ corresponding to a temperature of $T_c \approx 140$MeV. We present measurements of observables which probe the nature of the quark-gluon plasma and serve to distinguish it from hadronic matter. Although the transition is quite abrupt, we have seen no indications that it is first order.

preprint1995arXiv

On the Interplay of Monopoles and Chiral Symmetry Breaking in Non-Compact Lattice QED

Non-compact lattice QED is simulated for various numbers of fermion species $N_f$ ranging from 8 through 40 by the exact Hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm. Over this range of $N_f$, chiral symmetry breaking is found to be strongly correlated with the effective monopoles in the theory. For $N_f$ between 8 and 16 the chiral symmetry breaking and monopole percolation transitions are second order and coincident. Assuming powerlaw critical behavior, the correlation length exponent for the chiral transition is identical to that of monopole percolation. This result supports the conjecture that monopole percolation ``drives" the nontrivial chiral transition. For $N_f$ between 20 and 32, the monopoles experience a first order condensation transition coincident with a first order chiral transition. For $N_f$ as large as 40 both transitions are strongly suppressed. The data at large $N_f (N_f \mathrel {\mathpalette \vereq >} 20)$ is interpreted in terms of a strongly interacting monopole gas-liquid transition.

preprint1995arXiv

Phase Transitions at Finite Temperature and Dimensional Reduction for Fermions and Bosons

In a recent Letter we discussed the fact that large-$N$ expansions and computer simulations indicate that the universality class of the finite temperature chiral symmetry restoration transition in the 3D Gross-Neveu model is mean field theory. This was seen to be a counterexample to the standard 'sigma model' scenario which predicts the 2D Ising model universality class. In this article we present more evidence, both theoretical and numerical, that this result is correct. We develop a physical picture for our results and discuss the width of the scaling region (Ginzburg criterion), $1/N$ corrections, and differences between the dynamics of BCS superconductors and Gross-Neveu models. Lattices as large as $12 \times 72^2$ are simulated for both the $N=12$ and $N=4$ cases and the numerical evidence for mean field scaling is quite compelling. We point out that the amplitude ratio for the model's susceptibility is a particulartly good observable for distinguishing between the dimensional reduction and the mean field scenerios, because this universal quantity differs by almost a factor of $20$ in the two cases. The simulations are done close to the critical point in both the symmetric and broken phases, and correlation lengths of order $10$ are measured. The critical indices $β_{mag}$ and $δ$ also pick out mean field behavior. We trace the breakdown of the standard scenario (dimensional reduction and universality) to the composite character of the mesons in the model. We point out that our results should be generic for theories with dynamical symmetry breaking, such as Quantum Chromodynamics. We also simulated the $O(2)$ model on $8 \times 16^3$ lattices to establish that our methods give the results of dimensional reduction in purely bosonic