BZPEERReading, trust and collaboration for researchDiscover
Workspaces
Network
Opportunities
Account
Researcher profile
Eef van Beveren contributes to research discovery and scholarly infrastructure.
Trust snapshot
Actions
Research graph
Inspect adjacent work, topics, institutions and collaborators without jumping out to a separate graph page.
BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.
Published work
This document contains a summary of the LHCb workshop on multi-body decays of D and B mesons, held at CBPF, Rio de Janeiro, in July 2015. The workshop was focused on issues related to amplitude analysis of three- and four-body hadronic decays. In addition to selected LHCb results, contributions from guest theorists are included.
Quark models taking into account the dynamical effects of hadronic decay often produce very different predictions for mass shifts in the hadron spectrum. The consequences for meson spectroscopy can be dramatic and completely obscure the underlying confining force. Recent unquenched lattice calculations of mesonic resonances that also include meson-meson interpolators provide a touchstone for such models, despite the present limitations in applicability. On the experimental side, the $ρ(770)$ meson and its several observed radial recurrences are a fertile testing ground for both quark models and lattice computations. Here we apply a unitarised quark model that has been successful in the description of many enigmatic mesons to these vector $ρ$ resonances and the corresponding $P$-wave $ππ$ phase shifts. This work is in progress, with encouraging preliminary results.
The principal purpose of meson spectroscopy is to understand the confining force, which is generally assumed to be based on low-energy QCD. This is usually done in the context of quark models that ignore the dynamical effects of quark-pair creation and decay. Very recent lattice calculations confirm much earlier model results showing that neglecting such effects, in the so-called quenched approximation, may give rise to discrepancies of hundreds of MeV, and so distort the meson spectra resulting from quark confinement only. Models attempting to mimic unquenching through a redefinition of the constituent quark mass or screening of the confining potential at larger interquark separations are clearly incapable of accounting for the highly non-perturbative and non-linear effects on mesonic bound-state and resonance poles, as demonstrated with several published examples.
In this talk we review the limitations of including meson loops as perturbative corrections in a solvable quark model. We first discuss meson-meson scattering within a formalism which treats confined quark pairs and mesons on an equal footing. The interaction between the mesons proceeds through $s$-channel meson-exchange diagrams. Next, we develop a perturbative expansion of the model, and show that the resonance poles found in such a treatment, even by accounting for contributions up to fourth order, do not coincide with those obtained with the full model. We conclude that the resonance predictions based on perturbative approximations in quark models are not reliable, especially in those cases where the coupling to the scattering channels is large.
The $ρ(770)$ vector resonance, its radial recurrences, and the corresponding P-wave $ππ$ phase shifts are investigated in an unquenched quark model with all classes of relevant decay channels included, viz. pseudoscalar-pseudoscalar, vector-pseudoscalar, vector-vector, vector-scalar, axialvector-pseudoscalar, and axialvector-vector, totalling 26 channels. Two of the few model parameters are fixed at previously used values, whereas the other three are adjusted to the $ρ(770)$ resonance and the lower P-wave $ππ$ phases. Preliminary results indicate the model's capacity to reproduce these phases as well as the $ρ$ mass and width. However, at higher energies the phase shifts tend to rise too sharply. A possible remedy is an extension of the model so as to handle resonances in the final states for most of the included decay channels. Work in progress.
A multichannel Schrödinger equation with both quark-antiquark and meson-meson components, using a harmonic-oscillator potential for $q\bar{q}$ confinement and a delta-shell string-breaking potential for decay, is applied to the axial-vecor $X(3872)$ and lowest vector charmonia. The model parameters are fitted to the experimental values of the masses of the $X(3872)$, $J/ψ$ and $ψ(2S)$. The wave functions of these states are computed and then used to calculate the electromagnetic decay widths of the $X(3872)$ into $J/ψγ$ and $ψ(2S)γ$.
A recent quark-model description of X(3872) as an unquenched $2\,{}^{3\!}P_1$ $c\bar{c}$ state is generalised by now including all relevant meson-meson configurations, in order to calculate the widths of the experimentally observed electromagnetic decays $X(3872) \to γJ/ψ$ and $X(3872) \to γψ(2S)$. Interestingly, the inclusion of additional two-meson channels, most importantly $D^\pm D^{\star\mp}$, leads to a sizeable increase of the $c\bar{c}$ probability in the total wave function, although the $D^0\bar{D}^{\star0}$ component remains the dominant one. As for the electromagnetic decays, unquenching strongly reduces the $γψ(2S)$ decay rate yet even more sharply enhances the $γJ/ψ$ rate, resulting in a decay ratio compatible with one experimental observation but in slight disagreement with two others. Nevertheless, the results show a dramatic improvement as compared to a quenched calculation with the same confinement force and parameters. Concretely, we obtain $Γ( X(3872) \to γψ(2S) )=28.9$ keV and $Γ( X(3872) \to γJ/ψ)=24.7$ keV, with branching ratio $\mathcal{R}_{γψ}=1.17$.
We present indications of possible substructures from weak interactions, by inspecting LEP and LHC date and inferring threshold effects due to the production of pairs of composite heavy gauge bosons W+-, Z and their hypothetical partners with different spin. Thus, we find possible evidence of scalar or pseudoscalar partners of the W+- and the Z, viz. at 53 and 57 GeV, respectively. Additionally, data may indicate excited states of the Z at 210 and 240 GeV.
We comment on the recent observation of chi_b states by the ATLAS Collaboration and contest their peremptory interpretation of the highest of the three observed structures as the chi_b(3P) system. Moreover, we do not agree that from their data the mass barycenter of the chi_b(3P) system can be determined.
We present further and more compelling evidence of the existence of E(38), a light boson that most probably couples exclusively to quarks and gluons. Observations presented in a prior paper will be rediscussed for completeness.
We briefly review the general status of meson spectroscopy, especially in light of the often made claim that there are too many observed resonances to be accounted for as $q\bar{q}$ states. Also, the adequacy of the usual Coulomb-plus-linear, alias "funnel", confining potential for reproducing the experimental spectra of light, heavy-light, and heavy mesons is critically analysed. Thus, many serious discrepancies are observed and discussed. As possible causes, we suggest the neglect of unitarisation and other coupled-channel effects, as well as the deficiency of the funnel potential itself. In order to illustrate our alternative, "unquenched" approach, we present some recent examples of successfully described puzzling mesonic enhancements and resonances, such as the charmonium states X(4260) and X(3872), as well as the axial-vector charmed mesons $D_1(2420)$, $D_1(2430)$, $D_{s1}(2536)$, and $D_{s1}(2460)$.
We reply to a very recent Comment arxiv:1204.2349 by Bernhard, Friedrich, Schlueter, and Schoenning for the COMPASS Collaboration, in which it is stated that Monte-Carlo simulations of COMPASS data do not support any interpretation of a peaked structure in diphoton invariant-mass distributions below the neutral pion mass in terms of a new resonance. Here we show, by directly comparing the simulations to the COMPASS data themselves, that the authors' claim is not substantiated by the Monte-Carlo results presented in the Comment.
The nature of the X(3872) enhancement is analysed in the framework of the Resonance-Spectrum Expansion, by studying it as a regular $J^{PC}=1^{++}$ charmonium state, though strongly influenced and shifted by open-charm decay channels. The observed but Okubo-Zweig-Iizuka-forbidden $ρ^0 J/ψ$ and $ωJ/ψ$ channels are coupled as well, but effectively smeared out by using complex $ρ^0$ and $ω$ masses, in order to account for their physical widths, followed by a rigorous algebraic procedure to restore unitarity. A very delicate interplay between the $D^0 D^{*0}$, $ρ^0 J/ψ$, and $ωJ/ψ$ channels is observed. The data clearly suggest that the X(3872) is a very narrow axial-vector $c\bar{c}$ resonance, with a pole at or slightly below the $D^0D^{*0}$ threshold.
We present evidence for the existence of a light scalar particle that most probably couples exclusively to gluons and quarks. Theoretical and phenomenological arguments are presented to support the existence of a light scalar boson for confinement and quark-pair creation. Previously observed interference effects allow to set a narrow window for the scalar's mass and also for its flavor-mass-dependent coupling to quarks. Here, in order to find a direct signal indicating its production, we study published BABAR data on leptonic bottomonium decays. We observe a clear excess signal in the invariant-mass projections of electron-positron and muon-antimuon, which may be due to the emission of a so far unobserved scalar particle with a mass of about 38 MeV. In the process of our analysis, we also find an indication of the existence of a bottomonium-like hybrid state at about 10.061 GeV. Further signals might be interpreted as replicas of the light scalar, with masses roughly two and three times as large.
Masses and widths of the charmed axial-vector mesons $D_1(2420)$, $D_1(2430)$, $D_{s1}(2536)$, and $D_{s1}(2460)$ are calculated nonperturbatively in the Resonance-Spectrum-Expansion model, by coupling various open and closed meson-meson channels to the bare $J^P=1^+$ $c\bar{q}$ ($q=u,d$) and $c\bar{s}$ states. The coupling to two-meson channels dynamically mixes and lifts the mass degeneracy of the spectroscopic $^3P_1$ and $^1P_1$ states, as an alternative to the usual spin-orbit splitting. Of the two resulting $S$-matrix poles in either case, one stays very close to the energy of the bare state, as a quasi-bound state in the continuum, whereas the other shifts considerably. This is in agreement with the experimental observation that the $D_1(2420)$ and $D_{s1}(2536)$ have much smaller widths than one would naively expect. The whole pattern of masses and widths of the axial-vector charmed mesons can thus be quite well reproduced with only two free parameters, one of which being already strongly constrained by previous model calculations. Finally, predictions for pole positions of radially excited axial-vector charmed mesons are presented.
Mesonic resonances are generally observed in data as narrow, moderately broad, or wide peaks in scattering or production processes. In the eyes of nearly all experimentalists, any suchlike bump is a true resonance as soon as its statistical significance exceeds certain minimal values. However, this simple point of view ignores possible effects from competing hadronic channels and the opening of the corresponding thresholds. On the other hand, most theoretical hadron-model builders consider mesons merely bound states of a quark and an antiquark, or of more exotic combinations sometimes involving valence gluons as well. Also the latter description is much too naive, since considerable mass shifts or even the dynamical generation of extra states due to unquenching are equally ignored. In the present paper, a largely empirical yet very successful approach to meson spectroscopy is revisited, in which all the above phenomena can be accounted for non-perturbatively, with concrete examples of some enigmatic mesonic states described in detail. First, the X(4260) charmonium enhancement is argued to be a non-resonant structure resulting from depletion effects due to competing channels and resonances. Then, the X(3872) charmonium-like meson is described as a unitarised $J^{PC}=1^{++}$ $c\bar{c}$ state. Also, the unusual pattern of masses and widths of the open-charm axial-vector mesons $D_1(2420)$, $D_1(2430)$, $D_{s1}(2536)$, and $D_{s1}(2460)$ is shown to follow from highly non-perturbative coupled-channel and mixing effects. Finally, first indications of a very light scalar boson are presented, on the basis of published BABAR data.
We argue that the X(4260) enhancement contains a wealth of information on vector c-cbar spectroscopy. We discuss the shape of the X(4260) observed in the OZI-forbidden process "electron-positron into J/psi and a pair of charged pions", in particular at and near vector charmonium resonances as well as open-charm threshold enhancements. The resulting very broad X(4260) structure does not seem to classify itself as a vector charmonium resonance, but its detailed shape allows to identify new vector c-cbar states. Here, we estimate the resonance parameters of the psi(3D) state.
Most excited hadrons have multiparticle strong decay modes, which can often be described as resulting from intermediate states containing one or two resonances. In a theoretical approach, such a description in terms of quasi-two-particle initial and final states leads to unitarity violations, because of the complex masses of the involved resonances. In the present paper, an empirical algebraic procedure is presented to restore unitarity of the S-matrix while preserving its symmetry. Preliminary results are presented in a first application to S-wave pion-pion scattering, in the framework of the Resonance-Spectrum Expansion.
We study meson-meson scattering in a soluble model which describes asymptotically free mesons and confined quark-antiquark pairs via coupled channels. Concretely, the two scattered mesons are assumed to interact through s-channel meson-exchange diagrams. Furthermore, we develop a perturbative expansion of the model, and show that the thus found resonance pole positions, including contributions up to fourth order in perturbation theory, completely fail to reproduce the exact results. This shows that the resonance predictions based on perturbative approximations in quark models may be highly unreliable.
We discuss the shape of threshold signals in production cross sections of the reaction e+ + e- --> D* + antiD*, at the opening of the D(s)* antiD(s)* and Lambda(c)+ Lambda(c)- channels. Furthermore, evidence for the 3D, 5S, 4D, 6S, 5D, 7S, 6D, and 8S charmonium vector resonances is presented, on the basis of data recently published by the BaBar Collaboration. Central masses and resonance widths are estimated. Confirmation of these resonances would be a huge step in lifting the precision level of hadron spectroscopy towards that of atomic spectroscopy, with far-reaching consequences for theory.
We present evidence for the psi(5S) and psi(4D) c-cbar vector resonances in experimental data published by the Belle and BaBar Collaborations. Central masses and resonance widths are estimated.
Threshold enhancements like the X(4660) and depletion effects as the X(4260) are listed as c-cbar resonances in the Particle Data Group tables. We will discuss these observations, and present a list of further c-cbar enhancements, which are more likely to represent true vector charmonium excitations. We will furthermore discuss the importance of the observed Z resonances, viz. Z(4050), Z(4250), and Z(4430), for the family of charm-strange mesons. Another piece of very important information that can be extracted from the present data is the universal, flavor independent frequency of 190 MeV for mesons, due to the quark-antiquark oscillations within the glue environment. Finally, we will show hints from the data at a further flavor-independent quantity, having a value of 76 +-2 MeV, the origin of which is not yet understood. Talk available at http://cft.fis.uc.pt/eef/Frascati2010start.htm
We analyse electron-positron data for b-bbar production published by the BABAR Collaboration, in the invariant-mass interval delimited by the B-Bbar and Lambda(b)-Lambda(b) thresholds. In particular, we describe the Upsilon(10580) enhancement, not as a b-bbar resonance, but rather as a threshold phenomenon due to the opening of the B-Bbar decay channel and enhanced by the Upsilon(2D) bound-state pole not far below this threshold. The same data provide evidence for the true Upsilon(4S) resonance, which we find at 10.735 GeV with a width of 38 MeV. At higher energies, two more known Upsilon resonances are observed by us in the data and classified. The vital role played in our analysis by the universal confinement frequency omega is again confirmed, via a comparison with the charmonium spectrum.
We show that, by taking a bare mass spectrum with constant spacings for the quark-antiquark propagators, which is subject to considerable mass shifts from meson loops, one adequately describes a large variety of mesonic resonances, from the light scalars to the b-bbar states. All our results indicate that a harmonic-oscilator spectrum with universal frequency, in combination with coupled-channel effects, does a much better job than the q-barq spectrum of the funnel potential.
We present evidence for small oscillations we observe in electron-positron and proton-antiproton annihilation data, with a periodicity of 76+-2 MeV, independent of the beam energy. We discuss some possible scenarios to explain the phenomenon.
We present evidence, from published BABAR data, for the existence of further excitations in the b-bbar spectrum, namely the long-awaited Upsilon(1D) and Upsilon(2D) with central masses of 10098 pm 5 MeV and 10492 pm 5 MeV, respectively. The significance of the Upsilon(1 3D1) and Upsilon(2 3D1) signals is found to be 3.0 and 10.7 standard deviations, respectively.
We argue that the spectra of quark-antiquark systems should better be studied from higher radial excitations and, in particular, from configurations with well-defined quantum numbers, rather than from ground states and lower radial excitations, the most suitable system being charmonium.
We comment on the recent observation of the decay mode D(sJ)(*)(2860)-->D(*)K by the BABAR Collaboration [arXiv:0908.0806], and contest their peremptory conclusion that the data exclude a 0(+) assignment for the D(sJ)(*)(2860). In particular, we argue that the observed branching fraction B(D(sJ)(*)(2860)-->D(*)K)/B(D(sJ)(*)(2860)-->DK)=1.1 pm 0.15 pm 0.19 supports the existence of two largely overlapping resonances at about 2.86 GeV, namely a pair of radially excited tensor 2(+) and scalar 0(+) c-sbar states. This scenario is further justified by comparing with the corresponding excited charmonium states. Also other aspects of the charm-strange spectrum are discussed.
A multichannel description of the light scalar mesons in the framework of the Resonance-Spectrum Expansion is generalised by including vector-vector and scalar-scalar channels, besides the usual pseudoscalar-pseudoscalar channels. Experimental data for the isoscalar, isodoublet and isovector cases are fitted up to energies well above 1 GeV. The resulting pole positions of the light and intermediate scalar mesons are compared to the listed resonances. Possible further improvements are discussed.
A multichannel calculation of excited $J^{PC}=1^{--}$ $ϕ$ states is carried out within a generalization of the Resonance-Spectrum Expansion, which may shed light on the classification of the $ϕ(2170)$ resonance, discovered by BABAR and originally denoted X(2175). In this framework, a complete spectrum of bare $s\bar{s}$ states is coupled to those OZI-allowed decay channels that should be most relevant for the considered energy range. The included $S$- and $P$-wave two-meson channels comprise the lowest pseudoscalar, vector, scalar, and axial-vector mesons, while in the $q\bar{q}$ sector both the $^{3}S_1$ and $^{3}D_1$ states are coupled. The only two free parameters are tuned so as to reproduce mass and width of the $ϕ(1020)$, but come out reasonably close to previously used values. Among the model's $T$-matrix poles, there are good candidates for observed resonances, as well other ones that should exist according to the quark model. Besides the expected resonances as unitarized confinement states, a dynamical resonance pole is found at $(2186-i246)$ MeV. The huge width makes its interpretation as the $ϕ(2170)$ somewhat dubious, but further improvements of the model may change this conclusion.
Relations between scattering and production amplitudes are studied in a microscopic multichannel model for meson-meson scattering, with coupling to confined quark-antiquark channels. Overlapping resonances and a proper threshold behaviour are treated exactly in the model. Under the spectator assumption, it is found that the two-particle production amplitude shares a common denominator with the elastic scattering amplitude, besides a numerator consisting of a linear combination of all elastic and some inelastic matrix elements. The coefficients in these linear combinations are shown to be generally complex. Finally, the standard operator expressions relating production and scattering amplitudes, viz. A=T/V and Im(A)=T*A, are fulfilled, while in the small-coupling limit the usual isobar model is recovered.
By comparing SU(3)-breaking scales of linear mass formulae, it is shown that the lowest vector and scalar mesons all have a $\bar{q}q$ configuration, while the ground-state octet and decuplet baryons are $qqq$. Also, the quark-level linear $σ$ model is employed to predict similar $\bar{q}q$ and $qqq$ states. Furthermore, the approximate mass degeneracy of the scalar $a_0$(985) and $f_0$(980) mesons is demonstrated to be accidental. Finally, it is shown that various strong, electromagnetic, and weak mesonic decay rates are successfully explained within the framework of the quark-level linear $σ$ model.