Bare quantum simultaneity versus classical interactivity in communication complexity
A relational bipartite communication problem is presented that has an efficient quantum simultaneous-messages protocol, but no efficient classical two-way protocol.
Researcher profile
Dmytro Gavinsky
Dmytro Gavinsky contributes to research discovery and scholarly infrastructure.
ResearcherAffiliation not importedOpen to collaborate
Trust snapshot
Quick read
Trust 21 - EmergingVerification L1Unclaimed author
25works
0followers
6topics
4close collaborators
Actions
Decide how to stay connected
Identity and collaboration
How to connect with this researcher
Claiming links this public author record to a researcher profile and unlocks direct collaboration workflows.
Log in to claimDirect collaboration
Open a focused conversation when the fit is right
Claim this author entity first to unlock direct invitations.
Research graph
See the researcher in context
Inspect adjacent work, topics, institutions and collaborators without jumping out to a separate graph page.
Building this graph slice
BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.
Published work
25 published item(s)
preprint2020arXiv
Entangled simultaneity versus classical interactivity in communication complexity
In 1999 Raz demonstrated a partial function that had an efficient quantum two-way communication protocol but no efficient classical two-way protocol and asked, whether there existed a function with an efficient quantum one-way protocol, but still no efficient classical two-way protocol. In 2010 Klartag and Regev demonstrated such a function and asked, whether there existed a function with an efficient quantum simultaneous-messages protocol, but still no efficient classical two-way protocol. In this work we answer the latter question affirmatively and present a partial function Shape, which can be computed by a protocol sending entangled simultaneous messages of poly-logarithmic size, and whose classical two-way complexity is lower bounded by a polynomial.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2020arXiv
Santha-Vazirani sources, deterministic condensers and very strong extractors
The notion of semi-random sources, also known as Santha-Vazirani (SV) sources, stands for a sequence of n bits, where the dependence of the i'th bit on the previous i-1 bits is limited for every $i\in[n]$. If the dependence of the i'th bit on the remaining n-1 bits is limited, then this is a strong SV-source. Even the strong SV-sources are known not to admit (universal) deterministic extractors, but they have seeded extractors, as their min-entropy is $Ω(n)$. It is intuitively obvious that strong SV-sources are more than just high-min-entropy sources, and this work explores the intuition. Deterministic condensers are known not to exist for general high-min-entropy sources, and we construct for any constants $ε, δ\in (0,1)$ a deterministic condenser that maps n bits coming from a strong SV-source with bias at most $δ$ to $Ω(n)$ bits of min-entropy rate at least $1-ε$. In conclusion we observe that deterministic condensers are closely related to very strong extractors - a proposed strengthening of the notion of strong (seeded) extractors: in particular, our constructions can be viewed as very strong extractors for the family of strong Santha-Vazirani distributions. The notion of very strong extractors requires that the output remains unpredictable even to someone who knows not only the seed value (as in the case of strong extractors), but also the extractor's outputs corresponding to the same input value with each of the preceding seed values (say, under the lexicographic ordering). Very strong extractors closely resemble the original notion of SV-sources, except that the bits must satisfy the unpredictability requirement only on average.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2020arXiv
The communication complexity of the inevitable intersection problem
Set disjointness is a central problem in communication complexity. Here Alice and Bob each receive a subset of an n-element universe, and they need to decide whether their inputs intersect or not. The communication complexity of this problem is relatively well understood, and in most models, including $-$ most famously $-$ interactive randomised communication with bounded error, the problem requires much communication. In this work we were looking for a variation of the set disjointness problem, as natural and simple as possible, for which the known lower bound methods would fail, and thus a new approach would be required in order to understand its complexity. The problem that we have found is a relational one: each player receives a subset as input, and the goal is to find an element that belongs to both players. We call it inevitable intersection.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2019arXiv
Quantum Algorithms for Evaluating MIN-MAX Trees
We present a bounded-error quantum algorithm for evaluating Min-Max trees. For a tree of size N our algorithm makes N^{1/2+o(1)} comparison queries, which is close to the optimal complexity for this problem.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2019arXiv
Quantum versus classical simultaneity in communication complexity
This work addresses two problems in the context of two-party communication complexity of functions. First, it concludes the line of research, which can be viewed as demonstrating qualitative advantage of quantum communication in the three most common communication "layouts": two-way interactive communication; one-way communication; simultaneous message passing (SMP). We demonstrate a functional problem, whose communication complexity is $O((\log n)^2)$ in the quantum version of SMP and $\tildeΩ(\sqrt n)$ in the classical (randomised) version of SMP. Second, this work contributes to understanding the power of the weakest commonly studied regime of quantum communication $-$ SMP with quantum messages and without shared randomness (the latter restriction can be viewed as a somewhat artificial way of making the quantum model "as weak as possible"). Our function has an efficient solution in this regime as well, which means that even lacking shared randomness, quantum SMP can be exponentially stronger than its classical counterpart with shared randomness.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2018arXiv
On the randomised query complexity of composition
Let $f\subseteq\{0,1\}^n\timesΞ$ be a relation and $g:\{0,1\}^m\to\{0,1,*\}$ be a promise function. This work investigates the randomised query complexity of the relation $f\circ g^n\subseteq\{0,1\}^{m\cdot n}\timesΞ$, which can be viewed as one of the most general cases of composition in the query model (letting $g$ be a relation seems to result in a rather unnatural definition of $f\circ g^n$). We show that for every such $f$ and $g$, $$\mathcal R(f\circ g^n) \in Ω(\mathcal R(f)\cdot\sqrt{\mathcal R(g)}),$$ where $\mathcal R$ denotes the randomised query complexity. On the other hand, we demonstrate a relation $f_0$ and a promise function $g_0$, such that $\mathcal R(f_0)\inΘ(\sqrt n)$, $\mathcal R(g_0)\inΘ(n)$ and $\mathcal R(f_0\circ g_0^n)\inΘ(n)$ $-$ that is, our composition statement is tight. To the best of our knowledge, there was no known composition theorem for the randomised query complexity of relations or promise functions (and for the special case of total functions our lower bound gives multiplicative improvement of $\sqrt{\log n}$).
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2016arXiv
On the Joint Entropy of $d$-Wise-Independent Variables
How low can the joint entropy of $n$ $d$-wise independent (for $d\ge2$) discrete random variables be, subject to given constraints on the individual distributions (say, no value may be taken by a variable with probability greater than $p$, for $p<1$)? This question has been posed and partially answered in a recent work of Babai. In this paper we improve some of his bounds, prove new bounds in a wider range of parameters and show matching upper bounds in some special cases. In particular, we prove tight lower bounds for the min-entropy (as well as the entropy) of pairwise and three-wise independent balanced binary variables for infinitely many values of $n$.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2015arXiv
Equality, Revisited
We develop a new lower bound method for analysing the complexity of the Equality function (EQ) in the Simultaneous Message Passing (SMP) model of communication complexity. The new technique gives tight lower bounds of $Ω(\sqrt n)$ for both EQ and its negation NE in the non-deterministic version of quantum-classical SMP, where Merlin is also quantum $-$ this is the strongest known version of SMP where the complexity of both EQ and NE remain high (previously known techniques seem to be insufficient for this). Besides, our analysis provides to a unified view of the communication complexity of EQ and NE, allowing to obtain tight characterisation in all previously studied and a few newly introduced versions of SMP, including all possible combination of either quantum or randomised Alice, Bob and Merlin in the non-deterministic case. Some of our results highlight that NE is easier than EQ in the presence of classical proofs, whereas the problems have (roughly) the same complexity when a quantum proof is present.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2014arXiv
Partition Expanders
We introduce a new concept, which we call partition expanders. The basic idea is to study quantitative properties of graphs in a slightly different way than it is in the standard definition of expanders. While in the definition of expanders it is required that the number of edges between any pair of sufficiently large sets is close to the expected number, we consider partitions and require this condition only for most of the pairs of blocks. As a result, the blocks can be substantially smaller. We show that for some range of parameters, to be a partition expander a random graph needs exponentially smaller degree than any expander would require in order to achieve similar expanding properties. We apply the concept of partition expanders in communication complexity. First, we give a PRG for the SMP model of the optimal seed length, n+O(log k). Second, we compare the model of SMP to that of Simultaneous Two-Way Communication, and give a new separation that is stronger both qualitatively and quantitatively than the previously known ones.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2012arXiv
A Tail Bound for Read-k Families of Functions
We prove a Chernoff-like large deviation bound on the sum of non-independent random variables that have the following dependence structure. The variables $Y_1,...,Y_r$ are arbitrary Boolean functions of independent random variables $X_1,...,X_m$, modulo a restriction that every $X_i$ influences at most $k$ of the variables $Y_1,...,Y_r$.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2012arXiv
Quantum Money with Classical Verification
We propose and construct a quantum money scheme that allows verification through classical communication with a bank. This is the first demonstration that a secure quantum money scheme exists that does not require quantum communication for coin verification. Our scheme is secure against adaptive adversaries - this property is not directly related to the possibility of classical verification, nevertheless none of the earlier quantum money constructions is known to possess it.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2012arXiv
Quantum Predictive Learning and Communication Complexity with Single Input
We define a new model of quantum learning that we call Predictive Quantum (PQ). This is a quantum analogue of PAC, where during the testing phase the student is only required to answer a polynomial number of testing queries. We demonstrate a relational concept class that is efficiently learnable in PQ, while in any "reasonable" classical model exponential amount of training data would be required. This is the first unconditional separation between quantum and classical learning. We show that our separation is the best possible in several ways; in particular, there is no analogous result for a functional class, as well as for several weaker versions of quantum learning. In order to demonstrate tightness of our separation we consider a special case of one-way communication that we call single-input mode, where Bob receives no input. Somewhat surprisingly, this setting becomes nontrivial when relational communication tasks are considered. In particular, any problem with two-sided input can be transformed into a single-input relational problem of equal classical one-way cost. We show that the situation is different in the quantum case, where the same transformation can make the communication complexity exponentially larger. This happens if and only if the original problem has exponential gap between quantum and classical one-way communication costs. We believe that these auxiliary results might be of independent interest.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2010arXiv
A Separation of NP and coNP in Multiparty Communication Complexity
We prove that NP differs from coNP and coNP is not a subset of MA in the number-on-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity for up to k = (1-ε)log(n) players, where ε>0 is any constant. Specifically, we construct a function F with co-nondeterministic complexity O(log(n)) and Merlin-Arthur complexity n^{Ω(1)}. The problem was open for k > 2.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2010arXiv
Quantum Fingerprints that Keep Secrets
We introduce a new type of cryptographic primitive that we call hiding fingerprinting. A (quantum) fingerprinting scheme translates a binary string of length $n$ to $d$ (qu)bits, typically $d\ll n$, such that given any string $y$ and a fingerprint of $x$, one can decide with high accuracy whether $x=y$. Classical fingerprinting schemes cannot hide information very well: a classical fingerprint of $x$ that guarantees error at most $ε$ necessarily reveals $Ω(\log(1/ epsilon))$ bits about $x$. We call a scheme hiding if it reveals $o(\log(1/ε))$ bits; accordingly, no classical scheme is hiding. For any constant $c$, we construct two kinds of hiding fingerprinting schemes, both mapping $n$-bit strings to $O(\log n)$ qubits and guaranteeing one-sided error probability at most $1/n^c$. The first kind uses pure states and leaks at most O(1) bits, and the second kind uses mixed states and leaks at most $1/n^c$ bits, where the "leakage" is bounded via accessible information. The schemes are computationally efficient. Our mixed-state scheme is optimal, as shown via a generic strategy that extracts $1/\poly(n)$ bits from any fingerprint over $O(\log n)$ qubits.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2009arXiv
Classical Interaction Cannot Replace Quantum Nonlocality
We present a two-player communication task that can be solved by a protocol of polylogarithmic cost in the simultaneous message passing model with classical communication and shared entanglement, but requires exponentially more communication in the classical interactive model. Our second result is a two-player nonlocality game with input length $n$ and output of polylogarithmic length, that can be won with probability 1-o(1) by players sharing polylogarithmic amount of entanglement. On the other hand, the game is lost with probability $Ω(1)$ by players without entanglement, even if they are allowed to exchange up to k bits in interactive communication for certain $k\inΩ(n^{1/4})$. These two results give almost the strongest possible (and the strongest known) indication of nonlocal properties of two-party entanglement.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2008arXiv
Classical Interaction Cannot Replace a Quantum Message
We demonstrate a two-player communication problem that can be solved in the one-way quantum model by a 0-error protocol of cost O (log n) but requires exponentially more communication in the classical interactive (bounded error) model.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2008arXiv
Exponential separations for one-way quantum communication complexity, with applications to cryptography
We give an exponential separation between one-way quantum and classical communication protocols for a partial Boolean function (a variant of the Boolean Hidden Matching Problem of Bar-Yossef et al.) Earlier such an exponential separation was known only for a relational problem. The communication problem corresponds to a \emph{strong extractor} that fails against a small amount of \emph{quantum} information about its random source. Our proof uses the Fourier coefficients inequality of Kahn, Kalai, and Linial. We also give a number of applications of this separation. In particular, we show that there are privacy amplification schemes that are secure against classical adversaries but not against quantum adversaries; and we give the first example of a key-expansion scheme in the model of bounded-storage cryptography that is secure against classical memory-bounded adversaries but not against quantum ones.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2007arXiv
Exponential Separation of Quantum and Classical Non-Interactive Multi-Party Communication Complexity
We give the first exponential separation between quantum and classical multi-party communication complexity in the (non-interactive) one-way and simultaneous message passing settings. For every k, we demonstrate a relational communication problem between k parties that can be solved exactly by a quantum simultaneous message passing protocol of cost O(log n) and requires protocols of cost n^{c/k^2}, where c>0 is a constant, in the classical non-interactive one-way message passing model with shared randomness and bounded error. Thus our separation of corresponding communication classes is superpolynomial as long as k=o(\sqrt{\log n / \log\log n}) and exponential for k=O(1).
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2006arXiv
Exponential Separation of Quantum and Classical One-Way Communication Complexity for a Boolean Function
We give an exponential separation between one-way quantum and classical communication complexity for a Boolean function. Earlier such a separation was known only for a relation. A very similar result was obtained earlier but independently by Kerenidis and Raz [KR06]. Our version of the result gives an example in the bounded storage model of cryptography, where the key is secure if the adversary has a certain amount of classical storage, but is completely insecure if he has a similar amount of quantum storage.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2006arXiv
On the Role of Shared Entanglement
Despite the apparent similarity between shared randomness and shared entanglement in the context of Communication Complexity, our understanding of the latter is not as good as of the former. In particular, there is no known "entanglement analogue" for the famous theorem by Newman, saying that the number of shared random bits required for solving any communication problem can be at most logarithmic in the input length (i.e., using more than O(log n) shared random bits would not reduce the complexity of an optimal solution). In this paper we prove that the same is not true for entanglement. We establish a wide range of tight (up to a polylogarithmic factor) entanglement vs. communication tradeoffs for relational problems. The low end is: for any t>2, reducing shared entanglement from log^t(n) to o(log^{t-2}(n)) qubits can increase the communication required for solving a problem almost exponentially, from O(log^t(n)) to Ω(\sqrt n). The high end is: for any \eps>0, reducing shared entanglement from n^{1-\eps}log(n) to o(n^{1-\eps}/log(n)) can increase the required communication from O(n^{1-\eps}log(n)) to Ω(n^{1-\eps/2}/log(n)). The upper bounds are demonstrated via protocols which are exact and work in the \e{simultaneous message passing model}, while the lower bounds hold for \e{bounded-error protocols}, even in the more powerful \e{model of 1-way communication}. Our protocols use shared EPR pairs while the lower bounds apply to any sort of prior entanglement. We base the lower bounds on a strong direct product theorem for communication complexity of a certain class of relational problems. We believe that the theorem might have applications outside the scope of this work.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2006arXiv
Strengths and Weaknesses of Quantum Fingerprinting
We study the power of quantum fingerprints in the simultaneous message passing (SMP) setting of communication complexity. Yao recently showed how to simulate, with exponential overhead, classical shared-randomness SMP protocols by means of quantum SMP protocols without shared randomness ($Q^\parallel$-protocols). Our first result is to extend Yao's simulation to the strongest possible model: every many-round quantum protocol with unlimited shared entanglement can be simulated, with exponential overhead, by $Q^\parallel$-protocols. We apply our technique to obtain an efficient $Q^\parallel$-protocol for a function which cannot be efficiently solved through more restricted simulations. Second, we tightly characterize the power of the quantum fingerprinting technique by making a connection to arrangements of homogeneous halfspaces with maximal margin. These arrangements have been well studied in computational learning theory, and we use some strong results obtained in this area to exhibit weaknesses of quantum fingerprinting. In particular, this implies that for almost all functions, quantum fingerprinting protocols are exponentially worse than classical deterministic SMP protocols.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2005arXiv
A Note on Shared Randomness and Shared Entanglement in Communication
We consider several models of 1-round classical and quantum communication, some of these models have not been defined before. We "almost separate" the models of simultaneous quantum message passing with shared entanglement and the model of simultaneous quantum message passing with shared randomness. We define a relation which can be efficiently exactly solved in the first model but cannot be solved efficiently, either exactly or in 0-error setup in the second model. In fact, our relation is exactly solvable even in a more restricted model of simultaneous classical message passing with shared entanglement. As our second contribution we strengthen a result by Yao that a "very short" protocol from the model of simultaneous classical message passing with shared randomness can be simulated in the model of simultaneous quantum message passing: for a boolean function f, QII(f) \in exp(O(RIIp(f))) log n. We show a similar result for protocols from a (stronger) model of 1-way classical message passing with shared randomness: QII(f) \in exp(O(RIp(f))) log n. We demonstrate a problem whose efficient solution in the model of simultaneous quantum message passing follows from our result but not from Yao's.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2005arXiv
Bounded-Error Quantum State Identification and Exponential Separations in Communication Complexity
We consider the problem of bounded-error quantum state identification: given either state α_0 or state α_1, we are required to output `0', `1' or `?' ("don't know"), such that conditioned on outputting `0' or `1', our guess is correct with high probability. The goal is to maximize the probability of not outputting `?'. We prove a direct product theorem: if we're given two such problems, with optimal probabilities a and b, respectively, and the states in the first problem are pure, then the optimal probability for the joint bounded-error state identification problem is O(ab). Our proof is based on semidefinite programming duality and may be of wider interest. Using this result, we present two exponential separations in the simultaneous message passing model of communication complexity. Both are shown in the strongest possible sense. First, we describe a relation that can be computed with O(log n) classical bits of communication in the presence of shared randomness, but needs Omega(n^{1/3}) communication if the parties don't share randomness, even if communication is quantum. This shows the optimality of Yao's recent exponential simulation of shared-randomness protocols by quantum protocols without shared randomness. Second, we describe a relation that can be computed with O(log n) classical bits of communication in the presence of shared entanglement, but needs Omega((n/log n)^{1/3}) communication if the parties share randomness but no entanglement, even if communication is quantum. This is the first example in communication complexity of a situation where entanglement buys you much more than quantum communication does.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2004arXiv
Quantum Communication Cannot Simulate a Public Coin
We study the simultaneous message passing model of communication complexity. Building on the quantum fingerprinting protocol of Buhrman et al., Yao recently showed that a large class of efficient classical public-coin protocols can be turned into efficient quantum protocols without public coin. This raises the question whether this can be done always, i.e. whether quantum communication can always replace a public coin in the SMP model. We answer this question in the negative, exhibiting a communication problem where classical communication with public coin is exponentially more efficient than quantum communication. Together with a separation in the other direction due to Bar-Yossef et al., this shows that the quantum SMP model is incomparable with the classical public-coin SMP model. In addition we give a characterization of the power of quantum fingerprinting by means of a connection to geometrical tools from machine learning, a quadratic improvement of Yao's simulation, and a nearly tight analysis of the Hamming distance problem from Yao's paper.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access