Source author record

C. Emre Koksal

C. Emre Koksal appears in the imported research catalog. Authorship, coauthor and topic links are available while profile ownership is still unclaimed.

ResearcherUnclaimed source record

Catalog footprint

What is connected

25works
8topics
4close collaborators

Actions

Connect this record

Log in to claim

Research graph

See the researcher in context

Open full explorer

Inspect adjacent papers, topics, institutions and collaborators without losing the researcher page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Published work

25 published item(s)

preprint2021arXiv

Achieving Positive Covert Capacity over MIMO AWGN Channels

We consider covert communication, i.e., hiding the presence of communication from an adversary for multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) channels. We characterize the maximum covert coding rate under a variety of settings, including different regimes where either the number of transmit antennas or the blocklength is scaled up. We show that a non-zero covert capacity can be achieved in the massive MIMO regime in which the number of transmit antennas scales up but under specific conditions. Under such conditions, we show that the covert capacity of MIMO AWGN channels converges the capacity of MIMO AWGN channels. Furthermore, we derive the order-optimal scaling of the number of covert bits in the regime where the covert capacity is zero. We provide an insightful comparative analysis of different cases in which secrecy and energy-undetectability constraints are imposed separately or jointly.

preprint2021arXiv

How Long to Estimate Sparse MIMO Channels

Large MIMO transceivers are integral components of next-generation wireless networks. However, for such systems to be practical, their channel estimation process needs to be fast and reliable. Although several solutions for fast estimation of sparse channels do exist, there is still a gap in understanding the fundamental limits governing this problem. Specifically, we need to better understand the lower bound on the number of measurements under which accurate channel estimates can be obtained. This work bridges that knowledge gap by deriving a tight asymptotic lower bound on the number of measurements. This not only helps develop a better understanding for the sparse MIMO channel estimation problem, but it also provides a benchmark for evaluating current and future solutions.

preprint2021arXiv

Quickest Detection over Sensor Networks with Unknown Post-Change Distribution

We propose a quickest change detection problem over sensor networks where both the subset of sensors undergoing a change and the local post-change distributions are unknown. Each sensor in the network observes a local discrete time random process over a finite alphabet. Initially, the observations are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) with known pre-change distributions independent from other sensors. At a fixed but unknown change point, a fixed but unknown subset of the sensors undergo a change and start observing samples from an unknown distribution. We assume the change can be quantified using concave (or convex) local statistics over the space of distributions. We propose an asymptotically optimal and computationally tractable stopping time for Lorden's criterion. Under this scenario, our proposed method uses a concave global cumulative sum (CUSUM) statistic at the fusion center and suppresses the most likely false alarms using information projection. Finally, we show some numerical results of the simulation of our algorithm for the problem described.

preprint2016arXiv

Message Authentication and Secret Key Agreement in VANETs via Angle of Arrival

In the scope of VANETs, nature of exchanged safety/warning messages renders itself highly location dependent as it is usually for incident reporting. Thus, vehicles are required to periodically exchange beacon messages that include speed, time and GPS location information. In this paper paper, we present a physical layer assisted message authentication scheme that uses Angle of Arrival (AoA) estimation to verify the message originator location based on the claimed location information. Within the considered vehicular communication settings, fundamental limits of AoA estimation are developed in terms of its Cramer Rao Bound (CRB) and existence of efficient estimator. The problem of deciding whether the received signal is originated from the claimed GPS location is formulated as a two sided hypotheses testing problem whose solution is given by Wald test statics. Moreover, we use correct decision, $P_D$, and false alarm, $P_F$, probabilities as a quantitative performance measure. The observation posterior likelihood function is shown to satisfy regularity conditions necessary for asymptotic normality of the ML-AoA estimator. Thus, we give $P_D$ and $P_F$ in a closed form. We extend the potential of physical layer contribution in security to provide physical layer assisted secret key agreement (SKA) protocol. A public key (PK) based SKA in which communicating vehicles are required to validate their respective physical location. We show that the risk of the Man in the Middle attack, which is common in PK-SKA protocols without a trusted third party, is waived up to the literal meaning of the word "middle".

preprint2016arXiv

On The Security of AoA Estimation

Angle of Arrival (AoA) estimation has found its way to a wide range of applications. Much attention have been paid to study different techniques for AoA estimation and its applications for jamming suppression, however, security vulnerability issues of AoA estimation itself under hostile activity have not been paid the same attention. In this paper, the problem of AoA estimation in Rician flat fading channel under jamming condition is investigated. We consider the scenario in which a receiver with multiple antenna is trying to estimate the AoA of the specular line of sight (LOS) component of signal received from a given single antenna transmitter using a predefined training sequence. A jammer equipped with multiple antennas is trying to interrupt the AoA estimation phase by sending an arbitrary signal. We derive the optimal jammer and receiver strategies in various scenarios based on the knowledge of the opponent strategies and the available information about the communication channel. In all scenarios, we derive the optimal jammer signal design as well as its optimal power allocation policy. The results show the optimality of the training based Maximum Likelihood (ML) AoA estimator in case of randomly generated jamming signal. We also show that, the optimal jammer strategy is to emit a signal identical to the predefined training sequence turning the estimation process into a highest power competition scenario in which the detected AoA is the one for the transmitting entity of higher power. The obtained results are supported by the provided computer simulation.

preprint2016arXiv

Physical Layer Security in Massive MIMO

We consider a single-cell downlink massive MIMO communication in the presence of an adversary capable of jamming and eavesdropping simultaneously. We show that massive MIMO communication is naturally resilient to no training-phase jamming attack in which the adversary jams only the data communication and eavesdrops both the data communication and the training. Specifically, we show that the secure degrees of freedom (DoF) attained in the presence of such an attack is identical to the maximum DoF attained under no attack. Further, we evaluate the number of antennas that base station (BS) requires in order to establish information theoretic security without even a need for Wyner encoding. Next, we show that things are completely different once the adversary starts jamming the training phase. Specifically, we consider an attack, called training-phase jamming in which the adversary jams and eavesdrops both the training and the data communication. We show that under such an attack, the maximum secure DoF is equal to zero. Furthermore, the maximum achievable rates of users vanish even in the asymptotic regime in the number of BS antennas. To counter this attack, we develop a defense strategy in which we use a secret key to encrypt the pilot sequence assignments to hide them from the adversary, rather than encrypt the data. We show that, if the cardinality of the set of pilot signals are scaled appropriately, hiding the pilot signal assignments from the adversary enables the users to achieve secure DoF, identical to the maximum achievable DoF under no attack. Finally, we discuss how computational cryptography is a legitimate candidate to hide the pilot signal assignments. Indeed, while information theoretic security is not achieved with cryptography, the computational power necessary for the adversary to achieve a non-zero mutual information leakage rate goes to infinity.

preprint2015arXiv

Dynamic Network Control for Confidential Multi-hop Communications

We consider the problem of resource allocation and control of multihop networks in which multiple source-destination pairs communicate confidential messages, to be kept confidential from the intermediate nodes. We pose the problem as that of network utility maximization, into which confidentiality is incorporated as an additional quality of service constraint. We develop a simple, and yet provably optimal dynamic control algorithm that combines flow control, routing and end-to-end secrecy-encoding. In order to achieve confidentiality, our scheme exploits multipath diversity and temporal diversity due to channel variability. Our end-to-end dynamic encoding scheme encodes confidential messages across multiple packets, to be combined at the ultimate destination for recovery. We first develop an optimal dynamic policy for the case in which the number of blocks across which secrecy encoding is performed is asymptotically large. Next, we consider encoding across a finite number of packets, which eliminates the possibility of achieving perfect secrecy. For this case, we develop a dynamic policy to choose the encoding rates for each message, based on the instantaneous channel state information, queue states and secrecy outage requirements. By numerical analysis, we observe that the proposed scheme approaches the optimal rates asymptotically with increasing block size. Finally, we address the consequences of practical implementation issues such as infrequent queue updates and de-centralized scheduling. We demonstrate the efficacy of our policies by numerical studies under various network conditions.

preprint2015arXiv

Provably Delay Efficient Data Retrieving in Storage Clouds

One key requirement for storage clouds is to be able to retrieve data quickly. Recent system measurements have shown that the data retrieving delay in storage clouds is highly variable, which may result in a long latency tail. One crucial idea to improve the delay performance is to retrieve multiple data copies by using parallel downloading threads. However, how to optimally schedule these downloading threads to minimize the data retrieving delay remains to be an important open problem. In this paper, we develop low-complexity thread scheduling policies for several important classes of data downloading time distributions, and prove that these policies are either delay-optimal or within a constant gap from the optimum delay performance. These theoretical results hold for an arbitrary arrival process of read requests that may contain finite or infinite read requests, and for heterogeneous MDS storage codes that can support diverse storage redundancy and reliability requirements for different data files. Our numerical results show that the delay performance of the proposed policies is significantly better than that of First-Come- First-Served (FCFS) policies considered in prior work.

preprint2014arXiv

Delay Optimal Secrecy in Two-Relay Network

We consider a two-relay network in which a source aims to communicate a confidential message to a destination while keeping the message secret from the relay nodes. In the first hop, the channels from the source to the relays are assumed to be block-fading and the channel states change arbitrarily -possibly non-stationary and non-ergodic- across blocks. When the relay feedback on the states of the source-to-relay channels is available on the source with no delay, we provide an encoding strategy to achieve the optimal delay. We next consider the case in which there is one-block delayed relay feedback on the states of the source-to-relay channels. We show that for a set of channel state sequences, the optimal delay with one-block delayed feedback differs from the optimal delay with no-delayed feedback at most one block.

preprint2014arXiv

Network Control without CSI using Rateless Codes for Downlink Cellular Systems

Wireless network scheduling and control techniques (e.g., opportunistic scheduling) rely heavily on access to Channel State Information (CSI). However, obtaining this information is costly in terms of bandwidth, time, and power, and could result in large overhead. Therefore, a critical question is how to optimally manage network resources in the absence of such information. To that end, we develop a cross-layer solution for downlink cellular systems with imperfect (and possibly no) CSI at the transmitter. We use rateless codes to resolve channel uncertainty. To keep the decoding complexity low, we explicitly incorporate time-average block-size constraints, and aim to maximize the system utility. The block-size of a rateless code is determined by both the network control decisions and the unknown CSI of many time slots. Therefore, unlike standard utility maximization problems, this problem can be viewed as a constrained partial observed Markov decision problem (CPOMDP), which is known to be hard due to the "curse of dimensionality." However, by using a modified Lyapunov drift method, we develop a dynamic network control scheme, which yields a total network utility within O(1/Lav) of utility-optimal point achieved by infinite block-size channel codes, where Lav is the enforced value of the time-average block-size of rateless codes. This opens the door of being able to trade complexity/delay for performance gains in the absence of accurate CSI. Our simulation results show that the proposed scheme improves the network throughput by up to 68% over schemes that use fixed-rate codes.

preprint2014arXiv

Scheduling of Multicast and Unicast Services under Limited Feedback by using Rateless Codes

Many opportunistic scheduling techniques are impractical because they require accurate channel state information (CSI) at the transmitter. In this paper, we investigate the scheduling of unicast and multicast services in a downlink network with a very limited amount of feedback information. Specifically, unicast users send imperfect (or no) CSI and infrequent acknowledgements (ACKs) to a base station, and multicast users only report infrequent ACKs to avoid feedback implosion. We consider the use of physical-layer rateless codes, which not only combats channel uncertainty, but also reduces the overhead of ACK feedback. A joint scheduling and power allocation scheme is developed to realize multiuser diversity gain for unicast service and multicast gain for multicast service. We prove that our scheme achieves a near-optimal throughput region. Our simulation results show that our scheme significantly improves the network throughput over schemes employing fixed-rate codes or using only unicast communications.

preprint2014arXiv

Secret Key Generation Via Localization and Mobility

We consider secret key generation from relative localization information of a pair of nodes in a mobile wireless network in the presence of a mobile eavesdropper. Our problem can be categorized under the source models of information theoretic secrecy, where the distance between the legitimate nodes acts as the observed common randomness. We characterize the theoretical limits on the achievable secret key bit rate, in terms of the observation noise variance at the legitimate nodes and the eavesdropper. This work provides a framework that combines information theoretic secrecy and wireless localization, and proves that the localization information provides a significant additional resource for secret key generation in mobile wireless networks.

preprint2013arXiv

Capacity of Compound MIMO Gaussian Channels with Additive Uncertainty

This paper considers reliable communications over a multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) Gaussian channel, where the channel matrix is within a bounded channel uncertainty region around a nominal channel matrix, i.e., an instance of the compound MIMO Gaussian channel. We study the optimal transmit covariance matrix design to achieve the capacity of compound MIMO Gaussian channels, where the channel uncertainty region is characterized by the spectral norm. This design problem is a challenging non-convex optimization problem. However, in this paper, we reveal that this problem has a hidden convexity property, which can be exploited to map the problem into a convex optimization problem. We first prove that the optimal transmit design is to diagonalize the nominal channel, and then show that the duality gap between the capacity of the compound MIMO Gaussian channel and the min-max channel capacity is zero, which proves the conjecture of Loyka and Charalambous (IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, vol. 58, no. 4, pp. 2048-2063, 2012). The key tools for showing these results are a new matrix determinant inequality and some unitarily invariant properties.

preprint2013arXiv

On the Secrecy Capacity of Block Fading Channels with a Hybrid Adversary

We consider a block fading wiretap channel, where a transmitter attempts to send messages securely to a receiver in the presence of a hybrid half-duplex adversary, which arbitrarily decides to either jam or eavesdrop the transmitter-to- receiver channel. We provide bounds to the secrecy capacity for various possibilities on receiver feedback and show special cases where the bounds are tight. We show that, without any feedback from the receiver, the secrecy capacity is zero if the transmitter-to-adversary channel stochastically dominates the effective transmitter-to-receiver channel. However, the secrecy capacity is non-zero even when the receiver is allowed to feed back only one bit at the end of each block. Our novel achievable strategy improves the rates proposed in the literature for the non-hybrid adversarial model. We also analyze the effect of multiple adversaries and delay constraints on the secrecy capacity. We show that our novel time sharing approach leads to positive secrecy rates even under strict delay constraints.

preprint2013arXiv

To Obtain or not to Obtain CSI in the Presence of Hybrid Adversary

We consider the wiretap channel model under the presence of a hybrid, half duplex adversary that is capable of either jamming or eavesdropping at a given time. We analyzed the achievable rates under a variety of scenarios involving different methods for obtaining transmitter CSI. Each method provides a different grade of information, not only to the transmitter on the main channel, but also to the adversary on all channels. Our analysis shows that main CSI is more valuable for the adversary than the jamming CSI in both delay-limited and ergodic scenarios. Similarly, in certain cases under the ergodic scenario, interestingly, no CSI may lead to higher achievable secrecy rates than with CSI.

preprint2012arXiv

A Greedy Link Scheduler for Wireless Networks with Fading Channels

We consider the problem of link scheduling for wireless networks with fading channels, where the link rates are varying with time. Due to the high computational complexity of the throughput optimal scheduler, we provide a low complexity greedy link scheduler GFS, with provable performance guarantees. We show that the performance of our greedy scheduler can be analyzed using the Local Pooling Factor (LPF) of a network graph, which has been previously used to characterize the stability of the Greedy Maximal Scheduling (GMS) policy for networks with static channels. We conjecture that the performance of GFS is a lower bound on the performance of GMS for wireless networks with fading channels

preprint2012arXiv

Control of Wireless Networks with Secrecy

We consider the problem of cross-layer resource allocation in time-varying cellular wireless networks, and incorporate information theoretic secrecy as a Quality of Service constraint. Specifically, each node in the network injects two types of traffic, private and open, at rates chosen in order to maximize a global utility function, subject to network stability and secrecy constraints. The secrecy constraint enforces an arbitrarily low mutual information leakage from the source to every node in the network, except for the sink node. We first obtain the achievable rate region for the problem for single and multi-user systems assuming that the nodes have full CSI of their neighbors. Then, we provide a joint flow control, scheduling and private encoding scheme, which does not rely on the knowledge of the prior distribution of the gain of any channel. We prove that our scheme achieves a utility, arbitrarily close to the maximum achievable utility. Numerical experiments are performed to verify the analytical results, and to show the efficacy of the dynamic control algorithm.

preprint2012arXiv

Energy Efficient Greedy Link Scheduling and Power Control in wireless networks

We consider the problem of joint link scheduling and power control for wireless networks with average transmission power constraints. Due to the high computational complexity of the optimal policies, we extend the class of greedy link scheduling policies to handle average power constraints. We develop a greedy link scheduling and power control scheme GECS, with provable performance guarantees. We show that the performance of our greedy scheduler can be characterized using the Local Pooling Factor (LPF) of a network graph, which has been previously used to characterize the stability of the Greedy Maximal Scheduling (GMS) policy for wireless networks. We also simulate the performance of GECS on wireless network, and compare its performance to another candidate greedy link scheduling and power control policy.

preprint2012arXiv

Performance Bounds and Associated Design Principles for Multi-Cellular Wireless OFDMA Systems (with Detailed Proofs)

In this paper, we consider the downlink of large-scale multi-cellular OFDMA-based networks and study performance bounds of the system as a function of the number of users $K$, the number of base-stations $B$, and the number of resource-blocks $N$. Here, a resource block is a collection of subcarriers such that all such collections, that are disjoint have associated independently fading channels. We derive novel upper and lower bounds on the sum-utility for a general spatial geometry of base stations, a truncated path loss model, and a variety of fading models (Rayleigh, Nakagami-$m$, Weibull, and LogNormal). We also establish the associated scaling laws and show that, in the special case of fixed number of resource blocks, a grid-based network of base stations, and Rayleigh-fading channels, the sum information capacity of the system scales as $Θ(B \log\log K/B)$ for extended networks, and as $O(B \log\log K)$ and $Ω(\log \log K)$ for dense networks. Interpreting these results, we develop some design principles for the service providers along with some guidelines for the regulators in order to achieve provisioning of various QoS guarantees for the end users and, at the same time, maximize revenue for the service providers.

preprint2011arXiv

A Greedy link scheduler for Wireless Networks having Gaussian Broadcast and Multiple Access Channels

Information theoretic Broadcast Channels (BC) and Multiple Access Channels (MAC) enable a single node to transmit data simultaneously to multiple nodes, and multiple nodes to transmit data simultaneously to a single node respectively. In this paper, we address the problem of link scheduling in multihop wireless networks containing nodes with BC and MAC capabilities. We first propose an interference model that extends protocol interference models, originally designed for point to point channels, to include the possibility of BC and MAC. Due to the high complexity of optimal link schedulers, we introduce the Multiuser Greedy Maximum Weight algorithm for link scheduling in multihop wireless networks containing BCs and MACs. Given a network graph, we develop new local pooling conditions and show that the performance of our algorithm can be fully characterized using the associated parameter, the multiuser local pooling factor. We provide examples of some network graphs, on which we apply local pooling conditions and derive the multiuser local pooling factor. We prove optimality of our algorithm in tree networks and show that the exploitation of BCs and MACs improve the throughput performance considerably in multihop wireless networks.

preprint2011arXiv

Joint Scheduling and Resource Allocation in OFDMA Downlink Systems via ACK/NAK Feedback

In this paper, we consider the problem of joint scheduling and resource allocation in the OFDMA downlink, with the goal of maximizing an expected long-term goodput-based utility subject to an instantaneous sum-power constraint, and where the feedback to the base station consists only of ACK/NAKs from recently scheduled users. We first establish that the optimal solution is a partially observable Markov decision process (POMDP), which is impractical to implement. In response, we propose a greedy approach to joint scheduling and resource allocation that maintains a posterior channel distribution for every user, and has only polynomial complexity. For frequency-selective channels with Markov time-variation, we then outline a recursive method to update the channel posteriors, based on the ACK/NAK feedback, that is made computationally efficient through the use of particle filtering. To gauge the performance of our greedy approach relative to that of the optimal POMDP, we derive a POMDP performance upper-bound. Numerical experiments show that, for slowly fading channels, the performance of our greedy scheme is relatively close to the upper bound, and much better than fixed-power random user scheduling (FP-RUS), despite its relatively low complexity.

preprint2011arXiv

Joint Scheduling and Resource Allocation in the OFDMA Downlink: Utility Maximization under Imperfect Channel-State Information

We consider the problem of simultaneous user-scheduling, power-allocation, and rate-selection in an OFDMA downlink, with the goal of maximizing expected sum-utility under a sum-power constraint. In doing so, we consider a family of generic goodput-based utilities that facilitate, e.g., throughput-based pricing, quality-of-service enforcement, and/or the treatment of practical modulation-and-coding schemes (MCS). Since perfect knowledge of channel state information (CSI) may be difficult to maintain at the base-station, especially when the number of users and/or subchannels is large, we consider scheduling and resource allocation under imperfect CSI, where the channel state is described by a generic probability distribution. First, we consider the "continuous" case where multiple users and/or code rates can time-share a single OFDMA subchannel and time slot. This yields a non-convex optimization problem that we convert into a convex optimization problem and solve exactly using a dual optimization approach. Second, we consider the "discrete" case where only a single user and code rate is allowed per OFDMA subchannel per time slot. For the mixed-integer optimization problem that arises, we discuss the connections it has with the continuous case and show that it can solved exactly in some situations. For the other situations, we present a bound on the optimality gap. For both cases, we provide algorithmic implementations of the obtained solution. Finally, we study, numerically, the performance of the proposed algorithms under various degrees of CSI uncertainty, utilities, and OFDMA system configurations. In addition, we demonstrate advantages relative to existing state-of-the-art algorithms.

preprint2011arXiv

Robust Rate-Adaptive Wireless Communication Using ACK/NAK-Feedback

To combat the detrimental effects of the variability in wireless channels, we consider cross-layer rate adaptation based on limited feedback. In particular, based on limited feedback in the form of link-layer acknowledgements (ACK) and negative acknowledgements (NAK), we maximize the physical-layer transmission rate subject to an upper bound on the expected packet error rate. \textr{We take a robust approach in that we do not assume} any particular prior distribution on the channel state. We first analyze the fundamental limitations of such systems and derive an upper bound on the achievable rate for signaling schemes based on uncoded QAM and random Gaussian ensembles. We show that, for channel estimation based on binary ACK/NAK feedback, it may be preferable to use a separate training sequence at high error rates, rather than to exploit low-error-rate data packets themselves. We also develop an adaptive recursive estimator, which is provably asymptotically optimal and asymptotically efficient.

preprint2011arXiv

Secrecy Outage Capacity of Fading Channels

This paper considers point to point secure communication over flat fading channels under an outage constraint. More specifically, we extend the definition of outage capacity to account for the secrecy constraint and obtain sharp characterizations of the corresponding fundamental limits under two different assumptions on the transmitter CSI (Channel state information). First, we find the outage secrecy capacity assuming that the transmitter has perfect knowledge of the legitimate and eavesdropper channel gains. In this scenario, the capacity achieving scheme relies on opportunistically exchanging private keys between the legitimate nodes. These keys are stored in a key buffer and later used to secure delay sensitive data using the Vernam's one time pad technique. We then extend our results to the more practical scenario where the transmitter is assumed to know only the legitimate channel gain. Here, our achievability arguments rely on privacy amplification techniques to generate secret key bits. In the two cases, we also characterize the optimal power control policies which, interestingly, turn out to be a judicious combination of channel inversion and the optimal ergodic strategy. Finally, we analyze the effect of key buffer overflow on the overall outage probability.

preprint2010arXiv

On Secrecy Capacity Scaling in Wireless Networks

This work studies the achievable secure rate per source-destination pair in wireless networks. First, a path loss model is considered, where the legitimate and eavesdropper nodes are assumed to be placed according to Poisson point processes with intensities $λ$ and $λ_e$, respectively. It is shown that, as long as $λ_e/λ=o((\log n)^{-2})$, almost all of the nodes achieve a perfectly secure rate of $Ω(\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}})$ for the extended and dense network models. Therefore, under these assumptions, securing the network does not entail a loss in the per-node throughput. The achievability argument is based on a novel multi-hop forwarding scheme where randomization is added in every hop to ensure maximal ambiguity at the eavesdropper(s). Secondly, an ergodic fading model with $n$ source-destination pairs and $n_e$ eavesdroppers is considered. Employing the ergodic interference alignment scheme with an appropriate secrecy pre-coding, each user is shown to achieve a constant positive secret rate for sufficiently large $n$. Remarkably, the scheme does not require eavesdropper CSI (only the statistical knowledge is assumed) and the secure throughput per node increases as we add more legitimate users to the network in this setting. Finally, the effect of eavesdropper collusion on the performance of the proposed schemes is characterized.