Paper detail

Toughening and mechanosensing in bone: a perfectly balanced mechanism based on competing stresses

Bone is a stiff and though, hierarchical and continuously evolving material that optimizes its structure to respond to mechanical stimuli, which also govern growth and remodeling processes. However, a full understanding of the underlying mechanisms responsible for the cooperation of bone toughness and biological functions, with important implications in bone ageing, osteoporosis and tissue repair, has yet to be achieved. In particular, how micro-damage nucleation, needed for tissue remodeling, does not evolve into catastrophic failure in such a stiff material, still remains a partial enigma, cement lines, interfaces and sacrificial elements alone not providing a definitive answer to the question. Here, we bring to light a novel stress-based bone toughening mechanism, calling into play the nearly-symmetrical, chiral and hierarchical architecture of the osteons, demonstrating that their arrangement simultaneously gives rise to stress states alternating in sign along the osteon radius and to localized stress amplifications, both in the tensile and compressive regimes. This unveils a previously unforeseen synergistic mechanism allowing micro-damage accumulation without propagating cracks, kindled by the contrast between crack-opening due to tensile hoop stresses and crack-stopping due to compressive stresses at the crack tips in adjacent lamellae, which seal the crack ends conferring toughness to bone well beyond that predicted by current models. Furthermore, shear stresses occur at the lamellar interfaces, contributing with fluid flow to mechanically stimulate the osteocytes and to amplify the bone signalling. These results, obtained through original exact elastic solutions and confirmed by both FE fracture analyses and experimental tests on 3D-printed osteon prototypes, contribute with another piece in the puzzle to making the rational biophysical picture of bone mechanobiology complete.