Paper detail

Stable nodal line semimetals in the chiral classes in three dimensions

It has been realized over the past two decades that topological nontriviality can be present not only in insulators but also in gapless semimetals, the most prominent example being Weyl semimetals in three dimensions. Key to topological classification schemes are the three ``internal" symmetries, time reversal ${\cal T}$, charge conjugation ${\cal C}$, and their product, called chiral symmetry ${\cal S}={\cal T}{\cal C}$. In this work, we show that robust topological nodal line semimetal phases occur in $d=3$ in systems whose internal symmetries include ${\cal S}$, without invoking crystalline symmetries other than translations. Since the nodal loop semimetal naturally appears as an intermediate gapless phase between the topological and the trivial insulators, a sufficient condition for the nodal loop phase to exist is that the symmetry class must have a nontrivial topological insulator in $d=3$. Our classification uses the winding number on a loop that links the nodal line. A nonzero winding number on a nodal loop implies robust gapless drumhead states on the surface Brillouin zone. We demonstrate how our classification works in all the nontrivial chiral classes and how it differs from the previous understanding of topologically protected nodal line semimetals.