Optimal Decisions of a Rational Agent in the Presence of Biased Information Providers

preprint2020arXivOpen access

Abstract

We consider information networks whereby multiple biased-information-providers (BIPs), e.g., media outlets/social network users/sensors, share reports of events with rational-information-consumers (RICs). Making the reasonable abstraction that an event can be reported as an answer to a logical statement, we model the input-output behavior of each BIP as a binary channel. For various reasons, some BIPs might share incorrect reports of the event. Moreover, each BIP is: 'biased' if it favors one of the two outcomes while reporting, or 'unbiased' if it favors neither outcome. Such biases occur in information/social networks due to differences in users' characteristics/worldviews. We study the impact of the BIPs' biases on an RIC's choices while deducing the true information. Our work reveals that a "graph-blind" RIC looking for nn BIPs among its neighbors, acts peculiarly in order to minimize its probability of making an error while deducing the true information. First, we establish the counter-intuitive fact that the RIC's expected error is minimized by choosing BIPs that are fully-biased against the a-priori likely event. Then, we study the gains that fully-biased BIPs provide over unbiased BIPs when the error rates of their binary channels are equalized, for fair comparison, at some r>0r>0. Specifically, the unbiased-to-fully-biased ratio of the RIC's expected error probabilities grows exponentially with the exponent n2ln⁡(4ρ02(1r−1))\frac{n}{2}\ln\left(4ρ_0^2\left(\frac{1}{r}-1\right)\right), where ρ0ρ_0 is the event's prior probability of being 00. This shows not only that fully-biased BIPs are preferable to unbiased or heterogeneously-biased BIPs, but also that the gains can be substantial for small rr.

Explore this paper’s authors, topics and related work.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Reviews 0

Write a reviewWrite

No reviews yet.

Discussion 0

Add a commentWrite

No comments yet.