Paper detail

On the Discrete Groups of Mathieu Moonshine

We prove that a certain space of cusp forms for the Hecke congruence group of a given level is one-dimensional if and only if that level is the order of an element of the second largest Mathieu group. As such, our result furnishes a direct analogue of Ogg's observation that the normaliser of a Hecke congruence group of prime level has genus zero if and only if that prime divides the order of the Fischer-Griess monster group. The significance of the cusp forms under consideration is explained by the Rademacher sum construction of the McKay-Thompson series of Mathieu moonshine. Our result supports a conjectural characterisation of the discrete groups and multiplier systems arising in Mathieu moonshine.