Paper detail

Observation of an anomalous line shape of the $η^{\prime}π^{+}π^{-}$ mass spectrum near the $p\bar{p}$ mass threshold in $J/ψ\rightarrowγη^{\prime}π^{+}π^{-}$

Using $1.09\times10^{9}$ $J/ψ$ events collected by the BESIII experiment in 2012, we study the $J/ψ\rightarrowγη^{\prime}π^{+}π^{-}$ process and observe a significant abrupt change in the slope of the $η^{\prime}π^{+}π^{-}$ invariant mass distribution at the proton-antiproton ($p\bar{p}$) mass threshold. We use two models to characterize the $η^{\prime}π^{+}π^{-}$ line shape around $1.85~\text{GeV}/c^{2}$: one which explicitly incorporates the opening of a decay threshold in the mass spectrum (Flatté formula), and another which is the coherent sum of two resonant amplitudes. Both fits show almost equally good agreement with data, and suggest the existence of either a broad state around $1.85~\text{GeV}/c^{2}$ with strong couplings to $p\bar{p}$ final states or a narrow state just below the $p\bar{p}$ mass threshold. Although we cannot distinguish between the fits, either one supports the existence of a $p\bar{p}$ molecule-like state or bound state with greater than $7σ$ significance.

preprint2016arXivOpen access
M. AblikimM. N. AchasovS. AhmedX. C. AiO. AlbayrakM. AlbrechtD. J. AmbroseA. AmorosoF. F. AnQ. AnJ. Z. BaiR. Baldini FerroliY. BanD. W. BennettJ. V. BennettN. BergerM. BertaniD. BettoniJ. M. BianF. BianchiE. BogerI. BoykoR. A. BriereH. CaiX. CaiO. CakirA. CalcaterraG. F. CaoS. A. CetinJ. F. ChangG. ChelkovG. ChenH. S. ChenH. Y. ChenJ. C. ChenM. L. ChenS. ChenS. J. ChenX. ChenX. R. ChenY. B. ChenH. P. ChengX. K. ChuG. CibinettoH. L. DaiJ. P. DaiA. DbeyssiD. DedovichZ. Y. DengA. DenigI. DenysenkoM. DestefanisF. De MoriY. DingC. DongJ. DongL. Y. DongM. Y. DongZ. L. DouS. X. DuP. F. DuanJ. Z. FanJ. FangS. S. FangX. FangY. FangR. FarinelliL. FavaO. FedorovF. FeldbauerG. FeliciC. Q. FengE. FioravantiM. FritschC. D. FuQ. GaoX. L. GaoX. Y. GaoY. GaoZ. GaoI. GarziaK. GoetzenL. GongW. X. GongW. GradlM. GrecoM. H. GuY. T. GuY. H. GuanA. Q. GuoL. B. GuoR. P. GuoY. GuoY. P. GuoZ. HaddadiA. HafnerS. HanX. Q. HaoF. A. HarrisK. L. HeF. H. HeinsiusT. HeldY. K. HengT. HoltmannZ. L. HouC. HuH. M. HuJ. F. HuT. HuY. HuG. S. HuangY. P. HuangJ. S. HuangX. T. HuangX. Z. HuangY. HuangZ. L. HuangT. HussainQ. JiQ. P. JiX. B. JiX. L. JiL. W. JiangX. S. JiangX. Y. JiangJ. B. JiaoZ. JiaoD. P. JinS. JinT. JohanssonA. JulinN. Kalantar-NayestanakiX. L. KangX. S. KangM. KavatsyukB. C. KeP. KieseR. KliemtB. KlossO. B. KolcuB. KopfM. KornicerA. KupscW. KühnJ. S. LangeM. LaraP. LarinH. LeithoffC. LengC. LiCheng LiD. M. LiF. LiF. Y. LiG. LiH. B. LiH. J. LiJ. C. LiJin LiK. LiLei LiP. R. LiQ. Y. LiT. LiW. D. LiW. G. LiX. L. LiX. N. LiX. Q. LiY. B. LiZ. B. LiH. LiangY. F. LiangY. T. LiangG. R. LiaoD. X. LinB. LiuB. J. LiuC. X. LiuD. LiuF. H. LiuFang LiuFeng LiuH. B. LiuH. H. LiuH. M. LiuJ. LiuJ. B. LiuJ. P. LiuJ. Y. LiuK. LiuK. Y. LiuL. D. LiuP. L. LiuQ. LiuS. B. LiuX. LiuY. B. LiuY. Y. LiuZ. A. LiuZhiqing LiuH. LoehnerX. C. LouH. J. LuJ. G. LuY. LuY. P. LuC. L. LuoM. X. LuoT. LuoX. L. LuoX. R. LyuF. C. MaH. L. MaL. L. MaM. M. MaQ. M. MaT. MaX. N. MaX. Y. MaY. M. MaF. E. MaasM. MaggioraQ. A. MalikY. J. MaoZ. P. MaoS. MarcelloJ. G. MesschendorpG. MezzadriJ. MinT. J. MinR. E. MitchellX. H. MoY. J. MoC. Morales MoralesN. Yu. MuchnoiH. MuramatsuP. MusiolY. NefedovF. NerlingI. B. NikolaevZ. NingS. NisarS. L. NiuX. Y. NiuS. L. OlsenQ. OuyangS. PacettiY. PanP. PatteriM. PelizaeusH. P. PengK. PetersJ. PetterssonJ. L. PingR. G. PingR. PolingV. PrasadH. R. QiM. QiS. QianC. F. QiaoL. Q. QinN. QinX. S. QinZ. H. QinJ. F. QiuK. H. RashidC. F. RedmerM. RipkaG. RongCh. RosnerX. D. RuanA. SarantsevM. SavriéC. SchnierK. SchoenningS. SchumannW. ShanM. ShaoC. P. ShenP. X. ShenX. Y. ShenH. Y. ShengM. ShiW. M. SongX. Y. SongS. SosioS. SpataroG. X. SunJ. F. SunS. S. SunX. H. SunY. J. SunY. Z. SunZ. J. SunZ. T. SunC. J. TangX. TangI. TapanE. H. ThorndikeM. TiemensI. UmanG. S. VarnerB. WangB. L. WangD. WangD. Y. WangK. WangL. L. WangL. S. WangM. WangP. WangP. L. WangS. G. WangW. WangW. P. WangX. F. WangY. WangY. D. WangY. F. WangY. Q. WangZ. WangZ. G. WangZ. H. WangZ. Y. WangT. WeberD. H. WeiJ. B. WeiP. WeidenkaffS. P. WenU. WiednerM. WolkeL. H. WuL. J. WuZ. WuL. XiaL. G. XiaY. XiaD. XiaoH. XiaoZ. J. XiaoY. G. XieQ. L. XiuG. F. XuJ. J. XuL. XuQ. J. XuQ. N. XuX. P. XuL. YanW. B. YanW. C. YanY. H. YanH. J. YangH. X. YangL. YangY. X. YangM. YeM. H. YeJ. H. YinB. X. YuC. X. YuJ. S. YuC. Z. YuanW. L. YuanY. YuanA. YuncuA. A. ZafarA. ZalloY. ZengZ. ZengB. X. ZhangB. Y. ZhangC. ZhangC. C. ZhangD. H. ZhangH. H. ZhangH. Y. ZhangJ. ZhangJ. J. ZhangJ. L. ZhangJ. Q. ZhangJ. W. ZhangJ. Y. ZhangJ. Z. ZhangK. ZhangL. ZhangS. Q. ZhangX. Y. ZhangY. ZhangY. H. ZhangY. N. ZhangY. T. ZhangYu ZhangZ. H. ZhangZ. P. ZhangZ. Y. ZhangG. ZhaoJ. W. ZhaoJ. Y. ZhaoJ. Z. ZhaoLei ZhaoLing ZhaoM. G. ZhaoQ. ZhaoQ. W. ZhaoS. J. ZhaoT. C. ZhaoY. B. ZhaoZ. G. ZhaoA. ZhemchugovB. ZhengJ. P. ZhengW. J. ZhengY. H. ZhengB. ZhongL. ZhouX. ZhouX. K. ZhouX. R. ZhouX. Y. ZhouK. ZhuK. J. ZhuS. ZhuS. H. ZhuX. L. ZhuY. C. ZhuY. S. ZhuZ. A. ZhuJ. ZhuangL. ZottiB. S. ZouJ. H. Zou

Signal facts

What is known right now

Open access434 authors1 topic

Next steps

Decide what to do with this paper

Use like or dislike for the fast social read. The more specific scholarly feedback stays available below when needed.

Log in to curate

Reading frame

Keep the important context close to the paper

Keep the important signals around this paper in one place: votes, save state, collection context, reviews and the metadata you need before deciding what to do next.

Authors

M. AblikimM. N. AchasovS. AhmedX. C. AiO. AlbayrakM. AlbrechtD. J. AmbroseA. AmorosoF. F. AnQ. AnJ. Z. BaiR. Baldini FerroliY. BanD. W. BennettJ. V. BennettN. BergerM. BertaniD. BettoniJ. M. BianF. BianchiE. BogerI. BoykoR. A. BriereH. CaiX. CaiO. CakirA. CalcaterraG. F. CaoS. A. CetinJ. F. ChangG. ChelkovG. ChenH. S. ChenH. Y. ChenJ. C. ChenM. L. ChenS. ChenS. J. ChenX. ChenX. R. ChenY. B. ChenH. P. ChengX. K. ChuG. CibinettoH. L. DaiJ. P. DaiA. DbeyssiD. DedovichZ. Y. DengA. DenigI. DenysenkoM. DestefanisF. De MoriY. DingC. DongJ. DongL. Y. DongM. Y. DongZ. L. DouS. X. DuP. F. DuanJ. Z. FanJ. FangS. S. FangX. FangY. FangR. FarinelliL. FavaO. FedorovF. FeldbauerG. FeliciC. Q. FengE. FioravantiM. FritschC. D. FuQ. GaoX. L. GaoX. Y. GaoY. GaoZ. GaoI. GarziaK. GoetzenL. GongW. X. GongW. GradlM. GrecoM. H. GuY. T. GuY. H. GuanA. Q. GuoL. B. GuoR. P. GuoY. GuoY. P. GuoZ. HaddadiA. HafnerS. HanX. Q. HaoF. A. HarrisK. L. HeF. H. HeinsiusT. HeldY. K. HengT. HoltmannZ. L. HouC. HuH. M. HuJ. F. HuT. HuY. HuG. S. HuangY. P. HuangJ. S. HuangX. T. HuangX. Z. HuangY. HuangZ. L. HuangT. HussainQ. JiQ. P. JiX. B. JiX. L. JiL. W. JiangX. S. JiangX. Y. JiangJ. B. JiaoZ. JiaoD. P. JinS. JinT. JohanssonA. JulinN. Kalantar-NayestanakiX. L. KangX. S. KangM. KavatsyukB. C. KeP. KieseR. KliemtB. KlossO. B. KolcuB. KopfM. KornicerA. KupscW. KühnJ. S. LangeM. LaraP. LarinH. LeithoffC. LengC. LiCheng LiD. M. LiF. LiF. Y. LiG. LiH. B. LiH. J. LiJ. C. LiJin LiK. LiLei LiP. R. LiQ. Y. LiT. LiW. D. LiW. G. LiX. L. LiX. N. LiX. Q. LiY. B. LiZ. B. LiH. LiangY. F. LiangY. T. LiangG. R. LiaoD. X. LinB. LiuB. J. LiuC. X. LiuD. LiuF. H. LiuFang LiuFeng LiuH. B. LiuH. H. LiuH. M. LiuJ. LiuJ. B. LiuJ. P. LiuJ. Y. LiuK. LiuK. Y. LiuL. D. LiuP. L. LiuQ. LiuS. B. LiuX. LiuY. B. LiuY. Y. LiuZ. A. LiuZhiqing LiuH. LoehnerX. C. LouH. J. LuJ. G. LuY. LuY. P. LuC. L. LuoM. X. LuoT. LuoX. L. LuoX. R. LyuF. C. MaH. L. MaL. L. MaM. M. MaQ. M. MaT. MaX. N. MaX. Y. MaY. M. MaF. E. MaasM. MaggioraQ. A. MalikY. J. MaoZ. P. MaoS. MarcelloJ. G. MesschendorpG. MezzadriJ. MinT. J. MinR. E. MitchellX. H. MoY. J. MoC. Morales MoralesN. Yu. MuchnoiH. MuramatsuP. MusiolY. NefedovF. NerlingI. B. NikolaevZ. NingS. NisarS. L. NiuX. Y. NiuS. L. OlsenQ. OuyangS. PacettiY. PanP. PatteriM. PelizaeusH. P. PengK. PetersJ. PetterssonJ. L. PingR. G. PingR. PolingV. PrasadH. R. QiM. QiS. QianC. F. QiaoL. Q. QinN. QinX. S. QinZ. H. QinJ. F. QiuK. H. RashidC. F. RedmerM. RipkaG. RongCh. RosnerX. D. RuanA. SarantsevM. SavriéC. SchnierK. SchoenningS. SchumannW. ShanM. ShaoC. P. ShenP. X. ShenX. Y. ShenH. Y. ShengM. ShiW. M. SongX. Y. SongS. SosioS. SpataroG. X. SunJ. F. SunS. S. SunX. H. SunY. J. SunY. Z. SunZ. J. SunZ. T. SunC. J. TangX. TangI. TapanE. H. ThorndikeM. TiemensI. UmanG. S. VarnerB. WangB. L. WangD. WangD. Y. WangK. WangL. L. WangL. S. WangM. WangP. WangP. L. WangS. G. WangW. WangW. P. WangX. F. WangY. WangY. D. WangY. F. WangY. Q. WangZ. WangZ. G. WangZ. H. WangZ. Y. WangT. WeberD. H. WeiJ. B. WeiP. WeidenkaffS. P. WenU. WiednerM. WolkeL. H. WuL. J. WuZ. WuL. XiaL. G. XiaY. XiaD. XiaoH. XiaoZ. J. XiaoY. G. XieQ. L. XiuG. F. XuJ. J. XuL. XuQ. J. XuQ. N. XuX. P. XuL. YanW. B. YanW. C. YanY. H. YanH. J. YangH. X. YangL. YangY. X. YangM. YeM. H. YeJ. H. YinB. X. YuC. X. YuJ. S. YuC. Z. YuanW. L. YuanY. YuanA. YuncuA. A. ZafarA. ZalloY. ZengZ. ZengB. X. ZhangB. Y. ZhangC. ZhangC. C. ZhangD. H. ZhangH. H. ZhangH. Y. ZhangJ. ZhangJ. J. ZhangJ. L. ZhangJ. Q. ZhangJ. W. ZhangJ. Y. ZhangJ. Z. ZhangK. ZhangL. ZhangS. Q. ZhangX. Y. ZhangY. ZhangY. H. ZhangY. N. ZhangY. T. ZhangYu ZhangZ. H. ZhangZ. P. ZhangZ. Y. ZhangG. ZhaoJ. W. ZhaoJ. Y. ZhaoJ. Z. ZhaoLei ZhaoLing ZhaoM. G. ZhaoQ. ZhaoQ. W. ZhaoS. J. ZhaoT. C. ZhaoY. B. ZhaoZ. G. ZhaoA. ZhemchugovB. ZhengJ. P. ZhengW. J. ZhengY. H. ZhengB. ZhongL. ZhouX. ZhouX. K. ZhouX. R. ZhouX. Y. ZhouK. ZhuK. J. ZhuS. ZhuS. H. ZhuX. L. ZhuY. C. ZhuY. S. ZhuZ. A. ZhuJ. ZhuangL. ZottiB. S. ZouJ. H. Zou

Institutions

Add specific reaction

Move through the context

Research map

Open full explorer

Move through nearby people, institutions, topics and adjacent work without leaving the paper page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Structured reviews

0 review(s)

ContributeLeave structured feedbackUse the review template when you have a concrete strength, concern or method question.Open review form

No structured reviews yet. High-signal critique starts here.

Work discussion

0 comment(s)

DiscussAdd a high-signal commentKeep quick notes, caveats and replication pointers separate from formal reviews.Open comment form

No discussion yet. The first strong comment sets the tone.