Paper detail

Interactive, Effort-Aware Library Version Harmonization

As a mixed result of intensive dependency on third-party libraries, flexible mechanism to declare dependencies, and increased number of modules in a project, multiple versions of the same third-party library are directly depended in different modules of a project. Such library version inconsistencies can increase dependency maintenance cost, or even lead to dependency conflicts when modules are inter-dependent. Although automated build tools (e.g., Maven's enforcer plugin) provide partial support to detect library version inconsistencies, they do not provide any support to harmonize inconsistent library versions. We first conduct a survey with 131 Java developers from GitHub to retrieve first-hand information about the root causes, detection methods, reasons for fixing or not fixing, fixing strategies, fixing efforts, and tool expectations on library version inconsistencies. Then, based on the insights from our survey, we propose LibHarmo, an interactive, effort-aware library version harmonization technique, to detect library version inconsistencies, interactively suggest a harmonized version with the least harmonization efforts based on library API usage analysis, and refactor build configuration files. LibHarmo is currently developed for Java Maven projects. Our experimental study on 443 highly-starred Java Maven projects from GitHub indicates that i) LibHarmo identifies 621 library version inconsistencies covering 152 (34.3%) of projects, and ii) the average harmonization efforts are that 1 and 12 library API calls are affected, respectively due to the deleted and changed library APIs in the harmonized version. 5 library version inconsistencies have been confirmed, and 1 of them has been already harmonized by developers.