Paper detail

Graphical Perception in Animated Bar Charts

Interactive visual applications create animations that encode changes in the data. For example, cross-filtering dynamically updates linked visualizations based on the user's continuous brushing actions. The animated effects resulting from these interactions depends both on how interaction (e.g., brushing speed) controls properties of the animation such as frame rate, as well as how the data that is being explored dictates the data encoded in the animation. Past work has found that frame rate matters to general perception, however a critical question is which of these animation and data properties affects the perceptual accuracy of judgement tasks, and to what extent. Although graphical perception has been well studied for static data visualizations, it is ripe for exploration in the animated setting. We designed two animated judgment tasks of a target bar in an animated bar chart and empirically evaluate the effects of 2 animations properties - highlighting of the target bar and frame rate - as well as 3 data properties that affect the target bar's value throughout the animation. In short, we find that the rate and timing of animation changes is easier detected in larger values; that encodings such as color are easier to detect than shapes; and that timing is important - earlier changes were harder to perceive as compared to later changes in the animation. Our results are an initial step to understanding perceptual accuracy for animated data visualizations, both for presentations and ultimately as part of interactive applications.