Paper detail

Constraining Globular Cluster Formation Through Studies of Young Massive Clusters: I. A lack of ongoing star formation within young clusters

We present a survey of 130 Galactic and extragalactic young massive clusters (YMCs, $10^4 < M/\msun < 10^8$, $10 < t/{\rm Myr} < 1000$) with integrated spectroscopy or resolved stellar photometry (40 presented here and 90 from the literature) and use the sample to search for evidence of ongoing star-formation within the clusters. Such episodes of secondary (or continuous) star-formation are predicted by models that attempt to explain the observed chemical and photometric anomalies observed in globular clusters as being due to the formation of a second stellar population within an existing first population. Additionally, studies that have claimed extended star-formation histories within LMC/SMC intermediate age clusters (1-2 Gyr), also imply that many young massive clusters should show ongoing star-formation. Based on visual inspection of the spectra and/or the colour-magnitude diagrams, we do not find evidence for ongoing star-formation within any of the clusters, and use this to place constraints on the above models. Models of continuous star-formation within clusters, lasting for hundreds of Myr, are ruled out at high significance (unless stellar IMF variations are invoked). Models for the (nearly instantaneous) formation of a secondary population within an existing first generation are not favoured, but are not formally discounted due to the finite sampling of age/mass-space.