Comment on: "Hyperfine structure measurements of Co I and Co II with Fourier transform spectroscopy" by Fu et al. [JQSRT 2021, 107590]

preprint2022arXivOpen access

Abstract

This comment points out errors in the analysis of 61 magnetic hyperfine structure (AA) constants of Co II energy levels by Fu et al. [JQSRT 2021, 107590]. The paper was published without full awareness of the extensive literature already available for Co II hyperfine AA constants at the time; 57 of 58 AA constants that were claimed to have been measured for the first time had already been measured by the prior work of Ding \& Pickering [ApJS 2020, 251:24], who had published AA constants for 292 levels of Co II. The AA constant of 3d6^64s2^2 a5^5D4_4 has been determined by Fu et al. [JQSRT 2021, 107590] for the first time to be 12.0±1.812.0\pm1.8 mK (1 mK == 0.001 cm−1^{-1}), which was found to agree with line profiles observed by Ding \& Pickering [ApJS 2020, 251:24]. Discrepancies in 17 AA constants of Fu et al. [JQSRT 2021, 107590] were found, which are likely due to the analysis of weak, experimentally unclassified transitions with Ritz wavenumbers 25453.966 cm−1^{-1} and 25149.948 cm−1^{-1} by Fu et al. [JQSRT 2021, 107590] for the AA constants of the energy levels 3d7^7(2^2G)4s a3^3G5_5 and 3d7^7(2^2P)4s c3^3P2_2 respectively. Fewer transitions and poorer quality spectra analysed by Fu et al. [JQSRT 2021, 107590] are also concluded to have contributed to disagreements in the 17 AA constants.

Explore this paper’s authors, topics and related work.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Reviews 0

Write a reviewWrite

No reviews yet.

Discussion 0

Add a commentWrite

No comments yet.