Paper detail

Adaptive smoothing lengths in SPH

Context: There is a need to improve the fidelity of SPH simulations of self-gravitating gas dynamics. Aims: We remind users of SPH that, if smoothing lengths are adjusted so as to keep the number of neighbours, ${\cal N}$, in the range ${\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}\pmΔ{\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}$, the tolerance, $Δ{\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}$, should be set to zero, as first noted by Nelson & Papaloizou. We point out that this is a very straightforward and computationally inexpensive constraint to implement. Methods: We demonstrate this by simulating acoustic oscillations of a self-gravitating isentropic monatomic gas-sphere (cf. Lucy), using ${\cal N}_{_{\rm TOT}}\sim6,000$ particles and ${\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}=50$. Results: We show that there is a marked reduction in the rates of numerical dissipation and diffusion as $Δ{\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}$ is reduced from 10 to zero. Moreover this reduction incurs a very small computational overhead. Conclusions: We propose that this should become a standard test for codes used in simulating star formation. It is a highly relevant test, because pressure waves generated by the switch from approximate isothermality to approximate adiabaticity play a critical role in the fragmentation of collapsing prestellar cores. Since many SPH simulations in the literature use ${\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}=50$ and $Δ{\cal N}_{_{\rm NEIB}}\geq10$, their results must be viewed with caution.