Source author record

Harvey Liszt

Harvey Liszt appears in the imported research catalog. Authorship, coauthor and topic links are available while profile ownership is still unclaimed.

ResearcherUnclaimed source record

Catalog footprint

What is connected

9works
2topics
4close collaborators

Actions

Connect this record

Log in to claim

Research graph

See the researcher in context

Open full explorer

Inspect adjacent papers, topics, institutions and collaborators without losing the researcher page.

Building this map preview

BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.

Published work

9 published item(s)

preprint2020arXiv

Quantitative inference of the $H_2$ column densities from 3 mm molecular emission: A case study towards Orion B

Molecular hydrogen being unobservable in cold molecular clouds, the column density measurements of molecular gas currently rely either on dust emission observation in the far-IR or on star counting. (Sub-)millimeter observations of numerous trace molecules are effective from ground based telescopes, but the relationships between the emission of one molecular line and the H2 column density (NH2) is non-linear and sensitive to excitation conditions, optical depths, abundance variations due to the underlying physico-chemistry. We aim to use multi-molecule line emission to infer NH2 from radio observations. We propose a data-driven approach to determine NH2 from radio molecular line observations. We use supervised machine learning methods (Random Forests) on wide-field hyperspectral IRAM-30m observations of the Orion B molecular cloud to train a predictor of NH2, using a limited set of molecular lines as input, and the Herschel-based dust-derived NH2 as ground truth output. For conditions similar to the Orion B molecular cloud, we obtain predictions of NH2 within a typical factor of 1.2 from the Herschel-based estimates. An analysis of the contributions of the different lines to the predictions show that the most important lines are $^{13}$CO(1-0), $^{12}$CO(1-0), C$^{18}$O(1-0), and HCO$^+$(1-0). A detailed analysis distinguishing between diffuse, translucent, filamentary, and dense core conditions show that the importance of these four lines depends on the regime, and that it is recommended to add the N$_2$H$^+$(1-0) and CH$_3$OH(20-10) lines for the prediction of NH2 in dense core conditions. This article opens a promising avenue to directly infer important physical parameters from the molecular line emission in the millimeter domain. The next step will be to try to infer several parameters simultaneously (e.g., NH2 and far-UV illumination field) to further test the method. [Abridged]

preprint2020arXiv

Reconciling X-ray and 21cm HI absorption gas column densities toward obscured AGN

Hydrogen column densities inferred from X-ray absorption are typically 5 - 30 times larger than the neutral atomic hydrogen column densities derived from 21cm HI absorption toward radio-loud active galactic nuclei. Some part of the difference is ascribed to uncertainty in the spin temperature \Tsp\ = 100 K that is often used to convert 21cm HI HI absorption to N(HI). Here we propose another way to infer the gas column from HI absorption. In our Galaxy there is a nearly linear correlation between the inteferometrically-measured integrated 21cm HI absorption \WHI\ and reddening, \WHI\ $\propto$ \EBV$^{1.10}$ for \WHI\ $\ga 0.7$ \kms\ or \EBV\ $\ga 0.04$ mag. Scaling \EBV\ then provides the total gas column density N(H) from the same dust column that is responsible for optical obscuration and X-ray absorption, without calculating N(HI). Values of N(H) so derived typically exceed N(HI) by a factor 4 because the ubiquitous Galactic 21cm HI HI absorption samples only a portion of the interstellar gas. If the well-studied case of Hydra-A is a guide, even very large disparities in X-ray and 21cm HI gas column densities can be explained by resolving the core radiocontinuum and inferring N(H) from 21cm HI absorption. Milky Way conditions are often invoked in discussion of obscured AGN, so the empirical relationship seen in the Milky Way should be a relevant benchmark.

preprint2020arXiv

Tracers of the ionization fraction in dense and translucent gas: I. Automated exploitation of massive astrochemical model grids

The ionization fraction plays a key role in the physics and chemistry of the neutral interstellar medium, from controlling the coupling of the gas to the magnetic field to allowing fast ion-neutral reactions that drive interstellar chemistry. Most estimations of the ionization fraction have relied on deuterated species such as DCO+, whose detection is limited to dense cores representing an extremely small fraction of the volume of the giant molecular clouds they are part of. As large field-of-view hyperspectral maps become available, new tracers may be found. We search for the best observable tracers of the ionization fraction based on a grid of astrochemical models. We build grids of models that sample randomly a large space of physical conditions (unobservable quantities such as gas density, temperature, etc.) and compute the corresponding observables (line intensities, column densities) and the ionization fraction. We estimate the predictive power of each potential tracer by training a Random Forest model to predict the ionization fraction from that tracer, based on these model grids. In both translucent medium and cold dense medium conditions, several observable tracers with very good predictive power for the ionization fraction are found. Several tracers in cold dense medium conditions are found to be better and more widely applicable than the traditional DCO+/HCO+ ratio. We also provide simpler analytical fits for estimating the ionization fraction from the best tracers, and for estimating the associated uncertainties. We discuss the limitations of the present study and select a few recommended tracers in both types of conditions. The method presented here is very general and can be applied to the measurement of any other quantity of interest (cosmic ray flux, elemental abundances, etc.) from any type of model (PDR models, time-dependent chemical models, etc.). (abridged)

preprint2016arXiv

The detectability of mm-wave molecular rotational transitions

Elaborating on a formalism that was first expressed some 40 years ago, we consider the brightness of low-lying mm-wave rotational lines of strongly polar molecules at the threshold of detectability. We derive a simple expression relating the brightness to the line of sight integral of the product of the total gas and molecular number densities and a suitably-defined temperature-dependent excitation rate into the upper level of the transition. Detectability of a line is contingent only on the ability of a molecule to channel enough of the ambient thermal energy into the line and the excitation can be computed in bulk by summing over rates without solving the multi-level rate equations or computing optical depths and excitation temperatures. Results for \hcop, HNC and CS are compared with escape-probability solutions of the rate equations using closed-form expressions for the expected range of validity of our {\it ansatz}, with the result that gas number densities as high as $10^4 \pccc$ or optical depths as high as 100 can be accommodated in some cases. For densities below a well-defined upper bound, the range of validity of the discussion can be cast as an upper bound on the line brightness which is 0.3 K for the J=1-0 lines and 0.8 - 1.7 K for the J=2-1 lines of these species. The discussion casts new light on interpretation of line brightnesses under conditions of weak excitation, simplifies derivation of physical parameters and eliminates the need to construct grids of numerical solutions of the rate equations.

preprint2015arXiv

Molecular gas in absorption and emission along the line of sight to W31C G10.62-0.38

We used the ARO 12m antenna to observe emission from the J=1-0 lines of carbon monoxide, \hcop\ and HNC and the J=2-1 line of CS toward and around the continuum peak used for absorption studies and we compare them with CH, HNC, C\p\ and other absorption spectra from PRISMAS. We develop a kinematic analysis that allows a continuous description of the spectral properties and relates them to viewing geometry in the Galaxy. As for CH, HF, C\p, \hcop\ and other species observed in absorption, mm-wave emission in CO, \hcop, HNC and CS is continuous over the full velocity range expected for material between the Sun and W31 4.95 kpc away. CO emission is much stronger than average in the Galactic molecular ring and the mean \HH\ density derived from CH, $4 \pccc \la$ 2$<$n(\HH)$>$ $\la 10 \pccc$ at 4 $\la$ R $\la$ 6.4 kpc, is similarly elevated. The CO-\HH\ conversion factor falls in a narrow range \XCO\ $= 1-2\times10^{20}~\HH\ \pcc~({\rm K}-\kms)^{-1}$ if the emitting gas is mostly on the near side of the sub-central point, as we suggest. The brightnesses of \hcop, HNC, and CS are comparable (0.83\%, 0.51\% and 1.1\% respectively relative to CO) and have no variation in galactocentric radius with respect to CO. Comparison of the profile-averaged \hcop\ emission brightness and optical depth implies local densities n(H) $\approx 135\pm25\pccc$ with most of excitation of \hcop\ from electrons. At such density, a consistent picture of the \HH-bearing gas, accounting also for the CO emission, has a volume filling factor 3\% and a 5 pc clump or cloud size.

preprint2014arXiv

E(B-V), N(H I) and N(H_2)

We consider the structure of the N(H I) - E(B-V) relationship when H I is measured in the 21 cm radio line and \EBV\ is defined by far-IR dust-derived measures. We derive reddening-dependent corrections to N(H I) based on interferometric absorption measurements over the past 30 years that follow a single power-law relationship $\int τ(H I) dv = 14.07 ~\kms\ $\EBV$^{1.074}$ at 0.02 $\la$ \EBV\ $\la$ 3 mag. Corrections to 21cm line-derived H I column densities are too small to have had any effect on the ratio N(H I)/\EBV\ $= 8.3 \times 10^{21}\pcc$ mag$^{-1}$ we derived at 0.015 $\la$ \EBV\ $\la$ 0.075 mag and \absb\ $\ge$ 20\degr; they are also too small to explain the break in the slope of the N(H I) - \EBV\ relation at \EBV\ $\ga$ 0.1 mag that we demonstrated around the Galaxy at \absb $\ge 20$\degr. The latter must therefore be attributed to the onset of \HH-formation and we show that models of \HH\ formation in a low density diffuse molecular gas can readily explain the inflected N(H I)- \EBV\ relationship. Below \absb\ = 20\degr\ N(H I)/\EBV\ measured at 0.015 $\la$ \EBV\ $\la$ 0.075 mag increases steadily down to \absb\ = 8\degr\ where sightlines with small \EBV\ no longer occur. By contrast, the ratio N(H I)/\EBV\ measured over all \EBV\ declines to N(H I)/\EBV\ $= 5-6 \times 10^{21}\pcc$ mag$^{-1}$ at \absb\ $\la 30$\degr, perhaps providing an explanation of the difference between our results and the gas/reddening ratios measured previously using stellar spectra.

preprint2014arXiv

What microwave astronomical spectroscopy can tell you about the carriers of the DIBS

Astronomical microwave spectroscopy has greatly broadened the inventory of identifiable chemical species in diffuse molecular gas and is an increasingly effective way to measure the abundances of polar molecules that may be candidate diffuse interstellar band carriers. Here we review some recent developments that hold new promise for chemical abundance determinations. We summarize and categorize the molecular inventory that has accrued in the past twenty years from microwave observations of diffuse clouds and we present summary tables of the molecular abundances within various chemical families in both dark and diffuse molecular gas.

preprint2012arXiv

The abundance of C3H2 and other small hydrocarbons in the diffuse interstellar medium

Hydrocarbons are ubiquitous in the interstellar medium, observed in diverse environments ranging from diffuse to molecular dark clouds and strong photon-dominated regions near HII regions. Recently, two broad diffuse interstellar bands (DIBs) at 4881Å and 5450Å were attributed to the linear version of propynylidene l-C3H2, a species whose more stable cyclic conformer c-C3H2 has been widely observed in the diffuse interstellar medium at radio wavelengths. This attribution has already been criticized on the basis of indirect plausibility arguments because the required column densities are quite large, N(l-C3H2)/EB-V = 4 \times 1014 cm-2 mag-1. Here we present new measurements of N(l-C3H2) based on simultaneous 18-21 GHz VLA absorption profiles of cyclic and linear C3H2 taken along sightlines toward extragalactic radiocontinuum background sources with foreground Galactic reddening EB-V = 0.1 - 1.6 mag. We find that N(l-C3H2)/N(c-C3H2) ? 1/15 - 1/40 and N(l-C3H2)/EB-V ? 2 \pm 1 \times 1011 cm-2 mag-1, so that the column densities of l-C3H2 needed to explain the diffuse interstellar bands are some three orders of magnitude higher than what is observed. We also find N(C4H)/EB-V < 1.3 \times 1013 cm-2 mag-1 and N(C4H-)/EB-V < 1 \times 1011 cm-2 mag-1 (3?). Using available data for CH and C2H we compare the abundances of small hydrocarbons in diffuse and dark clouds as a guide to their ability to contribute as DIB carriers over a wide range of conditions in the interstellar medium.

preprint2010arXiv

The CO luminosity and CO-H2 conversion factor of diffuse ISM: does CO emission trace dense molecular gas?

Aims: We wish to separate and quantify the CO luminosity and CO-H2 conversion factor applicable to diffuse but partially-molecular ISM when H2 and CO are present but C+ is the dominant form of gas-phase carbon. Methods: We discuss galactic lines of sight observed in \HI, HCO+ and CO where CO emission is present but the intervening clouds are diffuse (locally \AV\ $\la 1$ mag) with relatively small CO column densities $\NCO \la 2\times10^{16}\pcc$. We separate the atomic and molecular fractions statistically using \EBV\ as a gauge of the total gas column density and compare NH2 to the observed CO brightness. Results: Although there are H2-bearing regions where CO emission is too faint to be detected, the mean ratio of integrated CO brightness to NH2 for diffuse ISM does not differ from the usual value of 1\K km/s of integrated CO brightness per $2\times10^{20}$ H2 $\pcc$ . Moreover, the luminosity of diffuse CO viewed perpendicular to the galactic plane is 2/3 that seen at the Solar galactic radius in surveys of CO emission near the galactic plane. Conclusions: Commonality of the CO-H2 conversion factors in diffuse and dark clouds can be understood from considerations of radiative transfer and CO chemistry. There is unavoidable confusion between CO emission from diffuse and dark gas and misattribution of CO emission from diffuse to dark or giant molecular clouds. The character of the ISM is different from what has been believed if CO and H2 that have been attributed to molecular clouds on the verge of star formation are actually in more tenuous, gravitationally-unbound diffuse gas.