Reply to W. T. Kranz on "Explicit analytical solution for random close packing in $d=2$ and $d=3$"
A recent Comment by W. T. Kranz is shown to be plagued by a serious mathematical error which makes its conclusions invalid.
Researcher profile
A. Zaccone
A. Zaccone contributes to research discovery and scholarly infrastructure.
ResearcherAffiliation not importedOpen to collaborate
Trust snapshot
Quick read
Trust 21 - EmergingVerification L1Unclaimed author
12works
0followers
7topics
4close collaborators
Actions
Decide how to stay connected
Identity and collaboration
How to connect with this researcher
Claiming links this public author record to a researcher profile and unlocks direct collaboration workflows.
Log in to claimDirect collaboration
Open a focused conversation when the fit is right
Claim this author entity first to unlock direct invitations.
Research graph
See the researcher in context
Inspect adjacent work, topics, institutions and collaborators without jumping out to a separate graph page.
Building this graph slice
BZPEER is loading the nearby papers, people, topics and institutions for this page.
Published work
12 published item(s)
preprint2021arXiv
Universal $L^{-3}$ finite-size effects in the viscoelasticity of confined amorphous systems
We present a theory of viscoelasticity of amorphous media, which takes into account the effects of confinement along one of three spatial dimensions. The framework is based on the nonaffine extension of lattice dynamics to amorphous systems, or nonaffine response theory. The size effects due to the confinement are taken into account via the nonaffine part of the shear storage modulus $G'$. The nonaffine contribution is written as a sum over modes in $k$-space. With a rigorous argument based on the analysis of the $k$-space integral over modes, it is shown that the confinement size $L$ in one spatial dimension, e.g. the $z$ axis, leads to a infrared cut-off for the modes contributing to the nonaffine (softening) correction to the modulus that scales as $L^{-3}$. Corrections for finite sample size $D$ in the two perpendicular dimensions scale as $\sim (L/D)^4$, and are negligible for $L \ll D$. For liquids it is predicted that $G'\sim L^{-3}$ in agreement with a previous more approximate analysis, whereas for amorphous materials $G' \sim G'_{bulk} + βL^{-3}$. For the case of liquids, four different experimental systems are shown to be very well described by the $L^{-3}$ law.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2020arXiv
Low-energy optical phonons induce glassy-like vibrational and thermal anomalies in ordered crystals
It is widely accepted that structural glasses and disordered crystals exhibit anomalies in the their thermal, mechanical and acoustic properties as manifestations of the breakdown of the long-wavelength approximation in a disordered dissipative environment. However, the same type of glassy-like anomalies (i.e. boson peak in the vibrational density of states (VDOS) above the Debye level, peak in the normalized specific heat at $T\simeq10 K$ etc) have been recently observed also in perfectly ordered crystals, including thermoelectric compounds. Here we present a theory that predicts these surprising effects in perfectly ordered crystals as a result of low-lying (soft) optical phonons. In particular, it is seen that a strong boson peak anomaly (low-energy excess of modes) in the VDOS can be due almost entirely to the presence of low-energy optical phonons, provided that their energy is comparable to that of the acoustic modes at the Brillouin zone boundary. The boson peak is predicted also to occur in the heat capacity at low $T$. In presence of strong damping (which might be due to anharmonicities in the ordered crystals), these optical phonons contribute to the low-$T$ deviation from Debye's $T^{3}$ law, producing a linear-in-$T$ behavior which is typical of glasses, even though no assumptions of disorder whatsoever are made in the model. These findings are relevant for understanding and tuning thermal transport properties of thermoelectric compounds, and possibly for the enhancement of electron-phonon superconductivity.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2016arXiv
Effects of shear flow on phase nucleation and crystallization
Classical nucleation theory offers a good framework for understanding the common features of new phase formation processes in metastable homogeneous media at rest. However, nucleation processes in liquids are ubiquitously affected by hydrodynamic flow, and there is no satisfactory understanding of whether shear promotes or slows down the nucleation process. We developed a classical nucleation theory for sheared systems starting from the molecular level of the Becker-Doering master kinetic equation and we analytically derived a closed-form expression for the nucleation rate. The theory accounts for the effect of flow-mediated transport of molecules to the nucleus of the new phase, as well as for the mechanical deformation imparted to the nucleus by the flow field. The competition between flow-induced molecular transport, which accelerates nucleation, and flow-induced nucleus straining, which lowers the nucleation rate by increasing the nucleation energy barrier, gives rise to a marked nonmonotonic dependence of the nucleation rate on the shear rate. The theory predicts an optimal shear rate at which the nucleation rate is one order of magnitude larger than in the absence of flow.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2016arXiv
Kinetics of fragmentation and dissociation of two-strand protein filaments: Coarse-grained simulations and experiments
While a significant body of investigations have been focused on the process of protein self-assembly, much less is understood about the reverse process of a filament breaking due to thermal motion into smaller fragments, or depolymerization of subunits from the filament ends. Indirect evidence for actin and amyloid filament fragmentation has been reported, although the phenomenon has never been directly observed either experimentally or in simulations. Here we report the direct observation of filament depolymerization and breakup in a minimal, calibrated model of coarse-grained molecular simulation. We quantify the orders of magnitude by which the depolymerization rate from the filament ends $k_\mathrm{off}$ is larger than fragmentation rate $k_{-}$ and establish the law $k_\mathrm{off}/k_- = \exp [( \varepsilon_\| - \varepsilon_\bot) / k_\mathrm{B}T ] = \exp [0.5 \varepsilon / k_\mathrm{B}T ]$, which accounts for the topology and energy of bonds holding the filament together. This mechanism and the order-of-magnitude predictions are well supported by direct experimental measurements of depolymerization of insulin amyloid filaments.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2016arXiv
Local inversion-symmetry breaking controls the boson peak in glasses and crystals
It is well known that amorphous solids display a phonon spectrum where the Debye $\sim ω^2$ law at low frequency melds into an anomalous excess-mode peak (the boson peak) before entering a quasi-localized regime at higher frequencies dominated by scattering. The microscopic origin of the boson peak has remained elusive despite various attempts to put it in a clear connection with structural disorder at the atomic/molecular level. Using numerical calculations on model systems, we show that the microscopic origin of the boson peak is directly controlled by the local breaking of center-inversion symmetry. In particular, we find that both the boson peak and the nonaffine softening of the material display a strong positive correlation with a new order parameter describing the local inversion symmetry of the lattice. The standard bond-orientational order parameter, instead, is shown to be a poor correlator and cannot explain the boson peak in randomly-cut crystals with perfect bond-orientational order. Our results bring a unifying understanding of the boson peak anomaly for model glasses and defective crystals in terms of a universal local symmetry-breaking principle of the lattice.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2016arXiv
Local structure controls shear and bulk moduli in disordered solids
Paradigmatic model systems, which are used to study the mechanical response of matter, are random networks of point-atoms, random sphere packings, or simple crystal lattices, all of these models assume central-force interactions between particles/atoms. Each of these models differs in the spatial arrangement and the correlations among particles. In turn, this is reflected in the widely different behaviours of the shear (G) and compression (K) elastic moduli. The relation between the macroscopic elasticity as encoded in G, K and their ratio, and the microscopic lattice structure/order, is not understood. We provide a quantitative analytical connection between the local orientational order and the elasticity in model amorphous solids with different internal microstructure, focusing on the two opposite limits of packings (strong excluded-volume) and networks (no excluded-volume). The theory predicts that, in packings, the local orientational order due to excluded-volume causes less nonaffinity (less softness or larger stiffness) under compression than under shear. This leads to lower values of G/K, a well-documented phenomenon which was lacking a microscopic explanation. The theory also provides an excellent one-parameter description of the elasticity of compressed emulsions in comparison with experimental data over a broad range of packing fractions.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2016arXiv
Reversibility and hysteresis of the sharp yielding transition of a colloidal glass under oscillatory shear
The mechanical response of glasses remains challenging to understand. Recent results indicate that the oscillatory rheology of soft glasses is accompanied by a sharp non-equilibrium transition in the microscopic dynamics. Here, we use simultaneous x-ray scattering and rheology to investigate the reversibility and hysteresis of the sharp sharp symmetry change from anisotropic solid to isotropic liquid dynamics observed in the oscillatory shear of colloidal glasses [D. V. Denisov, M. T. Dang, B. Struth, A. Zaccone, and P. Schall, Sci. Rep. 5, 14359 (2015)]. We use strain sweeps with increasing and decreasing strain amplitude to show that, in analogy to equilibrium transitions, this sharp symmetry change is reversible and exhibits systematic frequency-dependent hysteresis. Using the non-affine response formalism of amorphous solids, we show that these hysteresis effects arise from frequency-dependent non-affine structural cage rearrangements at large strain. These results consolidate the first-order like nature of the oscillatory shear transition and quantify related hysteresis effects both via measurements and theoretical modelling.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2015arXiv
Fragmentation and depolymerization of non-covalently bonded filaments
Protein molecules often self-assemble by means of non-covalent physical bonds to form extended filaments, such as amyloids, F-actin, intermediate filaments, and many others. The kinetics of filament growth is limited by the disassembly rate, at which inter-protein bonds break due to the thermal motion. Existing models often assume that the thermal dissociation of subunits occurs uniformly along the filament, or even preferentially in the middle, while the well-known propensity of F-actin to depolymerize from one end is mediated by biochemical factors. Here, we show for a very general (and generic) model, using Brownian dynamics simulations and theory, that the breakup location along the filament is strongly controlled by the asymmetry of the binding force about the minimum, as well as by the bending stiffness of the filament. We provide the basic connection between the features of the interaction potential between subunits and the breakup topology. With central-force (that is, fully flexible) bonds, the breakup rate is always maximum in the middle of the chain, whereas for semiflexible or stiff filaments this rate is either a minimum in the middle or flat. The emerging framework provides a unifying understanding of biopolymer fragmentation and depolymerization and recovers earlier results in its different limits.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2015arXiv
Free energy of sheared colloidal glasses
We develop a free energy framework to describe the response of glasses to applied stress. Unlike crystals, for which the free energy increases quadratically with strain due to affine displacements, for glasses, the nonequilibrium free energy decreases due to complex interplay of non-affine displacements and dissipation. We measure this free energy directly in strained colloidal glasses, and use mean-field theory to relate it to affine and nonaffine displacements. Nonaffine displacements grow with applied shear due to shear-induced loss of structural connectivity. Our mean-field model allows for the first time to disentangle the complex contributions of affine and nonaffine displacements and dissipation in the transient deformation of glasses.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2015arXiv
Non-equilibrium first order transition marks the mechanical failure of glasses
Glasses acquire their solid-like properties by cooling from the supercooled liquid via a continuous transition known as the glass transition. Recent research on soft glasses indicates that besides temperature, another route to liquify glasses is by application of stress that forces relaxation and flow. Here we provide experimental evidence that the stress-induced onset of flow of glasses occurs via a sharp first order-like transition. Using simultaneous x-ray scattering during the oscillatory rheology of a colloidal glass, we identify a sharp symmetry change from anisotropic solid to isotropic liquid structure at the transition from the linear to the nonlinear regime. Concomitantly, intensity fluctuations sharply acquire liquid distributions. These observations identify the yielding of glasses to increasing stress as sharp affine-to-nonaffine transition, providing a new conceptual paradigm of the yielding of this technologically important class of materials, and offering new perspectives on the glass transition.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access
preprint2014arXiv
Microscopic origin of nonlinear non-affine deformation and stress overshoot in bulk metallic glasses
The atomic theory of elasticity of amorphous solids, based on the nonaffine response formalism, is extended into the nonlinear stress-strain regime by coupling with the underlying irreversible many-body dynamics. The latter is implemented in compact analytical form using a qualitative method for the many-body Smoluchowski equation. The resulting nonlinear stress-strain (constitutive) relation is very simple, with few fitting parameters, yet contains all the microscopic physics. The theory is successfully tested against experimental data on metallic glasses, and it is able to reproduce the ubiquitous feature of stress-strain overshoot upon varying temperature and shear rate. A clear atomic-level interpretation is provided for the stress overshoot, in terms of the competition between the elastic instability caused by nonaffine deformation of the glassy cage and the stress buildup due to viscous dissipation.
0 citations0 reviewsNo code linkedOpen access